In defence of small, revealing domestic details in fiction

Saul Bellow once complained that he could ‘hear the tinkle of teacups’ in a novel by Elizabeth Taylor. But any writer who can make sound arise from ink and paper is a genius

Charlotte Stroud
Alice Munro after receiving the Man Booker International Prize in 2009 Peter Muhly/AFP/Getty Images
issue 21 November 2026

There is a kind of criticism often practised in the academy today that treats literature as if it were a specimen to be sliced and taxonomised according to abstract theories. Once the various lenses have been applied to the microscope – feminist, postcolonial, Marxist – an etiolated thing remains, sapped of vitality. Then there is the kind of criticism that persists outside the high walls of the university which instead marvels at how a selection of black words on a white page has all the palpitating freshness of a living thing. A critic of this disposition has no use for the tools of the laboratory, but simply desires to understand by what galvanising forces this miracle has been achieved.

Any writer who can make sound arise from ink and paper is a writer of the first order

The novelist Tessa Hadley is one of their number. In her essay collection Alone with a Book, she distances herself from the kind of critical work that spins ‘the gold of great writing into straw’. In a book that represents a quarter of a century of her critical output, she reminds us that literature belongs ‘to the world outside’; that in studying it we are always in pursuit of life itself.

This is one of the strange paradoxes of reading. While it promises escapism, it is also, as Hadley puts it, a way to ‘enhance living, make it deeper’. We retreat into a book so that we can ‘take back its enchantment into our life, into our perception of the world; it refreshes everything’. Which is why reading from a young age is so vitally important. A childhood ‘suffused’ with reading, as Hadley’s was, is one spent cultivating ‘an inner eye’, that highly impressionable organ that comes to dictate our tastes, our quality of perception and most importantly our ethical stance towards the world. Today, when the smartphone has usurped the book as our main form of escapism, we neglect to nourish the inner eye and instead perform for an Orwellian one. To read Alone with a Book is to understand how much we have to lose.

Hadley’s appetite for reading is vast. For her, while writing fiction is necessarily ‘parochial’, ‘built out of what’s close to home’, reading should be ‘global’. In a collection which includes appraisals of the work of the British writers Elizabeth Taylor and Margaret Drabble, the Canadians Alice Munro and Mavis Gallant, the South African J.M. Coetzee and the great Russian novelist Leo Tolstoy, Hadley establishes herself as one of those rare critics who possess vast knowledge, a refined sensibility and balanced judgment. Whatever she writes about, whether it’s the paintings of Félix Vallotton or the novels of Henry James, she brings her discerning inner eye to bear on the subject, and always with the utmost humility.

But there is a central pivot around which her roving eye moves, and that is her attachment to realism. Her taste for the ‘granularity of daily life’ was formed at a young age, and it remains her guiding sensibility. Her mind thrills at the way Munro can capture ‘the particularity of experience’, at how the ‘strenuous exercise of perception is always at work’ in Elizabeth Bowen’s writing, so that she can make us hear the twang of a ‘thin iron gate’. Hadley is awed by the capaciousness of realism, its ability, as Jane Austen first showed us, to ‘accommodate such a range of vision’.

If a collection as broad as this can be summed up, it is a defence of realism and, in particular, of the domestic kind, too often condemned for its narrowness. It was Saul Bellow who, while serving as a judge for the 1971 Booker Prize, dismissed Elizabeth Taylor’s nominated novel Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont, declaring that he could ‘hear the tinkle of teacups’. How wrong he was to view this as a criticism. Any writer who can make sound arise from ink and paper is a writer of the first order, regardless of whether the noise originates in the home or on the battlefield. It is a task that demands such powers of perception, such skills of verisimilitude that the writer must strain ‘every nerve’ to find the right alchemy of words.

Dismissing a novelist who achieves this near impossible feat, based on the supposed narrowness of their subject, is like rejecting Vermeer for painting the way light hits a copper pan instead of what is happening outside the window. There is nothing frivolous about cups that tinkle and pots that gleam. On the contrary, they are the achievement of the most serious kind of effort: the ‘pursuit of fresh truth-to-life’. Fortunately, we have Hadley, who not only defends this noble vocation in her criticism but continues to practise that rare alchemy in her own audible and luminous work.

Comments