In a recent interview, Robert Pattinson suggested that he likes ‘taking the jobs of younger actors’. But beating James Bond is only the first hurdle facing Britain’s out-of-work young. Almost 981,000 people between the ages of 16 and 24 – more than one in eight – are Neets: not in employment, education or training.
Increasingly, the problem is not temporary unemployment but permanent inactivity. Six in ten have never had a job. Almost half report having a disability; the proportion with mental-health problems has risen from 8 per cent in 2012 to around 20 per cent today. The estimated cost to the economy is £125 billion per year, with expenditure on youth disability benefits alone expected to reach £9 billion by 2037.
Britain has become an international outlier. Our youth unemployment gap – the disparity in employment rates between younger and older people – is the largest in the G7. A decade ago, our proportion of Neets was close to the EU average. Last year, only Romania’s rate was higher. Perhaps spurred on by a desire to keep up with the continental Joneses, Labour resolved to tackle the crisis. This week’s report into Neets, from the reliably Blairite former minister Alan Milburn, has much to commend it.
Milburn aims to ensure that Britain is a ‘working state’ rather than a welfare one. His recommendations are wide-ranging: introducing a new ‘Youth Allowance’ and a ‘Youth Opportunity Service’, expanding mental health support. In the longer term, Milburn aims to shift spending to encourage young people into work, with an aim of £1 on employment support for every £2 on benefits.
Milburn’s party often forgets the ‘labour’ in its name to pander to the dependent. As such, he is courageously honest in his report that some will lose out, that a right to training or support must be conferred with a responsibility to accept opportunities offered and that disability benefits should be reserved for the genuinely needy. Unlike Keir Starmer’s haphazard, penny-wise and pound-foolish attempts to trim the welfare bill, Milburn’s approach is comprehensive. Yet his report is less than the sum of its parts.
If Milburn’s reforms are implemented, they will save only £200 million a year by 2036 from a working-age welfare bill expected to reach £200 billion. But even if confronting the Neets crisis is treated as a moral endeavour to rescue the young from a life of depressing idleness rather than a savings exercise for a hard-pressed Treasury, Milburn fails to match his own ambitions. He is held back by an unwillingness to challenge the Labour policies that keep young people from employment.
Hospitality and retail are major employers of 16- to 24-year-olds, yet businesses in these sectors have been hit by Rachel Reeves’s hike to national insurance contributions and Angela Rayner’s additional employment regulation. The minimum wage for 18- to 20-year-olds has risen by more than a third since 2024. Making young people more expensive to hire inevitably means fewer are employed. Milburn stops short of calling for these policies to be fully reversed, afraid of upsetting the ministers that he wants to win over.
Instead, Milburn indulges recommendations for reform to one of the few areas of the state where we outperform our European neighbours – our schools. He wants us to judge schools by a new ‘ready-to-work standard’ for 16-year-olds, reintroduce modular examinations and place ‘oracy’ at the heart of the curriculum.
Adopting Milburn’s education proposals would undermine his valuable work elsewhere
Milburn and his team have, perhaps understandably, calculated that the stronger medicine for the government in the welfare proposals will be sweetened by endorsing the changes set out for schools by Andy Burnham and Lucy Powell, the Education Secretary. But each of these measures dilutes rather than strengthens the power of schools to help students flourish. Diverting Ofsted from a focus on academic standards slows school improvement. Introducing vague and subjective new accountability measures blurs the focus on rigorous testing and real achievement. Modular examinations were abandoned for a reason – they undermine deep learning and make it easier to indulge in the gaming of results. And ‘oracy’, as Lara Brown has pointed out in this magazine, is a tired obsession of progressive academics who want to move away from proper literacy, replacing grammar with chatter.
The virtues that Milburn wishes to instil in students – self-discipline, punctuality, team-spiritedness, resilience – will not be fostered by plans to take curriculum time away from academic learning and replace it with windy exercises in the ‘personal development’ teaching his report endorses. Valuable school time is already taken up with Personal, Social, Health and Economic Education which has become a playground for faddish theorising. Work-readiness comes from schools that prioritise hard work in the classroom, on the sports field and in keeping up exemplary standards of behaviour. Readiness for the responsibilities of adult life should suffuse every minute of the school day and all of a student’s activities – not be parcelled into an hour of phatic goodwill on a Friday afternoon.
Often, failure to fully accept a report’s recommendations is treated as cowardly, but adopting Milburn’s education proposals would undermine his valuable work elsewhere. If, as he suggests, more than seven in ten Neets do not want a life of dependency, the priority should be making it as easy as possible to hire them, rather than undermining school reforms that other countries envy and are seeking to emulate.
Comments