When in doubt, demand more censorship of the internet. This appears to be the closest thing the ruling British Labour party has to a governing philosophy, as its latest row with Google over Russell Brand’s YouTube account would attest.
The state has no right to demand tech companies take down perfectly legal content
Brand is now a convicted rapist. Few beyond his conspiratorial fanboys doubt his guilt. But he continues to insist he is innocent – as does his wife, whose decision to read out a disturbingly jokey statement from Brand in a YouTube video has enraged the government.
Days after Russell Brand was sentenced to ten-and-a-half years in prison for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault, Laura Gallacher relayed a message from her husband on their depressingly popular channel, which has 6.6 million subscribers:
As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for, so something strange is happening. The good news is that Christ is with us when we choose him, and I do. I am incarcerated in HMP Littlehey, little as in small and hey as in ‘Hey, I’m in the biggest sex-offenders prison in Europe.’
After Brand’s ostentatious – some might say convenient – conversion to Christianity a few years ago, he and Gallacher had been making weekly “Sunday Service” videos, featuring prayer and Bible readings. The offending video also features a long, unreleased, previously recorded segment featuring Brand.
The Ministry of Justice has launched an investigation into whether the video broke the rules around prisoners talking to the media. According to the guidelines, a prison governor must decide whether such public statements are permissible, taking into account whether “serious distress to victims of the prisoner and/or outrage to public sensibilities is not likely to result from the broadcast.” A breach of the rules would not constitute a criminal offence, but could lead to Brand losing privileges or having his sentence extended.
Meanwhile, the government is insisting Google not only remove the video in question but also, reportedly, Brand’s entire channel. His Instagram and Facebook accounts have already been disabled due to the platforms’ ban on convicted sex offenders. For its part, YouTube says it is “investigating,” but appears to believe the video doesn’t violate its terms of service.
When it comes to convicts talking to the media, there is a fine balance to be struck. While prisoners are, by definition, deprived of their usual liberties, this cannot come at the cost of them protesting their innocence. Any attempt to call into question a conviction is bound to cause “distress to victims,” even “outrage to public sensibilities,” particularly in a case as high-profile as this. These rules must not be interpreted too broadly, or imposed more punitively on public figures. Otherwise, we risk crowding out the space for doubt in our justice system and feeding the fantasies of Brand’s followers – who seem convinced this conviction is the establishment punishing him for his stances on Covid, vaccines, etc.
What should be clear-cut is that the state has no right to demand tech companies take down perfectly legal content. It is bad enough when British governments pass laws curtailing freedom of speech, online or off. This censorship-by-letterhead is altogether more devious – abusing the bully pulpit of Downing Street to coerce tech companies into censoring at Westminster’s whim.
This isn’t about sticking up for victims. This is about a political class which has come to see the policing of public discussion as its most sacred duty. Education secretary Lucy Powell has even bashed mainstream broadcasters for airing clips from Gallacher’s video. Powell seems to think it’s the government’s job to decide what should and shouldn’t be posted online and what should and shouldn’t be reported by the free media.
If Labourites truly want to tackle sexual violence, YouTube’s content-moderation policies seem a curious place to start. Perhaps they could get on top of the scourge of illegal migrants preying on women and girls across the country? And if Lucy Powell is so exercised about public figures making statements that “distress” rape victims, maybe she should have a word with… Lucy Powell, who infamously dismissed the grooming gangs as a far-right “dogwhistle” on the BBC?
Russell Brand is a rapist. I’ve no time for his jocular protestations, nor those who reflexively disbelieve his victims, and the judgement of the jury, because they happen to agree with him on the New World Order or whatever. But he has a right to make his case and tech companies cannot be expected to clamp down on content, ad hoc, in response to government pressure. Anything else would be an affront to freedom of speech. Not to mention a massive displacement activity from a Labour party that has demonstrably failed when it comes to sexual violence.
Comments