We live in a one-way shame culture
Anyone who has ever published a book and been dismayed by an anonymous review online will have cheered inwardly at the story of David Wilson. Professor Wilson is a criminologist and historian who has published several books. Each of his books has received a scathing one-star review on Amazon from a pseudonymous critic calling himself 'Junius'. The latest was posted, he says, within a few hours of his new book being published: 'abysmal... avoid... low quality... poor research... would disgrace an undergraduate dissertation'. Such reviews aren’t just words: they can cause material harm to books in Amazon’s ranking system.