James Heale

James Heale

James Heale is The Spectator’s deputy political editor.

Why politics hasn’t recovered from 2008 | with Lord Wood

From our UK edition

18 min listen

There have been a number of critiques of Tony Blair’s 5,000-word intervention on Labour and the country this week, but none more astute than Lord Wood’s. One of Labour’s foremost thinkers, Lord Wood joins James Heale for this special edition of Saturday Shots to discuss where Blair is right, where he is wrong, and why the former Prime Minister is, ultimately, stuck in the past. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Blair is not the answer | Lord Wood

Who has a winning vision for Labour – Blair, Burnham or Starmer?

From our UK edition

15 min listen

When it comes to political vision, Keir Starmer’s premiership has been something of a vacuum – and power abhors a vacuum. So cue Tony Blair, who this week has rushed in with a 5,000-word essay on what is wrong with Labour and, depending on who you listen to, either an outdated or radical view of where Britain should be as a country. This has galvanised Andy Burnham, Wes Streeting and (finally) Keir Starmer to put down on paper their vision for the country and how to solve the biggest issues we face. But whose is more convincing? Oscar Edmondson discusses the question with James Heale and Rachel Wolf, founding partner at Public First and author of the 2019 manifesto. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Labour’s vision vacuum: Blair vs Burnham vs Starmer

Is it too late for Britain’s ‘lost generation’?

From our UK edition

13 min listen

More than 600,000 16 to 24-year-olds are neither in work nor looking for a job. Youth worklessness is now costing Britain £125 billion a year – almost double the country’s entire defence budget. Those are the findings of Alan Milburn’s new review into youth worklessness, who warns that the UK is facing an ‘urgent national crisis’. But is it already too late? Noa Hoffman is joined by James Heale and Michael Simmons to discuss.

James Murray is facing his first big test

From our UK edition

James Murray, who replaced Wes Streeting as health secretary 13 days ago, is facing a fresh round of strikes by resident doctors next month. The walkout from 15 June until 19 June it will be the sixteenth in the long-running dispute over pay that began in May 2023. It followed a meeting earlier today between Murray and the British Medical Association (BMA). Murray has deviated little from his predecessor’s stance on this issue. He made it clear he was not willing to negotiate on pay, on the grounds that the union’s demands for more money are ‘unrealistic and unaffordable’. Resident doctors have received pay rises worth 33 per cent over the past four years, including a 3.5 per cent increase this year.

Can Andy Burnham really do it?

From our UK edition

30 min listen

Andy Burnham is the man on everyone’s lips in Westminster. As he campaigns to return to parliament in the Makerfield by-election, Tim and James bring you the definitive guide to Burnham – and what could happen next. They’re joined by Joshi Herrmann, founder and editor of Mill Media, whose profile of Burnham had Westminster buzzing over the weekend. He shares his view of the Greater Manchester mayor’s ‘unusual gifts and glaring weaknesses’, whether ‘Burnhamism’ really exists, and if Burnham’s emotional style of politics could survive the brutality of No. 10.

What did Nicola Sturgeon know?

From our UK edition

12 min listen

Peter Murrell, the SNP’s former chief executive and Nicola Sturgeon’s estranged husband, has admitted embezzling £400,000 in party funds. The guilty plea has revived questions about what senior figures in the SNP knew, how long the scandal had been going on, and what happens next. To discuss the story, including some of the ridiculous purchases including a couple of hairdryers (for a bald man) and £2600 salt and pepper shakers, James Heale and Michael Simmons join Megan McElroy.

‘It’s an orgy of chaos’: Steve Baker on how to oust a Prime Minister

From our UK edition

12 min listen

On today’s Saturday shots, James Heale is joined by former Conservative MP Steve Baker to discuss the fallout from Wes Streeting’s resignation and the ‘orgy of chaos’ that has ensued. Steve takes James inside the dark arts of a Westminster coup: why numbers matter, why you should pay attention to individual grievances, the importance of discipline – and why Labour’s rebels may already be getting it wrong. As Andy Burnham plots his return, do the people of Makerfield really want to be caught up in a by-election that will not be about local issues? And is Burnham as good as he thinks he is? Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Wesignation: does Streeting have a plan?

From our UK edition

17 min listen

After days of deliberation, Wes Streeting has finally quit Keir Starmer’s government. At the stroke of 1 p.m., the Ilford MP resigned as Health Secretary in a two-page letter that laid out his differences with the Prime Minister. He details, at length, the results the pair have achieved in government and says they offer ‘good reasons for me to remain in post’. But: ‘As you know from our conversation earlier this week, having lost confidence in your leadership, I have concluded that it would be dishonourable and unprincipled to do so.’ So there we go – the starting gun has been fired on the Labour leadership race... or has it? Noa Hoffman, James Heale and Tim Shipman discuss how this carefully worded resignation leaves the door open for Andy Burnham.

Wesignation: does Streeting have a plan?

Wes Streeting finally resigns

After days of deliberation, Wes Streeting has finally quit Keir Starmer’s government. At the stroke of 1 p.m., the Ilford MP resigned as Health Secretary in a two-page letter that laid out his differences with the Prime Minister. He details, at length, the results the pair have achieved in government and says they offer ‘good reasons for me to remain in post’. But: As you know from our conversation earlier this week, having lost confidence in your leadership, I have concluded that it would be dishonourable and unprincipled to do so. It is the opening salvo of a merciless script that goes for Starmer’s jugular. Streeting pins blame for the 'unprecedented' results of last week, which pose 'an existential threat to the future integrity' of the UK on Starmer himself.

Waiting for Wes: inside Labour’s leadership crisis

All eyes on Wes: inside Labour’s leadership crisis

From our UK edition

16 min listen

Wes Streeting is/was expected to make his move today for the Labour leadership – but does he have the numbers? There was some frantic briefing last night, with competing claims about who has the required number of MPs and who might be prepared to give up their seat to Andy Burnham. It almost takes us back to the days of Tory infighting. But the big news this morning is that Angela Rayner has been cleared by HMRC. In an incredibly well-timed judgment, there is now nothing standing in her way from making her own bid for the top job. So where are we on Thursday morning? What should we expect from the next 48 hours? James Heale speaks to Tim Shipman and James Lyons, former director of strategic communications in Number 10. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Farage’s plan to win over the left

The loudest man in politics knows when to keep his silence. Nigel Farage held his tongue on Monday as Keir Starmer’s premiership floundered. Aside from a few PFLs – proper f***ing lunches – to celebrate the local election results, the Reform UK leader was already looking to the next challenge. Like a shark, Farage keeps moving forward, into new waters, hungry for more. One ally sums up his approach to politics in a single word: ‘Momentum’. For the past few months, Farage has had one goal: destroying the Tories. The figure ‘1,453’ was the total of gains proudly pumped out on Reform’s Instagram. For Farage, 7 May was the political equivalent of the fall of Constantinople – the point when the Conservatives ceased to be a national party.

Keir Starmer looked utterly miserable during the King’s Speech

From our UK edition

This King’s Speech will live long in the memory: not for its contents, but for its context. The long-planned state opening of Parliament today was intended to be a fireguard for the Prime Minister after the battering of last week’s local elections. Yet even constitutional screens can only do so much in the face of a forest fire engulfing No. 10. With nearly 100 Labour MPs demanding Keir Starmer resign, today’s events have been overshadowed by the machinations of Wes Streeting. Ahead of the speech, the Health Secretary met Starmer for a 15-minute meeting chat, with confirmation breaking during the speech that he intends to resign tomorrow. That very much set the tone for today’s proceedings.

Starmer says put up or shut up

From our UK edition

13 min listen

The Prime Minister is digging his heels in. Keir Starmer has told his cabinet that he is not going anywhere, despite a growing list of MPs calling for him to go. At 9.30 a.m., Starmer was greeted by his senior ministers, many of whom now believe the game is up. So is this his ‘put up or shut up’ moment? Will anyone move today – and if they do, what happens next? Tim Shipman and James Heale join Noa Hoffman to assess Starmer’s fight for survival, the mood inside Labour, and where we go from here.

Keir Starmer is done

This morning’s cabinet meeting was one for the ages. At 9.30 a.m. Keir Starmer was greeted by his senior ministers, almost all of whom think the game is up. Ahead of entering Downing Street today, they will have seen the list of 80 Labour MPs – the magic number needed for a ballot – calling for him to go. Last night, we had junior aides jumping ship; this morning we have the first minister, Miatta Fahnbulleh. She has quit the government and called on Starmer to ‘do the right thing’.  When you have David Lammy, Yvette Cooper, John Healey and Shabana Mahmood all telling Downing Street that it is over, you know that the Prime Minister has lost the dressing room.

Keir Starmer’s position is looking increasingly untenable

Things are moving very fast in Westminster this evening. More than 60 Labour MPs are publicly calling on the Prime Minister to announce a date for his departure. The stream of these calls has ebbed and flowed in recent days – but the profile of the MPs has strikingly changed. On Friday night, it was the soft left out for Keir Starmer’s head; this evening it is the Labour right. Junior aides are now quitting the government, and resigning from their positions as parliamentary private secretaries (PPS). Three did so in quick succession this evening: Joe Morris, Sally Jameson and Tom Rutland, the respective PPSs for Wes Streeting, Shabana Mahmood and Emma Reynolds.  It is, in the words of one MP, ‘all one-way traffic, heading to the exit.

Keir Starmer’s big pitch is ... more of the same

Keir Starmer’s big pitch is … more of the same

From our UK edition

23 min listen

Keir Starmer has given what was billed as a make-or-break having spent the weekend under fire from his own party. He tried to strike a more urgent tone, promising bigger arguments, closer ties with Europe (which is basically already happening) and action on British Steel (subject to consultation). But with Labour still haemorrhaging votes on all sides, is this enough to steady his leadership – or has the party already begun to look beyond him? Tim Shipman and James Heale discuss Starmer’s speech, the Labour figures waiting in the wings – from Wes Streeting and Angela Rayner to Andy Burnham and Ed Miliband – and what Reform, the Tory party, the Lib Dems, the SNP and the Green party do next after a dramatic set of local elections. Produced by Megan McElroy.

Starmer is shedding support across Labour

From our UK edition

By inclination, tradition and design, the Labour Party is much less prone to toppling leaders than their Conservative counterparts. There is no equivalent to the 1922, Sir Graham Brady’s grin and the usual excited talk of ‘letters going in’. Perhaps an equivalent shorthand must now been coined for the process which is going on in the government ranks. The steady drip-drip-drip of MPs calling for Keir Starmer to quit has continued unabated for the past 48 hours. Now we are up to 36 names, with the latest perhaps being the most intriguing of all. ‘A sudden rush for a contest, encouraged by the soft left, could, inadvertently, end up putting the Blairite crown prince into No. 10.

Labour MP: I’ll challenge Starmer for leader

From our UK edition

In the aftermath of Thursday’s shellacking, a steady stream of Labour MPs have been coming out and calling on Keir Starmer to quit. Their tone has varied: some are much more coded than others. On Cofffee House, we have a rolling list that now stands at more than 30. A key tell is those arguing for ‘an orderly transition' – the subtext for which is ‘enough time until Andy Burnham can get into parliament’. The Mayor of Great Manchester would need months, not weeks, to fight and win a by-election that would allow him to return to parliament and thus claim the leadership. The precarious route by which that would happen has been enough to sew doubts in the minds of much of the Parliamentary Labour party (PLP).

Should he stay, or should he go? | with Maurice Glasman

Should he stay, or should he go? | with Maurice Glasman

From our UK edition

11 min listen

As the full picture of the local elections emerges, Labour faces a dilemma: stick with Keir Starmer, or put forward an alternative. Calls for Starmer to resign have intensified, and we are braced for MPs to stick their heads above the parapet this weekend. The message from the Prime Minister is that he ‘will not go’ and will not set out a path for his resignation either. So where does Labour go from here? Lord Glasman joins Tim and James to discuss the battle for the soul of the Labour party. Should they return to their traditions, or continue to ‘limp along in a state of paralysis’?