Ministers of all stripes have spent the past decade trying to ban conversion therapy. In abstract, it sounds like the kind of thing that most reasonable people would be against: stopping counsellors from trying to ‘pray away the gay’, often using religious practices. You could probably add stopping extreme conversion practices to a list of things we all want to do, along with stopping dangerous dogs mauling children.
This is the problem with legislation that focuses on the principle, rather than the practice and implementation of a policy
I use that last example as a reminder of the problems politicians end up mired in when they believe that the principle of what they are doing is so important that it doesn’t really matter if they’re actually solving the problem before them. The Dangerous Dogs Act was, initially, so badly drafted that it didn’t manage to stop dangerous dogs or indeed their owners, and instead focused obsessively on breeds that were deemed – often incorrectly – to be particularly menacing. This current government’s proposed legislation banning conversion practices runs the same risk: the principle sounds good, but the design ends up being such a mess that there are some really quite serious unintended consequences.
That was precisely the warning of Hilary Cass when she gave evidence to the joint committee scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill. The paediatrician and chair of the Cass Review into gender identity services for children and adolescents in England is in principle in favour of banning conversion therapy. She has said just that in her report, which was published in 2024. She also said it initially after the government published its draft legislation. But today, she explained that she had serious concerns about the bill, and that her initial support had been based on a conversation with the minister at the time with just 15 minutes between the bill being sent to her and a request for a press response. Now she’d had enough time to read the legislation, she was worried. ‘Having spent a long time thinking about it, I unfortunately now don’t think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.’
She explained: ‘I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it, but it was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.’ She said she’d given her quotes ‘based on the principles that I’d been told about, but without seeing the bill as drafted.’
Cass’s concerns are that responsible clinicians working in gender identity services for young people could end up being accused of being ‘conversion therapists’ simply because they are trying to explore whether a patient’s gender distress is really gender dysphoria that means they are transgender, or whether it has been caused by something else in their life, including homophobia from parents. She cited one example of a parent who had commented that they would have ‘beaten’ homosexuality out of their child, and that the child’s doctor had been concerned that this homophobia may have led the child to think that the only way to come to terms with their sexuality would be to switch gender identity.
Teenagers might report doctors who had conducted a ‘painful discussion’ with them, at the risk of those clinicians being jailed for engaging in conversion practices. She was also concerned that the polarisation around the trans debate generally made it much harder for people ‘doing careful exploratory work with teenagers’ to operate without ‘malign actors’ going after them.
This is the problem with legislation that focuses on the principle, rather than the practice and implementation of a policy. When ministers think in terms of there being a right and wrong side of a debate, they naturally overlook the possibility that they might be causing new and unexpected problems for the people they still probably think are on the ‘right’ side. Few people want exorcisms of gay people. But few people want to see a doctor going to jail for refusing to be reckless with their medical licence. Cass’s intervention should be enough to send that bill straight back to the drafting table.
Comments