Uk politics

Wednesday

Isabel Hardman

Media exposure was the worst thing that happened to Shamima Begum

From our UK edition

Why has Sajid Javid announced that he is revoking the citizenship of Shamima Begum? The 19 year old, who travelled as a teenager to join the Islamic State in Syria, has asked for 'forgiveness' from the UK, but last night the Home Secretary responded by saying he would be removing her status as a British citizen. He can do this, he argues, because she has a right to Bangladeshi citizenship, which means the government will not be rendering her stateless. A fair few people have suggested that this is about Javid's own ambitions in the Conservative party, as this move will likely appeal to the Tory grassroots. It has already earned praise from key newspapers like the Sun. But it's not just about the politics of this.

Lloyd Evans

The Independent Group is doomed to follow in the SDP’s footsteps

From our UK edition

It’s Day Three of the great insurrection against the tired, stale old politics. Only this morning, a fresh impetus was added to the movement. Chuka Umunna and his six escapologists have now been joined by four more asylum-seekers, one from Labour, three from the Tories. How these moral pioneers can bear to continue as members of our knackered and rotten parliament is unclear. The salary helps perhaps. The Houdinis made their first joint appearance at PMQs today and they tucked themselves up high on the opposition benches. The Speaker failed to invite any of them to open their gobs. A pity. The house would have hissed like a barbecue in a thunderstorm. Excited commentators have spoken of politics being reshaped, and of epochs fading and being reborn.

Isabel Hardman

Is the Independent Group already heading for a split?

From our UK edition

The three Conservative defectors to the Independent Group gave a notably upbeat press conference this lunchtime. It was quite a contrast to the sorrowful tone struck by the seven Labour MPs who announced they were leaving on Monday. Heidi Allen claimed that she was ‘so excited and in a way that I haven’t felt since I was first elected'. She also cracked jokes about the three amigos as she opened the event.  It has never been fully clear why Allen joined the Conservative party over any other, but Anna Soubry and Sarah Wollaston both argued that the organisation had been transformed in the years since they were first elected. Like the Labour defectors, they wanted to suggest that their values had not changed, but their party had.

James Forsyth

The Independent Group does more damage to Labour than the Tories

From our UK edition

Today’s PMQs was a rather surreal occasion. Sitting high up on the opposition benches were the new Independent Group of MPs. But none of them tried to ask a question and both Jeremy Corbyn and Theresa May chose to ignore the issue. Instead, we were treated to May repeatedly raising the defection of a Labour councillor in Brighton. I still think that this new group does more damage to Labour than the Tories. I doubt that many Tory voters will be attracted to a party led by the most ardent advocates of a second referendum. But the defection of these three Tory MPs risks creating an impression that the two main parties are as bad as each other.

Isabel Hardman

Lib Dems to Independent Group: please be our friends

From our UK edition

In a parallel universe, the MPs who've left the Labour and Conservative parties this week would be joining the existing centrist party that shares their views on Brexit. But the Liberal Democrats haven't had a look in, despite Vince Cable and before him Tim Farron claiming that they'd spoken to would-be defectors. Cable has just issued a statement saying that 'there is clearly some very radical changes now afoot' and offering to work with the new Independent Group. He said: 'We will hold out the hand of friendship to the independent MPs with whom we already have a good working relationship.' The Lib Dems have accepted that they have failed to provide a home for these despairing MPs.

Brendan O’Neill

The shame of those siding with Shamima Begum | 20 February 2019

From our UK edition

At last, having kept pretty shtum about it for the past few years, the virtue-signalling set has mustered up some sympathy for women caught up in the horrific Isis vortex.  Unfortunately, though, their sympathy isn’t for the Yazidi women who were burned alive after refusing to become sex slaves for Isis jihadists. Or the Kurdish women who found themselves living under the brutal misogynistic yoke of the Isis empire. Or the Syrian and Iraqi women whose husbands and sons were beheaded for adhering to the wrong branch of Islam. No, their sympathy is for a woman who supported the movement that did all those things. Who provided moral succour to the Isis barbarians.

Isabel Hardman

Theresa May ‘saddened’ as Heidi Allen, Anna Soubry and Sarah Wollaston quit the Tories

From our UK edition

Theresa May has said she is 'saddened' by the decision of Heidi Allen, Sarah Wollaston and Anna Soubry to leave the Conservative party and join the new Independent Group of MPs. In statement released in the past few minutes, the Prime Minister said: 'I am saddened by this decision – these are people who have given dedicated service to our party over many years, and I thank them for it. 'Of course, the UK’s membership of the EU has been a source of disagreement both in our party and our country for a long time. Ending that membership after four decades was never going to be easy. 'But by delivering on our manifesto commitment and implementing the decision of the British people we are doing the right thing for our country.

The Spectator

Full text: Heidi Allen, Anna Soubry and Sarah Wollaston’s Tory resignation letter

From our UK edition

Dear Prime Minister. It is with regret that we are writing to resign the Conservative whip and our membership of the Party. We voted for you as Leader and Prime Minister because we believed you were committed to a moderate, open-hearted Conservative Party in the One Nation tradition. A party of economic competence representing the best of British business, delivering good jobs, opportunity and prosperity for all, funding world class public services and tackling inequalities. We had hoped you would also continue to modernise our party so that it could reach out and broaden its appeal to younger voters and to embrace and reflect the diversity of the communities we seek to represent.

Katy Balls

The Tory defections to the Independent Group could help Corbyn

From our UK edition

After days of bad news for Labour over the decision of several moderates to quit and form The Independent Group, it's now the turn of the Tories. Three Conservative MPs have today resigned the party whip to join the group. In a joint letter to the Prime Minister, Anna Soubry, Sarah Wollaston and Heidi Allen say they no longer feel at home in a party where the policies are so 'firmly in the grip of the ERG and DUP'.  They will now join eight former Labour MPs in the newly formed group – bringing the total size up to 11. While the news has shocked some Conservatives, these three MPs were the politicians who were seen as the most likely to quit.

Steerpike

Watch: George Galloway compares journalist to Goebbels

From our UK edition

George Galloway has just waded into Labour's anti-Semitism row and it is safe to say his intervention won't do much to calm things down. The firebrand former politician said the claims of anti-Semitism agains the Labour party were a lie – and he then compared the Sky News journalist interviewing him to Josef Goebbels. Here's what he said: GG: 'It is really a black-op what is going on here. This is pure Goebbelian propaganda.' Niall Paterson: 'We've just mentioned Luciana Berger, do you think it is entirely relevant to talk about Goebbelian propaganda?' GG: 'I do.' NP: 'We've got a Jewish Labour MP leaving because of anti-Semitism.' GG: 'I don't believe she is leaving because of anti-Semitism, I believe you want people to believe that and the Goebbels is you.

Tuesday

Katy Balls

Could a meaningful vote come as early as next week?

From our UK edition

Is a Brexit breakthrough imminent? The talk in Westminster tonight is that the government could soon have something to present to MPs on the Irish backstop. Geoffrey Cox – the Attorney General – has been in Brussels this week working with EU officials on a legally binding change. He has managed to charm some on the EU side and – in a sign of his commitment to the cause – is said to have threatened to sleep in the corridors if that's what it took to get a deal done. At Cabinet today, Cox urged caution, telling colleagues there is still some way to go – yet Cabinet sources are optimistic that a concession is coming in the form of a codicil. So, what will it look like?

Isabel Hardman

Joan Ryan quits Labour and joins the Independent Group

From our UK edition

Another Labour MP, Joan Ryan, has tonight announced she is leaving the party to join the Independent Group. This is significant, and not just because it creates a sense of momentum. Ryan is the first Labourite to leave who wasn't involved in the months of secret planning meetings. She was, until fairly recently, arguing that the best thing to do would be to stay and fight to change the party back. Now, she has gone, releasing a potent statement about her reasons. Those reasons include what she calls 'the scourge of anti-Jewish racism', which 'simply did not exist in the party before his election as leader'. She argues that she has 'fought for as long as I can within the Labour Party'.

James Forsyth

Sajid Javid is wrong to strip Shamima Begum of her British citizenship

From our UK edition

Sajid Javid’s decision to strip Shamima Begum of her British citizenship leaves me deeply uneasy. I can understand why a Home Secretary charged with keeping the public safe would want to do whatever possible to keep this woman out of the country. But Begum was born in this country, grew up here and was educated here. This, surely, makes her British. As a country, we should want to take charge of investigating her and, if the evidence is there, prosecuting her. After all, she offended against the ties that bind when she headed from this country—a liberal democracy with the rule of law—to go and serve in a so-called caliphate that offended against the values we hold most dear.

Steerpike

Watch: Angela Smith blames ‘funny tinge’ comment on tiredness

From our UK edition

Angela Smith unwittingly became the story of the day yesterday when she referred to people of a 'funny tinge' on the BBC's Politics Live. Smith apologised – but still the story is dragging on. Today, the MP was asked to explain her comments, and she came up with a new excuse: she was tired. Here's what she said: 'Look, I never meant to say that. I misspoke really badly. I was very tired at that point. I had had six hours of press engagement and I was very tired. I was very tired. I misspoke really, really badly.' Mr S isn't sure that the answer to all this is for Smith to do more 'press engagement'...

Stephen Daisley

Luciana Berger’s departure is the beginning of the end for Labour

From our UK edition

Manny Shinwell knew how to deal with anti-Semites. Born in London’s East End, reared in Glasgow, and once jailed for inciting a riot on Red Clydeside, the pipe-smoking pugilist was a tough, proud Jew. During a debate in parliament in 1938, Shinwell (then Labour MP for Seaham) was jabbing at the government when Tory MP Robert Bower heckled: ‘Go back to Poland’. Shinwell got up, crossed the floor and thumped Bower clean in the face, then turned to the Speaker and said: ‘May I make a personal explanation?’.  Eight decades later, his great-niece has delivered another bloody nose to the face of anti-Semitism.

Robert Peston

Tom Watson’s intervention spells trouble for Jeremy Corbyn

From our UK edition

The second most important political act yesterday was the impassioned declaration of near UDI by the deputy leader of the Labour Party, Tom Watson. His sorrowful response to the resignation of Berger, Umunna, Leslie, Smith, Gapes, Coffey and Shuker was that they were wrong to resign but they were correct to identify that the party he loves has lost its way, especially over anti-Semitism. Watson was in effect setting himself up as shop steward of a parliamentary Labour Party that feels almost totally detached from the Labour leader and the shadow cabinet.

Monday

James Kirkup

Corbyn’s cheerleaders are wrong to sneer at Which? magazine

From our UK edition

First, a confession. Because I try not to spend too much time on Twitter, I sometimes miss “the story that everyone at Westminster is talking about” and struggle to keep up with village gossip. Worse, I lose track of the minor characters the ceaseless opera of poisonous soap, or fail to recognise them for what they are.  For instance, I only recently discovered that Aaron Bastani is actually a real person and not, in fact, someone’s parody of something. Sorry. Today on political Twitter, it seems that “everyone is talking” about Dr Bastani and Which? magazine, in the context of the new Independent Group of Labour MPs.  Dr Bastani suggested that the new group is “Pro Which? Magazine” in a tweeted list of its other supposed crimes.

Alex Massie

In praise of the Labour splitters | 18 February 2019

From our UK edition

The first thing to note is that it’s not about policy. The not-so secret seven MPs who left the Labour party this morning have not changed their policy preferences. They have not become Tories. Nor have they even become liberals. They could, with little difficulty, endorse much of the Labour party’s 2017 manifesto without compromising themselves in the slightest.  Because this break, this rebellion, this journey into exile, is not about policy. It is about character and values and so many of the other things the Labour party believes it holds dear to the extent it often behaves as though it thinks it owns a monopoly on these things.

Steerpike

Watch: Angela Smith apologises over ‘funny tinge’ gaffe

From our UK edition

The Independent Group is only a few hours old but already one of its leading members has made a blunder on air. Talking about race on the BBC's Politics Live, Angela Smith said: 'It's not just about being black or a funny...tin...from the BME community' Oh dear. Angela Smith has since apologised for her comments, saying that she 'misspoke': https://twitter.com/angelasmithmp/status/1097518807357288448?

James Forsyth

Will any Tory MPs join the Independent Group?

From our UK edition

Is this a split in the Labour party or something more? At today’s launch, Chuka Umunna was clear that the Independent Group want to attract MPs from parties other than Labour. Tory party sources admit that they ‘would not be surprised’ if some Tory MPs were to join this new group. Right now, the values of this group seem fairly—for want of a better word—Blairite. The addition of any Tory MPs would make this group more ideological heterodox; and show if it can carve out a distinctive intellectual position. Politically, it would also mean that it was not just Labour who are split.