Madeline Grant Madeline Grant

Andy Burnham’s mask slipped at PMQs

Andy Burnham at PMQs (Getty images)

Well readers, this is my last PMQs for a little while. I have to say that nothing has prepared me for the world of a screaming, greedy creature with no concept of its own dignity and a complete dependence on others better than watching the House of Commons. The gallery should be filled with pregnant mothers every Wednesday.

Burnham is showing his true colours as the pressure builds

Today was a prime example. Things started scratchily: a Labour MP who looked like both Penn and Teller at once, but who turned out to be the man who unseated Liz Truss, asked a planted question about supporting farmers. The Tory benches went – to use a technical term – bananas.

The Great Triviality was fresh from a tetchy Sky News interview in which he’d told a female journalist to ‘shush’. This also didn’t bode well. Mrs Badenoch began with a simple question: did Mr Burnham intend to cut welfare this parliament? Cue a multi-minute waffle about new opportunities, the efficacy of producing a ‘landmark report’ and how wonderful Alan Milburn was. The question, unsurprisingly, went unanswered. We had to wait for the ten-year plan.

Ten years was too long, Mrs Badenoch said, to wait to sort out welfare. She made the quite obvious point that in ten years ‘young people’ would cease to be very young at all. Faced with this mathematical problem, on the opposite bench Louise Haigh raged. She wore a look on her face which was both angry and confused: the same one she presumably flashes shoelaces or the childproof caps on bleach.

The argument continued – via the inevitable tedious segue into who was more nation-wreckingly incompetent, the Tories in 14 years or Labour in two. ‘What he wants is the vibes of welfare reform without actually doing anything’ Mrs Badenoch said. That is the essence of Burnham – government by vibe alone. Not since the Beach Boys has there been someone whose career has been more dependent on Good Vibrations.

As if to prove this right, Burnham then kept on repeating that he was giving young people hope. I mean if the face of hope is the ‘championship manager you fail to identify in a pub quiz’ look of Alan Milburn, then young people might as well just pray for a meat grinder war in Europe by means of a way out of it all.

Burnham went on to say that he believed in an ‘in the round’ consideration of the Milburn report. The Burnham government’s over reliance on management consultants is now public knowledge and increasingly evident in how Burnham speaks and acts. As Mrs Badenoch put it, ‘they want to have reviews and to consult and to create reports and then they release a landmark report…and it all takes another ten years’.

Now, a cynical voice might reasonably point out that the Tories had much longer than ten years and they did exactly the same thing. It was hardly ‘à la lanterne’ for the engorged priestly caste of management consultants during the days of George Osborne, was it? But Mrs Badenoch makes a reasonable point that the Prime Minister is clearly spending so much time around these people that his language is becoming affected. And so when he opens his mouth we are treated to an ‘in the round’ assault on the basics of English usage.

The exchange between the two leaders ended, appropriately then, in a fight about terminology. ‘Let me just explain something for the Prime Minister,’ Mrs Badenoch beamed in her most deliberately provocative way, ‘growth comes from business not from government’. This riled Burnham. He accused her of asking ‘self-serving questions’ in a ‘patronising tone’.

It was perhaps a sign that Mr Burnham felt annoyed that he indulged Sir Ed Davey. This week the Liberal Democrat leader had the audacity to accuse other people of being zombies obsessed with Brexit. Given basically every question he asks is about the EU this seems a little rich. Normally Mr Burnham bats these weird little questions away as if they were offers by the weird stinky kid to play on his football team.

Instead, the Prime Minister went into a strange diatribe – seemingly addressed to some Tory backbenchers – about how deliberately signing us up to an EU punishment clause would “help with the weekly shop”.

We also saw the return of the obvious bottom crawler-questions by some of the more substandard Labour backbenchers. One about how wonderful Clwyd is and another about how world hunger will be solved and world peace achieved by ‘youth development hubs’. This too might be a sign that Mr Burnham is expecting a rockier ride over welfare than he intended when he defenestrated Sir Keir.

All in all, it was a gravelly and gnarly performance. Mr Burnham is perhaps showing his true colours as the pressure builds. Today was the first time the doe-eyed, bus fare-obsessed exterior has cracked and the irritable Labour apparatchik underneath has begun to show.

Still, there were some moments of light relief. Amazingly a Lib Dem MP refused to use the term ‘fishermen’ when asking about fuel costs for boats. Consequently, she spent an entire question referring to ‘fishers’ to the visible confusion of MPs, who presumably thought she meant ‘fissures’. I will miss these moments of raw absurdity while I am on leave; the House of Commons does them better than any other; not even childrearing can come close.

Comments