Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator and author of Why We Get the Wrong Politicians. She also presents Radio 4’s Week in Westminster.

Is Britain falling out of love with the NHS?

Why is Wes Streeting launching a report that argues the NHS doesn’t need to change its funding model? The Health Secretary gave a speech this morning at the IPPR to mark a new analysis of whether social insurance systems automatically lead to better health outcomes. The answer, according to the report’s authors at least, is that they don’t and that overhauling the funding source of the NHS would not solve its most serious problems.  Its analysis ‘confirms the finding of other studies: no group of health systems systematically outperforms another’, but it is not exactly complimentary of the NHS itself.

A&E is buckling under the mental health crisis

Mental health provision is totally inadequate in this country: we already know that. But you can only really understand quite how badly broken it is by looking at how much other public services are creaking as a result. Take the report today from patient safety watchdog the Health Services Safety Investigations Body (HSSIB), which warns that mental health patients stuck in emergency departments in England are at risk of significant harm because they can currently leave of their own accord, even when staff deem them too sick to be on their own.

Antonia Romeo takes on the civil service

12 min listen

The new cabinet secretary, Antonia Romeo, has published a list of objectives setting out her vision for what the civil service will look like under her. Many have interpreted it as her tightening control over government ... especially since Darren Jones stepped back from his Downing Street role. The path is clear for her to become the Prime Minister’s ‘principal policy adviser’, and to reform the civil service ‘so that it is recognisable for excellence in delivery, innovation and improved productivity’. Is this all just word salad, or is she onto something? James Heale speaks to Isabel Hardman and former Foreign Office diplomat Ameer Kotecha. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Antonia Romeo takes on the civil service

Should we brace for another financial shock?

Britain’s response to the conflict in Iran is dominating Westminster – but is Keir Starmer really keeping the country out of war? After a tense Liaison Committee appearance exposed divisions over defence spending, pressure is also mounting on the government’s economic strategy. With energy prices rising, mortgage products disappearing and fears of inflation returning, how prepared is Labour for the fallout? James Heale speaks to Isabel Hardman and Michael Simmons.

Should we brace for another financial shock?

Has Starmer run into trouble with the defence investment plan?

One of the key rites of passage for all modern prime ministers is losing their temper a little during an exchange with Bernard Jenkin at the liaison committee. It happened to David Cameron, who would go rather pink and say ‘the thing is, BERNARD’ while trying to explain why he hadn’t implemented Jenkin’s committee’s plan on civil service reform. Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak had similar run-ins with the veteran Tory MP. Today, though, Keir Starmer lost his cool even more than the others had previously – and it was on a very telling topic. Jenkin wanted to know why Britain was ‘not on a war footing’ and where the much-delayed defence investment plan was. Starmer told him that ‘we are finalising the investment plan’, and was accused of ‘enormous complacency’.

Will the Covid inquiry teach us anything?

The Covid inquiry has published the third of its ten (ten!) modules today, this time focused on how the healthcare systems of the UK coped with the pandemic. Its key finding is that they only just managed to do so, and ‘on a number of occasions, they teetered on the brink of collapse’. That they did survive was ‘thanks to the almost superhuman efforts of healthcare workers and all the staff who support them’.  The inquiry chair, Heather Hallett, also takes issue with ‘politicians, including the secretary of state for health and social care, Matt Hancock’, who were ‘reluctant to accept that healthcare systems were “overwhelmed” as they chose this to mean total collapse’. She argues that ‘ultimately, in my view, it is a question of semantics.

Is Angela Rayner staging a coup?

11 min listen

Angela Rayner has entered the chat. Last night she gave a speech to Labour members which many are reading as the soft launch of her leadership bid. She told the room that Labour needs to be more ‘bold’ – echoing Gordon Brown as she called for a more left-wing direction. She took aim specifically at Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms, describing them as ‘un-British’. Is she staging a coup? And is she the viable leader that Labour can rally around? Also today, we had PMQs with lots more difficult questions on Mandelson and Iran – who came out on top? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Isabel Hardman and James Heale. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Is Angela Rayner staging a coup?

Starmer doesn’t have a handle on his job as Prime Minister

Keir Starmer had an appalling performance at Prime Minister's Questions today. It was summarised very well later in the session by Conservative MP Andrew Snowden, who told the chamber: Every week the Prime Minister comes here and reads out this pre-scripted nonsense that bears no resemblance to the questions he's actually asked. The leader of the opposition asked him about Peter Mandelson and he answered about the war in Iran. The leader of the opposition asked him about Peter Mandelson again, and he answered with an attack on the shadow justice secretary. He was asked about Mandelson again and talked about protests in London. What is he scared of? What is he hiding?

Is the government right to restrict jury trials?

23 min listen

The government's plan to restrict jury trials passed its first parliamentary hurdle this week. It is one measure, amongst many, in a Bill designed to reduce the huge backlog currently facing the Courts. Labour MP Karl Turner and Danny Shaw, a former adviser, join Isabel Hardman to discuss why they have each come to their own, different conclusion about the merits of the Bill. For Danny, it is a pragmatic yet principled measure that will help mitigate an extreme situation. Karl, for his part, is – as you will hear – ferocious in his opposition, and argues that the evidence simply doesn't back it up. Amongst the debate though, there are moments of agreement – from the state of the justice system, to the government's handling of such a controversial measure.

Is the government right to restrict jury trials?

Starmer should be honest about why he picked Mandelson

15 min listen

This afternoon we have had the first tranche of documents released by the government relating to the process by which Peter Mandelson was chosen to be US ambassador. Whilst we have got a clearer picture on the big question – how much Starmer and the government knew about Mandelson’s association with Epstein – Labour are not out of the woods. Quotes from Jonathan Powell reveal that the vetting process was rushed and that – he thought – they didn’t dig deep enough. There is also the small matter of Peter Mandelson’s request for a payout of over half a million pounds. Oscar Edmondson, Tim Shipman and Isabel Hardman discuss. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Starmer should be honest about why he picked Mandelson

Starmer and Badenoch were like squabbling kids at PMQs

Prime Minister’s Questions today saw a leader under repeated attack for a ‘screeching U-turn’ and their suitability to be Prime Minister called into question. Unusually, though, Keir Starmer was the one making that accusation, rather than being on the receiving end of it. He came to the chamber determined to tell Kemi Badenoch that she had made the wrong call on whether to join the US-Israeli action in Iran and that he, therefore, didn’t need to take lectures from her. Badenoch was, as it happens, not really lecturing Starmer; she just wanted to know whether he was going to go ahead with the planned rise in fuel duty in September.

Is Keir Starmer good in a crisis?

19 min listen

Tim Shipman is joined by Isabel Hardman to discuss the domestic fallout from the conflict in Iran – from oil prices surging past $100 a barrel to renewed pressure on Britain’s cost-of-living crisis. They examine how the rising price of energy could derail Labour’s economic plans, why Rachel Reeves may face difficult choices on fuel duty and support for households, and whether Keir Starmer has the political authority to navigate another economic shock ahead of the May elections.

Is Keir Starmer good in a crisis?

Labour humiliated by Chinese spy arrests

12 min listen

It was a bad tempered PMQs today – Kemi Badenoch attacked Starmer over his involvement, or lack thereof with the Iran conflict. And Starmer hit back at Badenoch over her questions. Not the type of unity you'd want to see on the major foreign policy issue of the day. Also today, three more arrests have been made related to Chinese spy allegations. One of them is the partner of a Labour MP Joani Reid, who has said she is 'not part of' her husbands business activities. James Heale speaks to Tim Shipman and Isabel Hardman.

Labour humiliated by Chinese spy arrests

Badenoch attacks Starmer’s Iran response at PMQs

Kemi Badenoch used Prime Minister’s Questions to accuse the government of being flat-footed in its response to the war in the Middle East. The Tory leader had plenty of material to use, and she did a good job with it: running through why the UK wasn’t allowing the RAF to attack Iranian missile sites, defence spending, the spring statement and Starmer’s own weak position as Prime Minister.

More reviews won’t fix the NHS’s failing maternity services

NHS maternity services are in crisis: everyone knows that. In fact, everyone has known a lot more than that for at least a decade. There have been so many reports highlighting the precise nature of this crisis that the health service and government now have 748 recommendations that they could implement to improve care. Instead of implementing them, though ministers are commissioning more reports, just in case the next one uncovers the thing that everyone else has missed. Baroness Amos’s latest interim report from her own investigation has not managed to uncover that one big thing that would solve the NHS maternity crisis, though it does come close to pointing out the underlying problem that allows all the others to continue.

Badenoch rattles Starmer – but are they as bad as each other?

17 min listen

Megan McElroy unpacks a rowdy PMQs with Tim Shipman and Isabel Hardman. Kemi Badenoch made Keir Starmer uncomfortable over student loans but – at a time when trust in the Conservative brand is low – could some of her rhetoric backfire? Plus, what did they make of the revelation that it was the Speaker of the House Lindsay Hoyle that reported Peter Mandelson to police as a flight risk? Produced by Megan McElroy and Patrick Gibbons.

Badenoch rattles Starmer – but are they as bad as each other?

Badenoch savaged Starmer at PMQs

Kemi Badenoch was on savage form at Prime Minister’s Questions. The leader of the opposition has generally improved her performance in this session, but she has always been particularly good at verbally kicking politicians when they are down. Today, she came out with some brutal lines, including that Labour MPs were saying they were being called 'the paedo defenders party' and that Starmer had '411 MPs and not a single one of them has any imagination'. Starmer by contrast was still waffling on about 'the party of Liz Truss' and complaining that she was 'carping from the sidelines'. Badenoch was vicious when Starmer tried his regular joke about Conservatives defecting to Reform Badenoch's tail was up this lunchtime because she felt she had been leading the debate on student loans.

Why ministers want to talk about Andrew

This afternoon’s Commons debate on Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor was unusual for all kinds of reasons. It was not just that the Speaker had decided that MPs could directly criticise the former Duke of York even though parliamentary convention normally prevents them from discussing the monarchy in the Chamber. It was not even that the government accepted the humble Address motion tabled by the Liberal Democrats calling for the release of the documents relating to Andrew’s appointment as trade envoy. It was also that the minister responding to the debate was able to spend most of his speech criticising someone else, rather than being on the defensive the whole time.

SEND plans: ‘cost-cutting or reform’?

10 min listen

Bridget Phillipson has unveiled Labour’s long-awaited overhaul of the special educational needs and disabilities system – a £4 billion reform designed to rein in spiralling costs and bring order to what MPs across the House describe as a broken model. Ministers insist this is reform, not retrenchment – but with councils under intense financial pressure and families fearful of losing hard-won support, Labour backbenchers are watching closely. Is this a genuine attempt to fix an unsustainable system, or just a cost-cutting exercise? Tim Shipman speaks to Isabel Hardman. Produced by Megan McElroy and Oscar Edmondson.

SEND plans: 'cost-cutting or reform'?

Keir Starmer doesn’t know how close his government is to collapse

Today’s unemployment figures aren’t just a reminder of the mess the government has made of the jobs market with its national insurance hikes. They also underline the futility of the government more generally. It has moved into survival mode and cannot pursue the welfare reforms that are clearly necessary. As Ben Miller sets out here, there are more factors than just the NI increase at play here, with weak growth and the rise of AI hitting young people being just two. A healthy government would be able to respond to the challenges for employers and those out of work. One stuck in survival mode cannot. Keir Starmer has long lost the trust of his backbenchers to be able to carry out any kind of meaningful welfare reform that goes beyond pots of money to ‘expand opportunities’.