Politics

Read about the latest political news, views and analysis

Wednesday

Iain Macwhirter

How the SNP damaged the independence cause

If you really want to annoy a Scottish nationalist, tell them the 2014 Scottish independence referendum had a lot in common with Brexit. Well, what was the battle cry in both cases? It was ‘take back control’. For all its internationalist rhetoric, the Yes campaign was – is – a campaign to erect borders against a union, the United Kingdom, that its advocates say does not serve the nation’s interests. Strip down the Leave campaign and it too was about erecting borders – albeit against a different union, the EU, which was claimed not to serve the nation’s interests. Indeed, historians may come to regard 2014 as the first manifestation of

Oscar Edmondson

Should Labour ditch the ‘doom and gloom’ narrative?

11 min listen

We have some new inflation figures today. Inflation rose 2.2 per cent in the 12 months to August. This is pretty much in line with the Bank of England’s target and should be good news for Labour, so why do they persist with this doom and gloom narrative?  Elsewhere, Labour’s awkward week has got more awkward with the news that Sue Gray, Keir Starmer’s chief of staff, is paid more than him. Surely they could have seen this news story coming?  Oscar Edmondson speaks to Kate Andrews and James Heale. Produced by Oscar Edmondson. 

Steerpike

Sue Gray paid more than the Prime Minister

To Westminster, where more trouble is afoot. It now transpires the Prime Minister is paid less than, er, his own chief of staff. Sue Gray has once again made headlines after the Beeb revealed the former top civil servant has been given a salary of a whopping £170,000 – which is £3,000 more than the man in the top job. How curious… Gray’s wage – higher than that of her Conservative predecessor Lord Booth-Smith, who earned between £140,000 and £145,000 a year – has sparked an uncomfortable row in government, with frustration amongst other advisers who believe they are being underpaid. According to the BBC, a number of staff members

Jonathan Spyer

Pager bombs won’t stop Hezbollah

The killing of 12 people, including several Hezbollah members, and the wounding of thousands more when 5,000 pagers simultaneously exploded in Lebanon yesterday represents an obvious tactical triumph for Israel (or whoever carried it out). The sight of members of the Iran-supported Shia Islamist group suddenly collapsing in agony while performing mundane daily tasks was met with great amusement by the movement’s many enemies across the region. Displaying the somewhat gleeful and malicious humour which characterises all sides in the Levant, a variety of memes mocking the hapless victims of the grim beeper soon proliferated.   Hilarity aside, the operation displays the extent to which Hezbollah has been thoroughly penetrated by its

Paul Wood

The mad, bad, sad world of Ryan Routh 

Any journalist who has covered a war will recognise Ryan Routh’s type immediately – the war zone nutter. Routh is currently all over America’s front pages, accused of trying to assassinate Donald Trump. The photograph used by most news outlets shows a grizzled-looking character with a flak vest, a stars-and-stripes neckerchief, and a troubled stare. Back in 2022, he travelled from his home in the US to Ukraine, shortly after Russia invaded. He ended up in Independence Square in Kiev, setting up an open-air camp adorned with flags and handwritten placards – open air camps with placards being another reliable sign of nutterdom. But then warzones have always attracted the mad,

Steerpike

Salmond blasts Sturgeon ‘failures’ on indyref anniversary

It’s 10 years to the day that those pesky Nats failed to secure independence north of the border – and not much has gone well for the SNP since. The once-formidable duo that was Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon broke down soon after, Salmond was accused of multiple cases of sexual misconduct (of which he was acquitted), and now the former first minister has an ongoing court case against the Scottish government about the handling of the allegations made about him. Meanwhile since Sturgeon stepped down in February 2023, she has been arrested, her husband – once CEO of the party – has been charged with embezzlement, the party has

Ross Clark

The poisoned chalice of trying to nationalise Thames Water

Keir Starmer won the Labour leadership election in 2020 on the back of a promise to nationalise public utilities. In one of his most blatant flip flops, he later went back on that, committing instead only to nationalise the rail industry – and even then by degrees as current franchises reached the end of their lives. But could the Prime Minister find himself driven towards a much broader nationalisation after all, and at high political cost? The question arises because of Thames Water, which has warned it could go bust next year if it is blocked from jacking up customers’ bills to help fill its own £15 billion financial black

Steerpike

Reform voters are ‘our people’, insists Badenoch

How to solve a problem like Reform? The Tories have been scratching their heads on the matter since their rather disastrous election result in July. And yet it appears that the Conservatives are, er, still pretty split on the best way forward. Former Conservative leader John Major has told the Beeb that a move to the right in a bid to reel back Reform voters would be a mistake. He’s not alone, with many of the Tory leadership candidates also having expressed scepticism about a move to the right. James Cleverly has in the past warned his party not to do a ‘counter-productive’ deal with Farage, with GB News even

Euan McColm

The future looks bleak for the SNP

Ten years ago today the Scottish independence referendum took place. The result was a resounding defeat for those who wanted Scotland to break away. The decade since has not been kind to the Scottish nationalist project. It all seemed very different for nationalists on the afternoon of Thursday September 18, 2014 Former SNP leader Alex Salmond, who led the independence campaign, looks a shadow of his former self. Last Saturday, Salmond was ignored by weary shoppers as he addressed a couple of hundred flag-waving supporters in Glasgow’s George Square; meanwhile, current party boss John Swinney gave an interview this week in which he suggested that the independence project’s great hope

Kate Andrews

Labour’s economic doom and gloom doesn’t match reality

Inflation was 2.2 per cent in the 12 months to August, unchanged from the month before, today’s update from the Office for National Statistics reveals. This is ever so slightly above the Bank of England’s target of 2 per cent, but it’s in the ballpark of where it’s supposed to be. And while the Bank expects inflation to rise slightly by the end of the year – to just under 3 per cent – it is due to fall again in 2025 and remain around target for the years to come. These figures are good news for Labour, but they raise question marks over how long the government can continue the

Steerpike

Tom Tugendhat’s criminal blunder

It’s fair to say that the punishment handed out to Huw Edwards has not gone down well. The disgraced BBC newsman was only given a suspended six-month sentence for child abuse image offences, meaning he avoids jail. He will also be placed on the sex offenders’ register for seven years, and undergo rehabilitation. There has been a fierce backlash at the perceived leniency of the sentence. It’s a pretty embarrassing mistake for a former Home Office minister to make In such circumstances, it was only a matter of time before someone tried to make political capital out of the trial. Tory leadership contender Tom Tugendhat has done just that, taking it upon

Arieh Kovler

The Hezbollah pager bomb plot has Israel’s fingerprints all over it

At the end of the 2014 film Kingsman: the Secret Service, the plucky spy hero is in trouble deep in an enemy base. Suddenly his tech wizard figures out that he can hack into the microchips inside the enemies’ heads and make them all explode. The bad guys all go boom. Hezbollah fighters must be asking themselves what other tricks Israel might have up its sleeves On Tuesday night, the spy thriller trope became real. Across Lebanon, Hezbollah operatives’ secure pagers exploded. Security camera footage showed the small explosions in supermarkets and shops, leaving Hezbollah terror operatives bleeding or worse. More than 3,000 people were injured in the hundreds of blasts,

Nigel Jones

Why should we listen to John Major?

Sir John Major has been sounding off. Again. The former Tory prime minister criticised his party’s Rwanda asylum plan as ‘un-Conservative and un-British’. In an interview with the BBC, Major said he thought Rishi Sunak’s plan to send migrants to Africa was ‘odious’: ‘I thought it was…if one dare say in a secular society, un-Christian, and unconscionable and I thought that this is really not the way to treat people.’ Major is the man – let it never be forgotten – who led the Tory party to a landslide defeat in 1997. The former prime minister also presided over Black Wednesday in 1992 – the exchange rate debacle that shattered the

Andrew Liddle

What was Labour’s role in stopping Scottish independence?

Scottish independence became such a difficult issue for Labour that it is easy to forget the party was once the UK’s staunchest defender. As voters prepared to go to the polls a decade ago, it was Gordon Brown who delivered the barnstorming call to arms that the Unionist cause so desperately needed. In doing so, he made what must rank as one of the most powerful speeches by a British politician in this century.  Addressing supporters of Better Together, the cross-party pro-UK campaign group on the eve of the referendum, Brown made not just an economic but also a moral and emotional case against nationalism. He emphasised the shared struggles

Lucy Dunn

Stop calling us ‘junior’, demand doctors

Junior doctors made headlines this week after they begrudgingly accepted the government’s pay deal. Two thirds of British Medical Association (BMA) members voted in favour of Health Secretary Wes Streeting’s offer, meaning medics across England will see a 22.3 per cent rise consolidated into their pay. Yet the move hasn’t entirely eased tensions between junior doctors and the government, with co-chair of the BMA Dr Vivek Trivedi insisting that medics will still ‘expect pay uplifts each and every year’. The co-chair of the doctors’ union went on to warn Streeting that wage increases must ‘occur in a timely fashion and at the pace that our members have asked for’ –

Alexander Larman

Prince Andrew will struggle to recover from A Very Royal Scandal

Sensational dramas about the Duke of York are rather like London buses: you wait five years for one, and then two come along at once. Amazon Prime’s three-part series, A Very Royal Scandal, which focuses on the notorious Newsnight interview with Prince Andrew, is released tomorrow. The show follows the perspective of both the journalist Emily Maitlis (Ruth Wilson) and, more surprisingly, Andrew himself, in another of the ever-chameleonic Michael Sheen’s superb performances. A Very Royal Scandal follows Netflix’s depiction of the interview, Scoop, which was released earlier this year. A Very Royal Scandal takes a more considered approach, daring to hint that Andrew was actively bad Whether the royals

Tuesday

Stephen Daisley

Now we know how Keir Starmer will fall

After coasting his way to No. 10, Sir Keir Starmer’s premiership has got off to a pretty cursed start. Some of this wasn’t his fault, such as the Southport riots, and some has come from enacting policies that, while controversial, represent rational political choices, such as means-testing the winter fuel payment and early release of prisoners. But alongside these there has been a gradual piling up of missteps, miscalculations and unforced errors. The most headline-grabbing have involved the Prime Minister, his wife and the running of Downing Street. Sir Keir Starmer’s premiership has got off to a pretty cursed start The last five years of Tory government weren’t the only

Owen Polley

Oasis should run a mile from this Irish rebel band

Liam Gallagher, it is fair to say, is not renowned for thoughtfulness or tact, particularly on the platform formerly known as Twitter. Still, many fans will have been appalled to learn that the singer apparently wants the Irish republican band, the Wolfe Tones, to perform at Oasis’s shows in Dublin next year. In response to a suggestion that the ‘rebel’ group should be added to the bill at Croke Park, Liam tweeted, ‘I’m up for it, let’s do it!’ The Wolfe Tones are best known for their song Celtic Symphony, which features the refrain, ‘Ooh, ahh, up the ‘Ra,’ in celebration of the Provisional Irish Republican Army. It was the PIRA

Steerpike

David Lammy: Climate change a more ‘fundamental’ threat than terrorism

Back to the Foreign Secretary, who seems unable to keep himself out of the headlines these days. It transpires that as well as being rather gaffe-prone on the subject of international relations – having described Donald Trump in the past as a ‘neo-Nazi sympathising sociopath’ – David Lammy has today taken it upon himself to wax lyrical about the dangers of the climate crisis. In fact, the Foreign Secretary even appeared to imply that climate change is a more urgent threat than Vladimir Putin or, er, terrorism. Quite the comparisons to choose… Speaking in Kew Gardens about the need to tie climate action closer to foreign policy, Lammy warned his

James Heale

Two takeaways from Ed Davey’s conference speech

Sir Ed Davey has just finished his conference speech in Brighton. No party is likely to hold a more upbeat political jamboree this year than the one which the Lib Dems have just concluded. With a record 72 MPs, July’s result ensured Davey became his party’s most successful leader since the days of Asquith and Lloyd George. So it’s no surprise that much of his speech effectively comprised a victory lap, in which he thanked the many, many people involved in his party’s triumphs across the blue wall. There were name checks too for Davey’s predecessors: Liberal legends of old like Charles Kennedy and Paddy Ashdown. The second takeaway from