James Delingpole

BBC1’s Honey is a dog’s breakfast

The latest example of the Bridgerton tendency, full of anachronisms, infelicities and gross implausibilities

James Delingpole James Delingpole
Kurt Fischer (Nate Mann) and Martha Schmitt (Ann Skelly) in Honey. Image: BBC / Sid Gentle Films Ltd / Ludovic Robert
issue 21 November 2026

I’m currently working on a screenplay set in 1066 about a precocious young woman who is absolutely sick of the patriarchy. She wants to become a housecarl in the elite royal guard but thanks to sexism, homophobia and racism all the white Anglo-Saxon males sniff that she’s unsuitable. But then one day, while she is practising her two-handed long-axe skills in a forest clearing, who should ride by but the King’s clever and beautiful wife (‘It’s Ealdgyth. But everyone calls me Edie’) and, a few exchanged hair-styling and make-up tips later, an enduring friendship is born. If the BBC won’t commission it I’ve no doubt Netflix will.

And that’s the problem, isn’t it? Those of us who care about anachronisms, infelicities and gross implausibilities in historical and political drama are now so heavily outnumbered by audiences who don’t know any better that our opinion no longer counts. We just have to sit there, muttering to ourselves, and take it.

In The Diplomat the other day, for example, the young, female, sexy US ambassador Kate Wyler (Keri Russell) was forced to take refuge at Windsor Castle with her handsome, twinkly-eyed husband Hal (Rufus Sewell), who now, equally realistically, happens to be US vice-president. But because the exterior shots were filmed at Burghley House, it looked nothing like Windsor Castle. Not even after the script had tried to gaslight us otherwise by having a red-tunicked officer call out to his bearskinned men on parade: ‘Windsor Castle guard! Left!’

The latest annoying example of this Bridgerton tendency is Honey, a semi-comedy series set in Cold War Berlin about an undercover female MI6 agent who totally cannot bear that she has to live according to the terms and conditions of her 1980s setting. So instead, she behaves like a young woman who has parachuted in from the mid-2020s and the assumption is that we’re all going to be OK with this.

Maybe if heroine Martha Schmitt (AKA Carolyn Martens) were a genuine time traveller it would be quite an entertaining conceit, a bit like Life On Mars behind the Iron Curtain. But she’s not. Rather, she is simply the creation of someone – up-and-coming Northern Irish scriptwriter Emma Moran – who wasn’t born when the Wall came down and appears to have little feel for or interest in all this ancient history.

For decades, and well within the lifetimes of many of us, up to 17 million East Germans were spied on, starved and immiserated by their vile communist regime. But for Moran, the period is just a convenient excuse to decorate her show with amusing poodle-perm haircuts, a fashionably retro 1980s electro soundtrack and communist nostalgia-chic iconography, while blithely rehearsing all the usual ‘you go, girl!’ pop-cultural shibboleths of the 2020s.

I called Honey a semi-comedy because it can’t make up its mind how serious it wants to be. On the one hand, people get shot in the head, have their throats slashed, or can be heard screaming from the cells of the Stasi’s grim concrete HQ. On the other, Schmitt gets smuggled into East Berlin curled under a blanket on the back seat of her handler’s car, in a pantomime sheep dog costume.

If you are a fan of Killing Eve, then Honey is everything you deserve

Later, in the bar where she works undercover as a tarty waitress, Martha seduces a hunky Tom Selleck type called Kurt (Nate Mann) who turns out to be CIA. Their bosses decide they should collaborate, posing as a married couple. So they go to a bridal outfitter, where the assistant asks how they met. Kurt is about to come up with a cover story which is bound to be clumsy because he’s a man. Luckily, Martha is able to butt in and explain that she met him after he’d just been mugged by a gang of schoolgirls and they were laughing at him because his cold-shrivelled willy was so small.

Eh? Is this what a spy, under continual threat of arrest, torture and death would say while attempting to keep a low profile in 1980s East Berlin? And if it’s not – if the point is that everything we see is to be taken as a great big joke, or at least that Martha is allowed to do whatever she wants without consequence – then where’s the jeopardy and what exactly is the point of the period setting and Le
Carré backdrop?

This fatal failure of tone and register is unfortunate because you can tell that buried beneath this dog’s breakfast is some real talent. Ann Skelly is superb in the lead role; Moran likely has numerous charming, quirky screenplays ahead of her. But they are both completely wasted on this silly, cloth-eared project which badly needed a grown-up – probably a male one of a certain age – to nip it in
the bud.

Apparently Honey also serves as the prequel – or ‘origins story’, as they say – for Killing Eve. If you are a fan of Killing Eve, then Honey is everything you deserve.

Comments