Michael Simmons

Michael Simmons

Michael Simmons is The Spectator's economics editor. Contact him here.

Reeves’s energy bailout risks solidifying Britain’s welfare trap

From our UK edition

This week Rachel Reeves ruled out a blanket energy bailout to manage the fallout from the Iran war. That’s the right approach. But her targeting of a bailout – reportedly to those on benefits – risks solidifying Britain’s welfare trap. When the Chancellor gave her economic update to the Commons on Tuesday following an emergency Cobra meeting, she took a potshot at Liz Truss. Not for the ex-prime minister’s mini-Budget but for her multi-billion-pound energy price guarantee that sent the gilt market into meltdown. ‘As we respond to this crisis, we must learn from the mistakes of the past,’ Reeves told MPs. The previous government pushed up borrowing, interest rates, inflation and mortgage costs with an unfunded, untargeted package of support under Liz Truss.

Why is Britain so ill-equipped to deal with economic shocks?

From our UK edition

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has just confirmed what we already knew: Britain will be hit harder than almost anywhere else by the economic fallout triggered by the war in Iran. Updated OECD forecasts released today slashed predictions of UK growth for this year to just 0.7 per cent from the 1.2 per cent previously expected. That’s a larger downgrade than any other G20 country. On inflation, the Washington-based organisation expects UK inflation to hit 4 per cent – the second highest in the G7. The causes are clear: an energy price hike, prolonged in nature, that simultaneously makes everything more expensive, reduces supply and destroys consumer demand. The result is even more stark: stagflation.

To drill or not to drill, that is the question

From our UK edition

15 min listen

In the final Prime Minister's Questions before Easter recess, Kemi Badenoch pushed Keir Starmer to commit to new oil & gas drilling licences. The Conservatives spot an easy win here – cost of living concerns are rising as America's war with Iran continues. Plus, with a burgeoning welfare bill, the trade-offs are even trickier for Labour to resolve. Who should Labour target? Tim Shipman and Michael Simmons join Patrick Gibbons to discuss. Come for Tim's impression of the Prime Minister, and stay for Michael's very strong response when asked if renewables are the answer. Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

To drill or not to drill, that is the question

Inflation stalls before the energy shock hits

From our UK edition

Prices rose by 3 per cent last month – the same rate as the month before. Figures just released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show that – ironically – falling petrol costs were one of the main things keeping the Consumer Prices Index (CPI) from climbing. This data was, of course, collected before the latest conflict in the Middle East – and we can soon expect the numbers to start heading in the wrong direction. Elsewhere, clothing costs were the largest upward driver of inflation, while food inflation remained broadly flat. In good news for drinkers, the cost of alcohol came down thanks to increased promotional activity in February. In a different world, the government would be cautiously welcoming today’s figures.

Energy bailout? Why Britain can’t afford a cap on household bills

From our UK edition

22 min listen

Today Rachel Reeves promised ‘support for those who need it most’ as she updated MPs on measures the government is taking as the Iran war risks increasing energy bills. Michael Simmons is joined by Spectator writer Ross Clarke to discuss why energy bailouts won’t work, why Reeves is unfair to pile the blame on Liz Truss and understand the complexities behind a means tested method to target those that need help most.

Energy bailout? Why Britain can’t afford a cap on household bills
Should we brace for another financial shock?

Should we brace for another financial shock?

From our UK edition

Britain’s response to the conflict in Iran is dominating Westminster – but is Keir Starmer really keeping the country out of war? After a tense Liaison Committee appearance exposed divisions over defence spending, pressure is also mounting on the government’s economic strategy. With energy prices rising, mortgage products disappearing and fears of inflation returning, how prepared is Labour for the fallout? James Heale speaks to Isabel Hardman and Michael Simmons.

Britain’s borrowing splurge is not sustainable

From our UK edition

After a record tax take and surplus in January, normal service has resumed. Britain experienced its second-largest February borrowing splurge since records began, according to figures just released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS). Last month we borrowed some £14.3 billion, which was £2.2 billion more than a year before and the second highest figure for a February since records began in 1993. Tom Davies, senior statistician at the ONS, said: ‘While [tax] receipts were up last year, that was outweighed by a rise in spending.’ A large part of that jump in spending was our debt interest payments which, at £13 billion, was the highest ever recorded for February, as this rather striking graph shows: Some £4.

Brace yourself: inflation is coming

From our UK edition

In a surprise to no one, the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) has voted nine-zero to hold interest rates at 3.75 per cent. The unanimous decision is the first time the MPC have been in complete agreement since September 2021. Before Trump and Israel’s bombs rained down on Iran, the markets had been overwhelmingly expecting a rate cut. This would have been welcome news for mortgage holders and the government. But with an energy price shock sending inflation expectations in the wrong direction, we are lucky the MPC didn’t hike rates this time. The markets are now expecting a rate hike towards the end of summer after inevitably higher energy prices lead to higher inflation.  Even before today’s announcement the mortgage market was feeling the pressure.

Britain may have finally turned a corner on jobs

From our UK edition

Finally, some good economic news: Britain may have turned a corner on jobs. Figures just released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show the unemployment rate remained flat at 5.2 per cent in January. On payrolled jobs there was positive news too: employees on PAYE payrolls in February grew at their fastest rate since October 2024, with 20,000 jobs added. If this really is the turnaround point on jobs, it comes as welcome relief for a Chancellor whose minimum wage hikes and National Insurance raid were to blame for much of the job destruction. Despite today’s welcome increases, we’re still down by over 114,000 jobs since Labour came to power. Whether this would truly have been the end of the job slump has now been made something of a moot point by events in Iran.

Britain can have AI or Net Zero – but it can’t have both

From our UK edition

8 min listen

Yesterday Rachel Reeves gave her Mais lecture and said UK would achieve ‘fastest AI adoption in the G7’. Today govt is publishing its position on AI rules that are crucial for keeping AI startups in the UK and not losing them abroad. Michael Simmons uncovers the data that shows just how costly of Britain's energy resources this plan for an AI revolution would be. And how incompatible this is with Ed Miliband's dreams of a net zero future.

Britain can have AI or Net Zero – but it can’t have both

Net Zero vs AI: can Reeves convince Miliband?

From our UK edition

16 min listen

The Chancellor will deliver the annual Mais lecture today and is expected to focus on closer alignment with the EU, AI and improving Britain's economic geography ('levelling up' in all but name). While her comments on Europe might gain the most headlines, we're more curious about what she will say over AI – given the current geopolitical context. Given the energy requirements of AI, the Iran crisis has only further exposed the holes in Britain's energy policy – can Rachel Reeves convince Ed Miliband to adapt his policies? And is this about the Chancellor's political headroom as much as the economic?

Net Zero vs AI: can Reeves convince Miliband?

Brace yourselves for a painful year ahead

From our UK edition

Figures just released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show the economy ground to a halt in January, with no growth recorded. That was despite economists and businesses reporting a brighter start to the year. Economists had expected January to see growth of 0.2 per cent. Over the three months to January we did see some growth, though just 0.2 per cent. Within that figure, services expanded 0.2 per cent while production grew 1.3 per cent. The positive numbers end there, however, with the construction sector contracting by 2 per cent. It’s unlikely things are going to get much better as the year goes on.

Should Reeves cut fuel duty?

From our UK edition

With Donald Trump signalling that he does not want a long war in Iran, markets have started to settle down. Traders are no longer betting on interest rate hikes, the FTSE is in the green and a barrel of oil is hovering around $90. Nevertheless, the pressure on the Chancellor to set out further financial support to tackle the cost of living is on. The average five-year fixed mortgage passed 5 per cent today for the first time since November, prices at the pumps have jumped at their fastest pace in four years, and Morgan Stanley is the latest bank to warn that inflation could hit 5 per cent later this year.  On petrol and diesel, Rachel Reeves is angry with service stations.

Is the special relationship over?

Is the special relationship over?

From our UK edition

The US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has said today will be the most intense day yet of American strikes on Iran. Over the weekend, Donald Trump claimed the war could soon be over – and suggested the US has already effectively won. He also took aim at Keir Starmer, accusing Britain of joining wars America has ‘already won’. Deputy and US editor Freddy Gray joins the podcast to explain what’s really happening in Washington and why he believes the ‘special relationship’ may be over – and not coming back. Economics editor Michael Simmons also joins to discuss the fallout. As oil prices surge and markets react, Reform UK is seizing on renewed pressure over the cost of living. What does the crisis mean for Rachel Reeves – and how serious could the economic consequences become?

Iran has wrecked Reeves’s cost-of-living promises

From our UK edition

Just as Britain’s economy looked to be ‘turning a corner’, it may be about to slam into a wall. The warning signs were obvious last week. On Monday, I’m told, the ship insurer Lloyd’s of London saw its ‘war desk’ hit its annual sales target within the first two hours of trading. As you read this email, the Chancellor will meet with the Lloyd’s chair to come up with a plan to support shipping amid the continuing war in the Middle East. Today, though, turmoil in the market has accelerated. As Asian markets opened overnight, the price of crude surged past $100 a barrel for the first time since 2022.

This oil crisis could be the worst we've ever seen – former Trump economist Tyler Goodspeed

This oil crisis could be the worst we’ve ever seen – former Trump economist Tyler Goodspeed

From our UK edition

30 min listen

Oil prices surged past $100 per barrel as the war with Iran intensified over the weekend. Since Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz, without a solution to the severe disruption in crude oil flows, how hard will we feel it back in Britain? And why has Britain left itself so vulnerable from its energy policy? Michael Simmons is joined by former advisor to Donald Trump Tyler Goodspeed to discuss why this situation has far greater consequences than Trump’s tariffs, how petroleum is so embedded in our everyday economy and why Ed Miliband could be heading for a Liz situation.

Energy inflation is the last thing Rachel Reeves needs

From our UK edition

A few weeks ago I thought a March interest rates cut was ‘near certain’. Inflation was coming down and Bank of England rate-setters’ concerns about wage growth were being replaced by fears that higher rates were contributing to rising unemployment. In my defence, markets agreed: they priced the chances of a cut at over 80 per cent. But since then, the world – and markets – have changed. The graph below shows something called the ‘overnight index swaps’ curve. Without getting too deep into the mechanics, it can be understood as a proxy for where traders think interest rates are heading. As you can see, the line had been steadily dropping before Donald Trump’s action in Iran sent it shooting back up – implying that a March rate cut has become much less likely.

Reality Check live: Chancellor Rachel Reeves delivers the Spring Statement

From our UK edition

75 min listen

Before the first missiles landed in Tehran, Rachel Reeves had been looking forward to today’s Spring ‘forecast’ statement, which was designed to be the lightest-touch intervention by a Chancellor since Philip Hammond in 2018: no OBR scoring of her fiscal rules, no tax announcements, no major policy changes and, crucially, no months of damaging speculation about black holes or gilt yields in Britain’s fragile economy. The strategy worked, with barely any chatter ahead of time and the only real question being how small her measures would be – until turmoil in the Middle East sent oil and gas prices surging, markets tumbling and bond yields climbing, threatening to render parts of her forecasts outdated.

Reality Check live: Chancellor Rachel Reeves delivers the Spring Statement
Spring statement: everything you need to know

Spring statement: everything you need to know

From our UK edition

12 min listen

Rachel Reeves has today delivered her much anticipated spring statement, her opportunity to address the looming energy crisis, the uncertainty in the Middle East and the crashing Labour market … unfortunately, she did none of the above. The Treasury promised that the spring statement was going to be boring – and at least it delivered on that pledge. For twenty painful minutes, Reeves rattled off her familiar lines about ‘stability’ and Liz Truss. Is this another wasted opportunity for Labour and the Chancellor? What will it mean for her own ‘stability’? Oscar Edmondson speaks to James Heale and Michael Simmons. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Rachel Reeves’s Spring Statement ignored Britain’s biggest problems

From our UK edition

Rachel Reeves got what she wanted: an uneventful spring statement. It’s not even leading the homepage of the Financial Times. But that doesn’t mean it doesn’t matter. The forecasts the Chancellor read out from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) do not paint a pleasant picture of Britain’s economy. Growth for this year was slashed compared with a year ago – coming in at just 1.1 per cent. Reeves seemed pleased that it then picks up to 1.6 per cent over the next few years, but that is not the kind of growth we need to turn around a country that has felt stagnant for years. By the end of the parliament, voters will be on average £1,000 per year better off, Reeves claimed. And that is, in fairness, improved on the numbers that accompanied her November Budget.