Eliot Wilson

Eliot Wilson

Eliot Wilson was a House of Commons clerk, including on the Defence Committee and Counter-Terrorism Sub-Committee. He is contributing editor at Defence On The Brink and senior fellow for national security at the Coalition for Global Prosperity

Labour is running out of time to prepare Britain for war

From our UK edition

House of Lords select committees are not entirely like their Commons counterparts. They operate in similar ways, but they are quieter, more stately, draw on more experienced membership, have less of an eye on the following day’s headline and tend therefore to attract less attention. In the past week, however, two Lords committees have published reports on issues of immediate interest and importance, bound up in the government’s recent warning that Nato could face a direct military threat from Russia by the end of the decade. Last week, the Industry and Regulators Committee published Ready for action in 1,000 days? Forging a new partnership between government and the defence industry. This week has seen a report from the National Resilience Committee entitled Are we ready?

Is Britain still safe for America’s armed forces?

The episode at RAF Fairford in September, when five men were arrested near the perimeter of the airbase, initially on suspicion of offences under the Explosives Act 1875 and the Terrorism Act 2005, remains mysterious. All five were released on bail the following day, as were two more people arrested later. Prime Minister Andy Burnham said there were, ‘strong indications that Iran played a part in what happened’. The Iranian embassy in London denied any involvement (but they would say that, wouldn’t they). It is still unclear exactly what did happen.

Keir Starmer is wrong to think Nato is unsalvageable

From our UK edition

We need to build up pan-European co-operation and co-ordination on defence and security – a common security framework as much as a common market. The EU is changing to respond to that, but it cannot be the EU alone when Europe’s periphery is core to its defence. It seems hard to believe, but 15 weeks ago, Sir Keir Starmer was still prime minister. Now, to read his name in the current news as anything but a reference point is oddly jarring. But last week he was in Dublin to receive honorary life membership of the British Irish Chamber of Commerce and spoke out as an ex-premier. To say, as Starmer did, that a European 'security framework' is as important as a common market is quietly revolutionary.

Will Trump punish Europe for his midterm losses?

From our UK edition

The consensus ahead of America’s midterm elections was that the Democrats would enjoy an advantage and could well take control of the House of Representatives after four years as the minority party. A few Trump loyalists, such as Natalie Baldassarre of the Republican National Convention, maintained a Berlin 1945-style optimism: Polls may suggest one thing, but the American people get the final say, and Republicans remain laser-focused on driving voters to the polls, defying history, and protecting our majorities. The reality was that the Democrats scored huge wins to take control of the House and the Senate; with 29 governorships, they are the majority at state level for the first time since 2010.

How long must Britain wait to see Healey’s defence spending boost?

From our UK edition

Politics can be a rollercoaster. When Andy Burnham chose John Healey as the new Chancellor of the Exchequer in July, there were pricklings of hope that Healey might begin to extricate the government from its hazy morass of misdirection, inaction and false promises on defence spending. He had, after all, resigned from Sir Keir Starmer’s cabinet less than six weeks previously on exactly that issue. And he had done so with painful candour, his resignation letter providing a brutal punch to the embattled prime minister: You have been unable, and the Treasury has been unwilling, to commit the resources that the nation needs to defend the country at this time of rising threats.

The ‘Coalition of the Willing’ is not the way to support Ukraine

From our UK edition

Andy Burnham has relatively little in common with Sir Keir Starmer, which is in large part why the Labour party embraced him so warmly – and without a contest – as its new leader in July. Those traits he does share seem, unfortunately, to be the bad ones. One of Starmer’s less endearing habits as prime minister was an apparently ironclad belief in his power of political reification. If he said something often enough and sufficiently fervently, it seemed to him to become somehow true and tangible. He talked so often of taking 'hard decisions' that it didn’t matter when he ducked or postponed actual decision-making; he pledged to increase defence spending until in his mind it had already happened.

The SNP has tough decisions to make on defence

From our UK edition

A few months ago, Colonel Alistair Scott Carns DSO, OBE, MC, RMR, MP was the talk of Westminster as a possible dark horse candidate for when, as seemed increasingly certain, Sir Keir Starmer was ejected from office. In June, the decorated Royal Marines reservist resigned as Minister for the Armed Forces on the same day that John Healey walked out as Defence Secretary. He did so in solidarity with Healey’s judgement that the Defence Investment Plan was underfunded and made service military personnel unsafe. Perhaps it was the fact that he resigned towards the end of the day when Healey had taken the plunge in the morning, or maybe it was simply a reflection of his inexperience, having only been an MP for two years.

It’s no surprise Burnham wants to delay boosting defence spending

From our UK edition

There was a grim inevitability about this. 'Whitehall sources', which is almost always code for the government rolling the pitch with the media to prepare for bad news, have suggested that a decision about when to increase defence expenditure will probably not be made for another year. The announcement will be part of the government’s Spending Review, which some had anticipated would be published in the spring. Now, though, the mood music from Andy Burnham’s administration is that it will take place in autumn 2027 so that it can sit alongside that year’s Budget.

RAF Fairford shows that Britain’s security must start at home

From our UK edition

We have to start with the ritualistic part of any consideration of an apparent attempted terrorist attack. We do not know the whole story behind the arrest of five men on terrorist charges near RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire on Sunday morning. Anyone old enough to have played Chinese whispers as a child knows how quickly information can become distorted or mangled. The ubiquity of social media has potentiated this a thousandfold. So we ought to be cautious. This is what we do know. At 12.45 a.m. on Sunday, Gloucestershire constabulary received a call concerning 'three suspicious vehicles' moving in the direction of RAF Fairford, a Ministry of Defence facility operated by the US Air Force.

Horses still have a role in the British army – for now

From our UK edition

The Ministry of Defence is a frustrating organisation, secretive, slow to change, often hidebound by process. In one regard, however, the department is always 110 per cent and reaching for the stars: the relentless positivity of its press office. It is not unreasonable to sense the Panglossian hand of the MoD press office behind a recent story in the Times, for which the paper’s New York correspondent, Will Pavia, went to woodlands outside Sandhurst. Here he observed elements of the Household Cavalry on exercise, in slightly surprising circumstances which he summed up elegantly: The soldiers were taking part in an exercise with a personnel carrier found to be capable of moving stealthily through rough, wooded terrain while emitting only a modest infra-red heat signature.

Germany’s growing Nato influence should shame Britain

From our UK edition

In defence and security, two adages form a powerful alliance: money talks, and you get what you pay for. These seem obvious truths, but when an issue is most effectively addressed by spending money, many politicians become remarkably open to magic bullets, untested theory and counterintuition. We are, however, now seeing the underlying power of spending emphasised at the 60-acre, glossily glazed Nato headquarters on Boulevard Leopold III in Brussels. It was reported over the weekend that the Chief of Defence of the Bundeswehr, General Carsten Breuer, has been chosen as the next chairman of Nato’s military committee. The 61-year-old Rhinelander has more than four decades of military service and became Chief of Defence in March 2023.

John Healey has failed the defence spending test

From our UK edition

Sir Keir Starmer’s premiership was already in crisis on 11 June this year when John Healey submitted his resignation as Defence Secretary. A quiet, unshowy, widely liked and respected Yorkshireman who had spent most of the past 25 years on Labour’s front bench, Healey had applied himself seriously to the defence brief, shadowing it for four years before being appointed to lead the Ministry of Defence in 2024. Healey resigned because he took the view that the Defence Investment Plan (DIP), the dreadfully delayed document which would set out the financial implementation of last year’s Strategic Defence Review, was simply inadequate. It did not provide for defence expenditure to rise quickly enough to match the threats facing the United Kingdom.

Giving 16-year-olds the vote would be absurd

From our UK edition

It is not always easy to guess what lasting effects a prime minister will have. With Sir Keir Starmer’s announcement that he is leaving parliament – he was only ever a backbencher for four months when first elected, and he clearly does not care for it – immediate thoughts are of an ignominious end. But Starmer may leave behind a profound change. Today the House of Commons will take the remaining stages of the Representation of the People Bill, then send it to the House of Lords for its scrutiny there. It is a hugely significant piece of draft legislation but has largely disappeared in the fog of everyday political war. Representation of the People Acts are generally major statutes because they regulate the electoral system and how the House of Commons is composed.

The Navy is right to be nervous about Russia’s maritime strength

From our UK edition

Russia's threats towards Britain in recent weeks of 'consequences' for its continued support of Ukraine have allowed the government to start warning the electorate of the scale and nature of the new dangers the UK faces – from Russia and from its allies. The baton has now been taken up by the First Sea Lord, General Sir Gwyn Jenkins. Appearing on the Defence Talks podcast, Jenkins warned of potential 'catastrophic events'. Nato, he said, would currently 'struggle to contain' Russia’s maritime strength in undersea warfare. This covers a wide spectrum, from conventional crewed submarines familiar from our conception of the Cold War to autonomous underwater vehicles – drones of the sea rather than the sky – operating from and in concert with crewed motherships.

Why would Germany want to help fund Trident?

From our UK edition

It wasn’t supposed to be like this. When the Cold War ended and the main rationale for enormous stockpiles of nuclear weapons largely disappeared, it seemed natural that their spread would become a thing of the past. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022 upended that Whiggish march of history. Throughout the conflict, President Vladimir Putin and his proxies, including the more-idiot-than-useful Dmitri Medvedev, have threatened the use of nuclear weapons, both tactical and strategic. He has hinted at strikes against Ukraine, Poland, Germany and the United Kingdom. In 2024, Putin amended Russia’s nuclear doctrine to lower the threshold for the use of nuclear weapons from facing an 'existential threat' to a 'critical threat to Russia’s sovereignty and territory'.

Why is Trump unhappy about military drills with South Korea?

Donald Trump has instructed his Secretary of War, Pete Hegseth, to 'substantially reduce' joint military exercises between the United States and South Korea. The two countries have had a bilateral defence agreement since 1953, and it was in defence of the government in Seoul that 36,500 American service personnel gave their lives during the Korean War. (It is worth noting that, despite the signing of an armistice at Panmunjom in July 1953, the conflict is technically ongoing.) Trump’s hazardous decision to downgrade military co-operation with and support for South Korea has come as a surprise.

Marco Rubio’s defence spending call is nothing new

This week Ed Miliband made his first trip to Washington D.C. since becoming Andy Burnham’s Foreign Secretary. He is 56 now, an MP of more than 20 years’ standing in his fourth cabinet role, yet there is something both boyish and gauche about him: the eternal younger brother. How would he fare as Britain’s envoy to President Trump and the cult of Maga? Miliband had been invited to Washington by Secretary of State Marco Rubio after the pair met at an Association of South East Asian Nations foreign ministers’ conference in the Philippines last month. It had been rumoured that the Trump administration was disappointed at Burnham’s selection of Miliband as Foreign Secretary, insofar as it is possible to imagine President Trump displaying much interest in the matter at all.

Is Reform serious about using the Navy to control migration?

From our UK edition

It is 70 years since Donald McLachlan’s Daily Telegraph leader urged prime minister Sir Anthony Eden to demonstrate 'the smack of firm government', and there has always been an element of the British electorate which thrills at the idea. This is a constituency Nigel Farage knows well and has long courted, the same one that looked at the chaos of the mid-1970s and wondered whether activist groups calling for a 'strong leader' might have a point. Reform UK has returned to this mood music once again as it sets out new policies on illegal migration. Its home affairs spokesman, Zia Yusuf, has been laying out the basic features of what is posturingly dubbed 'Operation Fortress': Britain is being invaded. Tory and Labour governments responded with a free ferry service and free hotels.

We still know little about Andy Burnham’s defence stance

From our UK edition

It was a bare-bones demonstration of politics as theatre. Today, the Prime Minister went to Barrow-in-Furness on the Cumbrian coast to visit BAE Systems Submarines. The shipyard there has built all but three of the Royal Navy’s nuclear-powered submarines – the others were turned out by Cammell Laird of Birkenhead – and are undertaking the construction of the four Dreadnought-class ballistic missile submarines which will carry Britain’s nuclear deterrent through the 2030s and beyond. The theatricality came from the fact that Andy Burnham went to Barrow to make an announcement which was inevitable and predictable.

Why won’t Burnham commit to the 2030 defence target?

From our UK edition

It is hard to imagine many people will miss Sir Keir Starmer now he has gone. Perhaps, like phantom limb syndrome, he will continue to cause pain even though it was generally agreed that amputation was the best option. This week, however, after new boy Andy Burnham delivered a windy address on social care in Golders Green, there were exchanges in the subsequent question-and-answer session which made it feel as if Sir Keir had never left at all. The new Prime Minister was asked whether he would commit to spending 3 per cent of GDP by 2030. He would not. Wes Streeting, the new Defence Secretary, has also refused to make such a promise, although he has said more vaguely that he would resign if the Defence Invetstment Plan is not ‘fully funded’.