Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator and author of Why We Get the Wrong Politicians. She also presents Radio 4’s Week in Westminster.

Andy’s care plan

From our UK edition

It's Wednesday, which means there's another announcement from Downing Street. Yes, another one. Today, Andy Burnham is talking social care, and this time, he wants to build a 'cross-party consensus' to fix the broken system. Unfortunately neither Kemi Badenoch nor Sir Ed Davey were able to attend in person, but in a far more successful assemblage, James Heale, Tim Shipman, and Isabel Hardman have come together to talk over the details of what was announced. Tim also assesses what direction the new PM may be heading in over assisted dying legislation. You can read Isabel's piece on Andy's social care plans here Produced by Henry Lloyd and Ed Parker.

Andy's Care Plan

Burnham won’t reform social care with ‘cross-party consensus’

From our UK edition

Does Andy Burnham really believe that cross-party consensus is going to resolve the decades-long stalemate on the funding of adult social care? Of course he doesn't, not least because he wouldn't be giving a speech about it this morning: he would have succeeded back in 2009 when he made his first set of proposals on the matter. The new prime minister is probably the figure who bears the greatest scars on their back out of everyone who has attempted to reform social care – and that includes people who've been plugging away at this without much reward, such as the economist Andrew Dilnot.

Burnham must also tackle the quality of Britain’s social care

From our UK edition

Andy Burnham knows that ‘fixing’ social care will drain political capital away from him faster than a teenager emptying their parents’ bank account. At the moment, he is clearly more focused on funding mechanisms to put the sector on a sustainable footing and the way in which it will or won’t be enmeshed with the NHS. But there’s another longer-term drain on his – or any future prime minister's – capital too, which is the quality of care that’s available. The debate has understandably been focused on the financial aspect, but, for a long time, we have not had an open discussion of what adult social care should actually be like for the people in the system.

Anas Sarwar’s peerage is hardly a surprise

From our UK edition

To the surprise of very few in Scottish politics, bar apparently himself, Anas Sarwar is stepping down as leader of the Scottish Labour party to take up a peerage and serve as a minister in Andy Burnham's government. Sarwar had ruled out this prospect himself during the Holyrood election campaign, but now that he's past the painful result that Labour got in May, he's off for the new life he said he didn't want.  Sarwar was, of course, the first senior Labour figure to call for Keir Starmer to step down – he held a press conference back in February telling the then prime minister that 'the distraction needs to end, and the leadership in Downing Street needs to change'.

Does Burnham really know how to change Britain?

From our UK edition

Andy Burnham told his Cabinet this morning that they need to give people a ‘sense that help is coming’. He was largely focused on the cost of living as he addressed ministers, but one of his other big themes in the past 24 hours since taking over as prime minister has been moving power out of Westminster and ‘into every postcode in the land’. It’s the kind of pitch that most new PMs make before they start to realise the limits of their own power, and wonder whether they want to let go of any more of it in the way they’d initially suggested. Burnham is coming into government at a time when the British state seems pretty powerless.

Yvette Cooper is a left-field pick for Health Secretary

From our UK edition

What does Yvette Cooper as Health Secretary mean for the NHS? It's a question no one thought to ask before today, which underlines why her appointment is quite left-field. Cooper does have experience: she was a junior minister in the health department back in the very early days of the Blair government and was part of the team that implemented the Sure Start programme. But it's been a while since those days, and Cooper hasn't talked that much about health since. Like her new boss, Cooper pledged to integrate health and social care when she and Andy Burnham were candidates in the 2015 Labour leadership election. Beyond that, we just have to go on how she has conducted herself as a minister.

No, we don’t need a better tone at PMQs

From our UK edition

Keir Starmer has been quite an irritable – and irritating at times – performer in the Commons as prime minister. His sessions with Kemi Badenoch in particular have been marked by pompous lectures about how she should be conducting Prime Minister's Questions, along with lofty comments about the ‘spirit in which’ the opposition has been behaving. Starmer hasn't seen anything wrong with this attitude because he made the fatal mistake early on of buying his own hype about what a committed and decent public servant he is, rather than being anxious about whether he was actually meeting his own standards. This means that he seems genuinely appalled by any question that suggests he is in fact not meeting those standards.

It wasn’t all cosy at Starmer’s final PMQs

From our UK edition

It's difficult for an outgoing Prime Minister to mess up their valedictory PMQs: there is always more goodwill in the Chamber on those occasions than at any other time in the parliamentary calendar. Keir Starmer managed a dignified and emotional departure today, and was helped along by an upbeat and relatively friendly Kemi Badenoch, who alternated between jokes and comments that came painfully close to being compliments.

Burnham’s HR whips department won’t work

From our UK edition

Now that he’s officially the Prime Minister in waiting, Andy Burnham is trying to work out how to stop Labour MPs from turning against him in the same way they turned against Keir Starmer. He’s got a letter from nearly 80 backbenchers calling on him to ‘refresh’ the party’s immigration policy, and he has already apologised for the party’s stance on Gaza. Burnham said yesterday: ‘I know many people feel that at the start of Israel’s military action in Gaza my party didn’t get it right and I am sorry about that. The response has too often not been good enough. We need to do better.

The most appalling thing about the NHS maternity scandal

From our UK edition

By the end of this year, Britain will have had (at least) seven prime ministers in the past decade – and more than 700 recommendations on how to stop the ongoing scandal in NHS maternity services. None of which have – as yet – been implemented. The Ockenden review into maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, which was published on Wednesday, adds nearly 100 more. There are many harrowing stories in the report. But one of the most telling is about what was going on above the wards Its findings are appalling and yet familiar, which Donna Ockenden, a senior midwife, knows better than most, given this is the third review she has published on NHS hospitals failing mothers and babies.

Kemi Badenoch’s victory lap

From our UK edition

14 min listen

Supercharged by a by-election victory in Aberdeen South and Starmer’s resignation, Kemi Badenoch delivered a drive-by at PMQs today. She took aim at members of Starmer’s cabinet in succession: Rachel Reeves, Ed Miliband and Bridget Phillipson. Starmer’s line is that he is handing over the country in a better position than he found it; Badenoch’s is that, if it is all going so well, why is he resigning? She has a point. She also highlighted the spectacle of many in Starmer’s government posing for a photo with Andy Burnham on his return to Westminster yesterday. The Prime Minister should feel ‘betrayed’, she said. Again, she has a point. Is this Badenoch at her best? And how will she fare against Burnham? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Isabel Hardman and Noa Hoffman.

Kemi Badenoch’s victory lap

Did Kemi Badenoch take the personal jibes too far at PMQs?

From our UK edition

Keir Starmer came to PMQs wearing that look of post-resignation relief that we’ve grown all too used to seeing on a prime minister’s face over the past decade. He had to deal with a particularly brutal Kemi Badenoch today, though the full force of the Leader of the Opposition’s attacks was largely directed at Starmer’s cabinet, rather than him. Reeves appeared close to tears as Starmer replied with a full tribute to her Badenoch first congratulated the Prime Minister on his party’s by-election win, but then added jokingly that she suspected he would be less happy with his new MP than she was with hers.

Starmer’s tears show why he failed as PM

From our UK edition

Keir Starmer looked visibly emotional as he walked up to the lectern in Downing Street this morning. The Prime Minister then held it together for the majority of his resignation speech – until the very end where he paid tribute to his ‘fantastic wife Vic’ and his ‘beautiful children who are my pride and joy’. It’s difficult for Starmer to say that he led with good grace It’s not unusual for anyone to grow emotional while talking about their family, but it was quite telling that this was the only point where Starmer visibly struggled: even those who have worked closely with him have struggled to work out what really animates him beyond family and football.

Was Brexit worth it – and can Burnham save Britain?

From our UK edition

55 min listen

For this week’s Edition, William Moore is joined by the Spectator’s assistant editor Isabel Hardman and the editor of The New Statesman Tom McTague. Plus, in a special episode this week, the Spectator’s economics editor Michael Simmons joins for the first half of the episode, before political editor Tim Shipman jumps in later on. This week: was Brexit worth it? As we approach the tenth anniversary of the vote to leave the European Union, the Spectator’s editor – and former prominent Vote Leave campaigner – Michael Gove makes the case that not only was Britain right to leave, but it has benefitted from leaving. The past decade however has been marked by domestic political chaos, so to what extent was Brexit a symptom or a cause of Britain’s structural problems?

Was Brexit worth it – and can Burnham save Britain?

How quickly could Starmer be deposed?

From our UK edition

16 min listen

Voters head to the polls tomorrow in Makerfield for what could be the most consequential by-election in modern British history. If Andy Burnham wins by a significant margin, he will be heralded as the man Labour need to beat Reform nationally – and Starmer could be forced out within days. Yet the Prime Minister has come out fighting, warning Burnham that now is not the time for a challenge. What should we expect from what promises to be a febrile 72 hours in British politics? Will Starmer’s deposition be conducted with decorum, or will it descend into a bloodbath? Plus: with Keir Starmer travelling back from the G7 today, parliament saw Deputy Prime Minister’s Questions.

How quickly could Starmer be deposed?

David Lammy’s heart wasn’t in DPMQs

From our UK edition

Claire Coutinho emerged as the Tory frontbencher taking deputy prime minister’s questions today, with the shadow energy secretary focusing on oil and gas licences and cabinet dysfunction. Those two topics are more closely related this week than usual: Coutinho wanted to exploit the report that Ed Miliband had ‘ghosted’ Keir Starmer when the Prime Minister was trying to get him to accept a cut to his departmental budget. She was also keen to talk about North Sea exploration, given tomorrow is the Aberdeen South by-election. Lammy had been well prepared for these questions, but didn’t seem particularly passionate or personally invested in them David Lammy, standing in for Starmer, was ready for the ghosting story, responding to it even before Coutinho had raised it.

Will Burnham avoid the Starmer trap?

From our UK edition

Voters in Makerfield haven’t even gone to the polling stations, but already the Labour leadership contest is well into a detailed exposition of what Andy Burnham – rather than any of the other contenders – might do. A few ‘star’ new MPs had been promoted straight into government, but the rest hadn’t had an invite to Downing Street Defence spending, welfare cuts, social care, immigration and the EU are all matters Burnham has pronounced on – and then changed his stance. The problem with WWAD (What Would Andy Do?), as the bracelets for Labour’s messiah might read, is that the answer really depends on the weather.

A&E is broken. Can anyone fix it?

From our UK edition

‘Corridor care’ should be an oxymoron, but is instead such a feature of the NHS now that nearly 3,000 people a day found themselves being treated in corridors, cupboards or even car parks last month. New figures show that 2,241 patients a day on average who had corridor care while in A&E, with a further 669 being cared for in cupboards, toilets and car parks. These are the latest official figures which show how the NHS isn’t working – but earlier in the week the Royal College of Emergency Medicine came up with its own estimate of how many people were dying unnecessarily as a result of long A&E waits: 1,300 a month.

Kemi Badenoch’s remarkable turnaround

From our UK edition

18 min listen

For the second week in a row, PMQs comes in light of a disturbing instance of violent crime. Last week, ministers were recoiling at the shocking bodycam footage from Henry Novak’s murder, and this week comes in the context of a knife attack by a Sudanese asylum seeker in Belfast. Kemi Badenoch was impressive again, not just in condemning the Belfast violence but also pressing the PM on the much-delayed defence investment plan. She seems to have completed a remarkable turnaround in her fortunes: she’s polling well, looks much more assured and is taking the fight to Labour and Reform. As she starts to win over the party and the commentariat, can she win over the country? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Tim Shipman and Isabel Hardman. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Kemi Badenoch's remarkable turnaround

Keir Starmer’s weakness was on display at PMQs

From our UK edition

Prime Minister’s Questions today was ostensibly about the Defence Investment Plan – or its absence. But Kemi Badenoch was really using the DIP in her six questions to build her narrative about Keir Starmer being unable to take any of the big decisions. He was, she said repeatedly, ‘paralysed’.  The Prime Minister, who loves to lecture other politicians on how they should conduct themselves, also very much enjoys telling the same politicians that he will be taking no lectures from them Given Starmer refused in all of those questions to give any further details about the DIP other than that it would be coming ‘before the Nato summit’ at the start of July, Badenoch could have ended up looking like she was just churning through the same question without making progress.