Ask a Democratic grandee such as James Carville, Bill Clinton’s old campaign director, for his thoughts on life and politics and one would get some version of the following. He would quite like everyone involved with MAGA to go to prison, but does not want to see transgender athletes competing in his granddaughter’s swim meet. He knows businessmen and entrepreneurs socially and has a certain crude reverence for the “grit” it takes to succeed in that sphere of life. He is against “cancellation” – especially the cancellation of rich and famous people for verbal flubs and faux pas – but is also against the attempts to force universities and employers to stop doing it. He is opposed to an uncontrolled southern border in the abstract, but opposes still more the practical steps needed to deport illegal aliens.
This worldview, such as it is, was the true victor of this month’s midterm elections. MAGA was routed and many of its leaders will now face congressional investigations. At the same time, three states – including Washington – passed ballot initiatives that would bar transgender athletes from K-12 girls’ sports, and California’s voters rejected a 5 percent wealth tax on the state’s billionaires. Colorado has passed a similar transgenderism measure, but has rejected a proposal to make state officials cooperate with ICE on deportations. These results, when combined, reflect the general outlook of Carville, but also the outlook of the John F. Kennedy School of Government, the Army General Staff, Joe Rogan, Nancy Pelosi, Jamie Dimon, and the characters on Curb Your Enthusiasm. They are privately thankful to MAGA for making it safe to tell off-color jokes again, but not thankful enough to spare them prison.
One can see a new center-ground beginning to emerge. If the Democratic party retakes the White House in 2028, Puerto Rico will likely be admitted as a state, as will, absurdly, Washington, DC, forever locking the GOP out of power at a congressional and presidential level.
As Carville now urges, the Supreme Court could be enlarged to give it a liberal majority. Anti-MAGA trials will be the party’s substitute for redistributive economics, as will moratoriums on data centers – which will increasingly be built elsewhere, just as the products of American companies are now manufactured elsewhere. Higher interest rates will likely prevent a repeat of the Inflation Reduction Act, but they will also bar the door to the left by making their ideas too costly to fathom.
Following the example of European governments, much will be made of the need to reshore supply chains and rearm in order to face Russia. The major technology concerns which worked with MAGA will be intermittently and half-heartedly harassed – the 2023 Department of Justice discrimination suit against SpaceX being the model. Big Tech will be deemed too important to seriously damage, of course, though Elon Musk may be another matter. The border will remain “closed” to avoid upsetting footage on the CBS Evening News, though many asylum seekers will simply be flown in instead, as the Haitians of Springfield, Ohio, were; deportations from the interior will mostly cease. Wall Street bankers will still be able to say the words “retard” and “pussy.”
There is a popular constituency for this type of politics but it numbers in the low millions. Most live somewhere in Northern Virginia, work in government or in the defense industries and find Stephen Colbert very funny. All the same, the American state tends to reflect the prejudices of such people in the absence of a strong countervailing force. The judgments of the current Supreme Court are a good example: no to student debt relief, but yes to birthright citizenship. The midterms represent a reversion to this mean, now that MAGA has done it the favor of excising some of its less defensible parts.
MAGA bears a good deal of responsibility for its return. Aside from the Iran war, the Trumpists’ mistake was to style their movement as a defense of normality. Trump’s new Chief of Staff Stephen Miller recently told an audience at the State Department that MAGA was about the preservation of “normal, healthy, ordered living.”
This rather fraudulent social peace is unlikely to last. It will be much too cynical for its own good
In his “Techno-Optimist Manifesto,” the Trump-aligned venture capitalist Marc Andreessen declared for “an absolute rejection of resentment.” Rather than a movement of social upheaval, MAGA, with the exception of Trump the man, increasingly views itself as a managed flushing-out of society’s enemies in order to preserve the whole. Of course, the principal beneficiaries of this are the people who already manage this society – people like Carville – who are thus relieved of having to carry out the distasteful task themselves.
This rather fraudulent social peace is unlikely to last. It will be much too cynical for its own good, governed only by the arbitrary prejudices of old, rich Democrats. It will be a sleazy Thermidorian era dominated by figures such as Gavin Newsom, people with an exaggerated sense of their own deviousness and ability to “balance” different forces – “abundance liberals,” the Democratic Socialists of America, neo-MAGA, and the podcasters – to their own benefit.
Having no foundation in principle, it will fall to the first ideological challenger, whether that is a resurgent MAGA or more likely the DSA. War is not to be ruled out either; if it should come to it, the new “prairie populism” that leading Democrats now speak of would be little more than a device for corralling Americans into a great-power conflict with Russia. In either case, the cries of “retard” and “pussy” in the New York bourses may at last fall silent.
Comments