World

Russell Brand has become an excuse for British censorship

When in doubt, demand more censorship of the internet. This appears to be the closest thing the ruling British Labour party has to a governing philosophy, as its latest row with Google over Russell Brand’s YouTube account would attest. The state has no right to demand tech companies take down perfectly legal content Brand is now a convicted rapist. Few beyond his conspiratorial fanboys doubt his guilt. But he continues to insist he is innocent – as does his wife, whose decision to read out a disturbingly jokey statement from Brand in a YouTube video has enraged the government.

Shenzhen was kabuki theater

Vladimir Putin did not get to carve up the world at today’s historic summit in Shenzhen with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping. But he got the next best thing, which was a photo opportunity. Plus, warm words of friendship from Donald Trump. And from the Chinese side, the validation that Xi still values the two inheritances of Cold War superpower status that Russia has hung on to – a large nuclear arsenal and a permanent seat at the UN’s Security Council.  Best of all for Putin – and most shocking to Trump’s critics – was the moment when Trump called Putin “my friend” and promised that they would do “a lot of wonderful things” together.

shenzhen

A job well done for Putin in Shenzhen

He may not have got a hug on the tarmac from Xi Jinping, but it’s been a good APEC summit in Shenzhen for Vladimir Putin nonetheless. Of course, the optics were always going to be good, with the trilateral meeting between Putin, Xi and Donald Trump elevating the Russian president to the same status as his superpower interlocutors. No wonder it has been hyped in the domestic media for days, even as they (rightly) downplayed the idea that this was ever going to be a “Yalta 2.0” dividing up the globe. It is, however, about more than just optics. The Russians were not expecting any concrete agreements to emerge from the event but hoped to be able to accomplish three things. First of all, keep the Donald onside.

Ukraine

Ukraine is much weaker without access to Starlink

The full-scale war in Ukraine began with fast, armored advances that covered hundreds of miles in weeks. Then drones began finding tanks and other vehicles in their hideouts, destroying them before offensives could get going. By 2024, both sides had largely given up on armored warfare. A 19-mile-wide “kill zone” now straddles the front line, with drones spotting and striking anything that moves. The front line has barely shifted. Ukraine recently found a way to get tanks back into the fight, raising the prospect of a new phase in the conflict. But those innovative tactics could be under threat, following interruptions to Ukraine’s use of the Starlink satellite network.

ukraine

Ukrainians are struggling to keep going

Each time I fly back to Odesa, my hometown, to see my family, I notice how things have changed since my last visit to Ukraine. Which is to say, how much worse they have become. Take the bombing raids, which used to happen only at night. Now they take place in the daytime as well and have grown much more violent and unpredictable. The Russians send over a cocktail of drones, ballistic missiles and guided aerial bombs. You never know where they’ll hit – residential buildings, shopping centers, pharmacies, trains, you name it (“Russian Roulette” is the new, blackly comic Ukrainian name for it). The war, all the time, is getting closer to you and your loved ones. It used to be happening in another part of your region. Then in another area of your city.

The UN is no longer a forum for international peace

Should Russia’s aggressive war on Ukraine, with its accompanying litany of horrific human rights abuses, disqualify it from a seat on the United Nations’ Security Council (UNSC)? That’s what Poland’s feisty foreign minister Radek Sikorski called for yesterday in New York. The UNSC was meant to be a "guardian of peace, not to give immunity to aggressors" like Russia, Sikorski told Polish television. More, he called the legal basis for Russia’s permanent seat at the Security Council table – with its accompanying veto over all resolutions – "questionable" because Moscow took over the USSR’s old seat without a vote.  In moral terms, Sikorski has a point – and it’s one that the Ukrainians have been pushing for a while.

Israel

Can Netanyahu cling on?

Israel looks set for a lengthy period of back-room deals, coalition negotiations and potential political instability after neither of the two main camps won a clear victory in Tuesday’s election, despite a record turnout. Partial results at 8 a.m. Israeli time on Wednesday, with 57.3 percent of the votes counted, gave Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing Likud 27 seats, with 21 for Gadi Eisenkot’s center-right Yashar, reported the Times of Israel. Both sides fall short of the 61 seats needed to form a governing coalition in Israel’s 120 seat parliament Yashar’s “Change bloc” allies are the center-right Beyachad, the center-left Democrats and the right-wing Yisrael Beiteinu.

Can Netanyahu win again?

Next Tuesday, Israel holds elections for the first time since the appalling attacks of October 7, 2023. After such a sadistic onslaught, which happened on Benjamin Netanyahu’s watch, many pundits predicted his political days were numbered (though it’s worth noting that neither Roosevelt nor George W. Bush were expected to resign after Pearl Harbor and 9/11 respectively – indeed both were subsequently re-elected.) But Israel is tiny, and in per-capita terms, the loss of life on October 7 was 12 times worse than 9/11 was for the US; 89 times worse than the Bataclan massacre in Paris, 140 times worse than 7/7 in London.

netanyahu

The man who could topple Benjamin Netanyahu

The year is 2019 and, after almost a full term in office, Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition government of right-wing and religious parties heads to a general election. Opposing him is a former IDF chief of staff heading a new centrist party which quickly soars in the polls, making him the main challenger for prime minister. That challenger was Benny Gantz. Gantz formed alliances, fought elections and got caught up in the paralysis of Israel’s 2019-20 governing crisis in which nobody was able to form a coalition. Facing the threat of the Covid-19 pandemic, Gantz agreed to a deal with Netanyahu where they’d take turns at being prime minister – with Netanyahu going first, of course. Nobody except Gantz believed his turn would come.

America

Europe

Michel Houellebecq and the tyranny of Islamist sensitivity

They’re coming for Michel Houellebecq again. The rumpled, chain-smoking laureate of misery is once more in the crosshairs of the French state for causing offense. I’ll give you one guess who he’s offended. That’s right: Muslims. Islam really has become the premier snowflake religion, a faith so exquisitely fragile that even a grumpy novelist puffing on a Gauloise in a Parisian cafe can give its clerics a fit of the vapors. If a faith cannot survive a mordant Frenchman calling it silly without going crying to the courts, then the problem is the faith, not those who mock it Houellebecq has been formally charged by a judge in Nanterre, near Paris, for comments he made in 2022.

Terror at the gates: the dangers of Shabana Mahmood’s new asylum scheme

In the Aeneid, after the purported departure of the Greeks, the Trojans find two things left behind: a great wooden horse and a Greek soldier named Sinon. Sinon is brought before King Priam of Troy. He tells an emotive story about being persecuted at the hands of his enemies while imploring the Trojans to accept the wooden horse into the city, promising that it is a gift from Minerva. Priam is so moved by Sinon’s story that he tells him: “Whoever you are, forget the Greeks lost to you, you’ll be one of us.” That night, now unchained and trusted to walk the city, Sinon opens the wooden horse and out comes a group of hardened soldiers, who set about burning and razing his supposed sanctuary.

Britain’s prison early release scheme is already a disaster

Four days after he was released from HMP Wandsworth, Michael Bogle was back inside. The 38-year-old had served 11 of 32 weeks in prison for stealing before he was freed last month via the government’s early release program. He strolled out of jail, told reporters he would “hopefully not” shoplift again, then stole from a Sainsbury’s a few hours later. The early release program was meant to increase prison capacity. But it isn’t working. Since it began two years ago, 80,000 people have been freed, yet there are just 1,000 extra prison spaces. Last week, the Ministry of Justice revealed that more offenders were recalled to jail in the first half of this year (25,531) than were let out (25,255).

prison

Who really triumphed at the ‘tri-lat?’

Big international summits tend to be flat affairs in terms of newslines – even when you throw in the dangerously powerful combination of Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. And this week’s "tri-lat" between the leaders of the US, China and Russia in Shenzhen didn’t exactly throw up endless surprises. As expected, the presidents talked about nuclear proliferation and arms control – which was admittedly something new for the Chinese Communist party. Beijing has a mere 600 nuclear warheads, compared with roughly 5,000 each for Russia and the United States, and China has never been part of the New START treaty framework.

Au revoir to French

A couple of weeks ago, in the autumn sun of the High Atlas, I trekked from the Kasbah du Toubkal down into Morocco’s Azzaden Valley. It is an exhilarating landscape – smoky old villages and green walnut orchards, surrounded by snow-dusted peaks. Arguably, it is best appreciated on a roof terrace with a steaming pot of tagine, so that’s where I put myself. Between spicy mouthfuls, I asked my young Amazigh (Berber) mountain guide whether he spoke much French to his clients. He looked at me as though I had asked whether he traveled to Marrakech by penny farthing. “No one learns French any more,” he spat, in triumphant, self-taught English. The venom in his voice startled me, though it shouldn’t have.

Putin will not get his Yalta moment

This week was to be the crowning moment of Vladimir Putin’s career. After decades of cosplaying a superpower leader, Putin would at last sit down at history’s first-ever three-way summit between Russia, China and the US, to be held in Shenzhen on Thursday. The Russian press has been excitedly talking of the summit as a new Yalta – echoing the 1945 summit where Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill sat down to carve out a new map of Europe out of the ruins of the Nazi empire.  The smoldering ruins of the Kerch Bridge confirm that Putin’s outsize self-image rests on a rotten foundation Alas for Putin, Kyiv chose this very week to finally blow up the great vanity project that had stood as the symbol of Russia’s new imperial might.

Who owns Charles de Gaulle?

More than a half century after his death, Charles de Gaulle is making a surprising comeback. Last Saturday, the ambitious two-part biopic about General de Gaulle’s wartime heroism received a seven-minute standing ovation at its American première in Los Angeles. Here in France, presidential candidates are boldly proclaiming their Gaullist values and vision for a nation plunged in crisis. Evoking Charles de Gaulle’s legacy is a winning electoral strategy.   Meanwhile, the great man’s beloved country house, La Boisserie, has sadly fallen into disrepair and its future remains uncertain. Charles de Gaulle’s heirs are engaged in an acrimonious family feud over the ownership and fate of the famous residence in Colombey-les-Deux-Églises, about 120 miles south-east of Paris.

Is this the reason for Europe’s latest migrant crisis?

Spain goes to the polls in a fortnight and Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez is struggling to win over voters. His Socialist party is trailing the conservative People’s party in opinion polls with the right-wing Vox in third place and projected to win more than 70 seats in parliament. “Every generation has its own struggle – for us, that struggle is housing,” said Sanchez at a recent rally. It’s not just a housing crisis that has hurt Sanchez’s Premiership. The anger that earlier this month brought 120,000 demonstrators onto the Madrid streets also stems from his failure to control Spain’s borders.

Why the West gets Poland wrong

Another dismal gun massacre swung the bright but brief searchlights of news toward Poland a fortnight  ago. I could write a whole separate article on these rather frequent murders and the foolish attempts to claim they are political when they usually aren’t. But my point is different. Much more important things are happening in Poland and nobody in Britain pays much attention. The country is locked in a dispute between parties and ideologies which lays bare a new (or more accurately, restored) political dynamic of historic significance. This conflict led Poland’s president recently to abort a foreign trip midflight, in order to return home and storm through police lines into a courthouse to protest at what the government of his own country was upto.

Jensen Huang is impossible to replace at Nvidia

At least Jensen Huang, the founder of the chip-making giant Nvidia, will have more time to devote to his tangled love life. After news emerged of his second affair, this time with a senior company employee, to add to the alleged Chinese “honeytrap” agent, the board clearly felt it had no choice but to replace him. Instead of waiting to be pushed, Huang did the honorable thing and resigned. There was probably no other way out of the mess. Even so, no one should kid themselves that this has fixed anything – because it will be impossible to find another CEO as talented as the one Nvidia has just lost.

jensen huang

Why do western leaders pay so little attention to Christian persecution?

A Nigerian woman who watched Boko Haram militants kill her husband after he identified himself as a Christian will be joining a delegation today delivering a petition with over one million signatories to 10 Downing Street. The letter is calling for “greater protection for Christian communities in sub-Saharan Africa, justice for victims and help for survivors rebuilding their lives.” The men asked her husband whether he was Muslim or an infidel. He replied that he was neither, but a Christian In October 2014, Afordia and her husband were traveling by car in Adamawa State, in north-east Nigeria, when men in uniform stopped them. The couple initially mistook the men for Nigerian soldiers before armed men emerged from hiding and ordered them out of the vehicle.

Can the Republicans avert a disastrous intra-party feud?

No sooner had Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth dodged an impeachment inquiry by Congress than he ended up in a fresh kerfuffle. First, Republicans had refused to vote for Representative Thomas Massie’s resolution on Tuesday night, while insufficient numbers of Democrats showed up to support it. Yesterday was Veterans’ Day. To mark it, Hegseth visited the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier at Arlington National Cemetery together with his wife and several chums. A video released by CNN showed his entourage chatting and laughing until a US Army sentinel reprimanded them, shouting, “All visitors will maintain an atmosphere of respect and silence at all times!

Illustration

The too-cozy arrangement between Donald Trump and Nvidia

Jensen Huang has been removed from his position as CEO of Nvidia, the corporate giant that sells the chips the United States counts on to beat China in the artificial intelligence race. American intelligence agencies, the New York Times reported, determined that a woman close to Huang had been recruited by China’s spy agency, the Ministry of State Security, to collect intelligence on him. Officials who saw the intelligence believed the two were having an affair. She also worked for one of his company’s biggest customers in Asia. Alice Huang was an executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore company that rents out the use of Nvidia’s AI chips to Chinese firms. Its Malaysian affiliate bought at least $4.

fake breasts

Would you pass the ‘fake breasts’ test?

I am considering sticking on a pair of prosthetic breasts and applying for a job at Oxford University. The Spectator paying what it does, all of us columnists must have a side-hustle of sorts. Perhaps this could be mine. The thought is inspired by the emergence into the news of Matt Rattley, a lecturer in biochemistry at St. Hilda’s College, Oxford. I know it is unkind to attack people for their looks, so allow me to describe Rattley’s appearance in as neutral a manner as possible. Rattley is clearly a man – or to put it in the language of our time, he is someone who was “assigned male at birth.

Is Britain still safe for America’s armed forces?

The episode at RAF Fairford in September, when five men were arrested near the perimeter of the airbase, initially on suspicion of offenses under the Explosives Act 1875 and the Terrorism Act 2005, remains mysterious. All five were released on bail the following day, as were two more people arrested later. Prime Minister Andy Burnham said there were, “strong indications that Iran played a part in what happened.” The Iranian embassy in London denied any involvement (but they would say that, wouldn’t they). It is still unclear exactly what did happen.

forces

Raheem Kassam takes the National Pulse international

Nigel Farage has often talked about spotting and exploiting gaps in the market. So it is no surprise that one of his former aides is now doing the same. Step forward Raheem Kassam, the bomb-throwing onetime UKIP-per, who has made a name for himself in the US as the co-owner of Butterworths, a favorite hangout of "MAGA" in Washington DC. Word reaches Cockburn that Kassam is pitching up in London more frequently these days and intends to become a fixture of the media landscape for the foreseeable future. Get the smelling salts in... Kassam is expected to launch a new UK version of his site, the National Pulse. In the mid-2010s, Kassam edited the old Breitbart London site that was a favorite of right-wingers in Britain.

Thomas Markle

Does Thomas Markle deserve the death penalty?

There are many crimes that Thomas Markle may or may not be guilty of, specifically involving the possession of child abuse material, but not everyone would go quite as far as the Florida congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna. She posted on X that “I am calling for Thomas Markle to receive [sic] the Death Penalty. Agents seized items from his LA storage units including film negatives showing him (ID'd by a longtime witness) with a nude prepubescent girl, one involving apparent genital contact, plus other images of him with children in various stages of undress.” She concluded, at the end of her bloodthirsty tweet, “He is a sick human.”  Luna, admittedly, has form in such eye-catching (and frankly preposterous) statements.

Will the Abu Dhabi talks lead to peace in Ukraine?

Is Vladimir Putin serious about ending his war on Ukraine? Or are the peace talks that began today in Abu Dhabi just a cynical smokescreen to buy time while Russian forces kick Ukraine’s cities to pieces?   Early readouts from both sides suggest at least three new initiatives that make these talks difference from previous fruitless sit-downs between Russia, Ukraine and the US. One is a reframing of the conflict’s solution away from just Ukraine to take in the bigger picture of what the Kremlin calls the “security architecture of Europe.” Translated, that persistent Kremlin demand means the creation of an effective Russian sphere of influence beyond its borders into which NATO and its forces cannot step.

abu dhabi peace ukraine

Trump’s midterm disaster: what went wrong?

22 min listen

Freddy Gray breaks down a catastrophic midterm defeat for Donald Trump's Republican party alongside guests Jacob Heilbrunn and Andrew Day, who argue that public fury over a disastrous, inflation-fueling war with Iran decisively shattered Trump’s 2024 coalition, exposed his administration's erratic focus and flawed candidate endorsements, and triggered a major generational reckoning that severely damages J.D. Vance’s political standing while creating openings for figures like Ron DeSantis and Jon Ossoff ahead of 2028. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

The point-scoring over the Krakow shooting has already begun

On Saturday at 2:59 p.m., the first shots rang out of a black Subaru as it drove onto an intersection just before the main square in Kraków, Poland’s second largest city. On CCTV footage, several people can be seen falling to the ground immediately; others start running. The Subaru drives off. Over the ensuing minutes, the Subaru made its way around the main square and through Kraków’s Old Town. It then crashed by a crossroads leading into Kazimierz, Kraków’s old Jewish quarter. The police car chasing it stopped, and two policemen – senior constables Jakub Kulik and Artur Morański – emerged pointing handguns at the driver. A 24-year-old man with a rifle got out of the car and fired at the policemen: one of them was hit once, the other three times.

krakow

Germany’s mainstream parties are on the brink of oblivion

The old Federal Republic of Germany is dead. The two parties that ran the country, founded in 1949, are bleeding support to a surging far right and the Greens and far left, leaving them shadows of their former selves. The Christian Democrats (CDU), who gave Germany chancellors Konrad Adenauer and Helmut Kohl, and the Social Democrats (SPD), the party of Willy Brandt and Helmut Schmidt, are now being threatened with oblivion. For the first time in the post-war era, this September the CDU was tossed out of a state assembly in elections in Mecklenburg-West Pomerania after failing to clear the 5 percent hurdle. The SPD got a lousy 9.3 percent in Saxony-Anhalt's vote on 6 September, which was won by the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) with a landslide 43.8 percent.

How Denmark turned against this horrifying reality show

Posterity has graced Peter Weir’s 1998 film The Truman Show. Its tale of a man who since birth has unwittingly been held captive in a Hollywood soundstage as the subject of a reality TV show was a worldwide commercial hit. Yet it did not massively appeal to the prevailing Hollywood establishment: at the 1999 Oscars, it received best director, supporting actor and screenplay nominations, but nothing for the star performance of its lead, Jim Carrey; and no best picture nomination. (Instead, this was the year the now-incarcerated rapist Harvey Weinstein is said to have spent $5 million on Oscar marketing for the eventual best picture winner, Shakespeare in Love).