From the magazine

The smugness of the turkey haters

Robert F. Moss
Freedom From Want by Norman Rockwell, 1943 (US National Archives)  
Cover image for 11-23-2026
EXPLORE THE ISSUE November 23 2026

Thanksgiving is coming – and it’s time to talk turkey. It’s a surprisingly controversial topic. When it comes to the Thanksgiving menu, many Americans are not just indifferent to turkey but outright hostile to it. (I happen to be married to one such grouch.) They say things like, “For me Thanksgiving is all about the sides,” which is the culinary equivalent of watching the Super Bowl for the ads.

The turkey-haters can be pretty smug about it, too. “Stop pretending you like turkey,” a Business Insider editorial demanded a few years ago. “It’s no good on Thanksgiving, or any other day.” A decade ago, Adam Rapoport, then editor in chief of Bon Appétit, implored readers to “Just say no to turkey,” insisting that “no one loves turkey” and claiming the best thing about Thanksgiving is the gravy. (He is no longer editor in chief of Bon Appétit, though that had nothing to do with his position on gravy.)

I suspect this malice stems from two factors: the over-engineered state of the modern turkey and the long-standing practice of oven-roasting it, and especially oven-roasting it with stuffing.

Today’s commodity turkey is an ungainly, unnatural fowl, manipulated through selective breeding to have massive, cottony breasts and to weigh two to three times more than old-fashioned birds. If you stuff one with a bread-based dressing, which is basically a Petri dish for bacteria, you have to roast it till the stuffing has reached a safe 165 degrees, by which point the legs are going to be dried to a crisp and the thick breasts woefully overcooked.

No wonder Americans started switching off the oven and looking for a better way.  Back in the 1980s, a bunch of gourmets down in the Cajun country of Louisiana, perhaps generously lubricated with Dixie Beer, had the brilliant idea of spicing up Thanksgiving by deep-frying the bird.

They took a portable crawfish cooker – the kind with a giant aluminum pot over a butane burner – and filled it with melted lard instead of water, then lowered the poor turkey into the bubbling cauldron using a rope. This was supposed to result in a more tender, juicy turkey than oven-roasting, but I suspect the real appeal was the thrill of all that sizzling oil and the sense of imminent danger should a splash encounter the open flame. You are not 100 percent guaranteed to burn down your garage if you deep-fry your Thanksgiving turkey, but it’s not out of the question. You will, however, be 100 percent guaranteed to render the outer parts of the meat crusty and flavorless and the interior dry as cardboard.

Many driveway chefs try to prevent that dryness by injecting seasoned butter into the carcass with a syringe before frying. This, in my experience, results in interior meat still dry as cardboard but interspersed with little pockets of salty, spicy goo. On the plus side, you might actually end up burning your garage down and spare yourself from having to eat the damn thing.

I have a better suggestion this Thanksgiving. Why not barbecue the bird? This may ruffle a few feathers, but I maintain that turkey is the most underrated of barbecue meats. Properly cooked, smoked turkey is tender and juicy and its mild flavor lets the rich accent of smoke really shine. Plus, in these days of ever-soaring beef prices, turkey remains quite affordable. You can acquire one for a poultry sum.

First, spatchcock the bird. It’s fun to say and not hard to do. Just place the turkey on a large cutting board, breast-side down, and remove the backbone by slicing down either side with a pair of heavy kitchen shears or a sharp butcher’s knife (but be sure to mind those fingers!).

Next, flip the turkey over and press down on the breastbone to flatten the bird. That compactness will help the meat cook more evenly and stay juicy. Also, the skin will be all on the top side and turn out much crisper.

It’s a community experience too as smoking a turkey encourages everyone to gather outside the grill

There’s no need to mess about with fancy liquid brines or complex rubs. Just dry brine the turkey by sprinkling it with kosher salt on both sides, then place it on a sheet pan and refrigerate the bird until you are ready to cook it. Leave it for at least two hours, but overnight is better.

You can cook the turkey low and slow on a backyard smoker, if you wish. Go for 325°F for two to three hours, until the meat reaches an internal temperature of 160 degrees. I prefer to do it hot and fast on a kettle grill, banking the coals to one side for indirect heat and putting the bird on the other, roasting it, covered, at around 450 degrees till it’s done.

The result, I am convinced, will make for a far superior centerpiece for your Thanksgiving table. You’ll create more of a community experience, too, since smoking a turkey encourages everyone to gather outside around the grill. (A nearby cooler of beer doesn’t hurt, either.) Your guests will gobble it up and have something to be genuinely thankful for this year.

Comments