Katy Balls

Katy Balls

Katy Balls is The Spectator’s former political editor.

Wednesday

Katy Balls

What the Sue Gray row is really about

Another day, another story about Sue Gray. Today the BBC reports the details of Sir Keir Starmer's chief of staff’s salary. Gray is paid the handsome sum of £170,000 a year – £3,000 more than her boss, the prime minister. She therefore earns more than any cabinet minister or Tory predecessor in the role. In a sign of how some in Whitehall feel about her pay, a source tells the BBC’s political editor Chris Mason: It was suggested that she might want to go for a few thousand pounds less than the prime minister to avoid this very story. She declined. A Cabinet Office spokesman responds: It is false to suggest that political appointees have made any decisions on their own pay bands or determining their own pay.

Tuesday

Katy Balls

Where do the Lib Dems go next?

11 min listen

Liberal Democrat Conference wraps up today in Brighton. It could well be the happiest conference we visit this season with the party riding high after winning 72 seats at the election. The challenge that they face now is improving on that number, providing some opposition to the Labour party and protecting their new Surrey MPs once the new Tory leader is decided. We have heard Ed Davey speak passionately on social care, but can they carve a distinct position on other big policy issues, such as Europe? Or the NHS?  Katy Balls speaks to James Heale and Stephen Bush, associate editor of the Financial Times.

Monday

Katy Balls

Do the Starmers need a personal shopper?

12 min listen

This weekend we had another twist in the story involving Labour donor Lord Alli, who was caught up in a 'cash for access' scandal a couple of weeks back. It now seems he has forked out the thick end of 20k on clothes and glasses for Keir Starmer and his wife. Foreign sec David Lammy was on the Sunday media round and gave a less than convincing defence of the prime minister and Lady Victoria. Has the PM broken the rules already?  Also today, Keir Starmer is in Rome meeting Italian prime minister Giorgia Meloni today where they will be discussing boat crossings and Italy's deal with Albania. It’s a timely first engagement for Starmer’s new border security commander Martin Hewitt. Will he succeed in 'smashing the gangs'?  Oscar Edmondson speaks to Katy Balls and Fraser Nelson.

Katy Balls

Can Starmer’s border security commander ‘smash the gangs’?

Keir Starmer finally has a chair for the government's Border Security Command. When the Prime Minister first entered government, the Home Office advertised for someone to head the new unit, which ministers hope will be their answer to 'stopping the boats'. Overnight, Martin Hewitt has been named as the successful applicant. He is a senior police officer who previously served as chair of the National Police Chiefs’ Council. Of all the jobs Starmer has to offer it may prove to be the hardest – and most thankless During that time Hewitt suggested that politicians ought to refrain from calling police 'woke' as 'it is an easy one-liner that will get you a bit of a headline, and it’s great in social media, but I don’t think it’s particularly helpful'.

Saturday

Katy Balls

Is Gordon Brown back?

14 min listen

Last week, there was a surprise visitor to the Treasury: Gordon Brown. The former prime minister and chancellor secretly returned to his old digs for the first time since he left office 14 years ago. According to onlookers, Brown visited his old office as he caught up with the new chancellor – and his friend – Rachel Reeves. What was discussed? Many have speculated that among the topics on the agenda was the winter fuel allowance, a policy ushered in by Brown and now amended by Reeves.  Elsewhere, Tony Blair has been doing the media rounds promoting his new book and giving his thoughts on leadership. Should Keir be listening? Are interjections from former prime ministers ever helpful?  James Heale speaks to Katy Balls and Patrick Maguire.

Friday

Katy Balls

Will Starmer call Putin’s bluff?

10 min listen

Keir Starmer and David Lammy are in the Washington for a planned foreign policy summit with Joe Biden. They will principally be talking about a new deal regarding the use of UK long range missiles in Russia, a move which Putin has warned would constitute an escalation of the war and the formalisation of NATO's involvement. Also up for discussion is support for Israel after the foreign secretary announced a partial embargo on arms. Is the UK diverging from the US on foreign policy? James Heale speaks to Katy Balls and Keir Giles, fellow at Chatham House and author of Who Will Defend Europe?Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Katy Balls

The Lucy Powell Edition

27 min listen

From working on the 1997 general election campaign, to serving in the shadow cabinets of three leaders, politician Lucy Powell has been a prominent figure in the Labour Party for many years. First elected to parliament in 2012, she was appointed Leader of the House of Commons and Lord President of the Council following Labour's general election win in July. As Women With Balls returns from a summer break, Katy Balls talks to Lucy about why she transferred out of Oxford University, what her motivations were for serving under Jeremy Corbyn, and why the 2024 general election felt like Glastonbury festival. Lucy also talks about her focus for the newly formed Modernisation Committee.  Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

Thursday

Katy Balls

Is Gordon Brown back?

Last week, there was a surprise visitor to the Treasury: Gordon Brown. The former prime minister and chancellor secretly returned to his old digs for the first time since he left office 14 years ago. According to onlookers, Brown visited his old office as he caught up with the new chancellor – and his friend – Rachel Reeves. To Brownites, news of this meeting has been received with glee. Is their main man back in the fold? The conversation between Brown and Reeves is part of a pattern for this government: New Labour old-timers returning to share their wisdom with first-time ministers. In the Department of Health, Wes Streeting has Alan Milburn and Paul Corrigan while Dan Corry, Brown’s former head of the No. 10 policy unity, is leading a review of environmental regulation.

Wednesday

Katy Balls

Trump vs Harris debate: who won?

14 min listen

Last night saw the first Trump vs Harris debate and the consensus seems to be that Harris came out on top. She managed to avoid sticky issues about her political past and goaded Trump into some rambling and – at times – outrageous remarks. What did we learn?  Also today, we have had new figures on the economy with GDP flatlining for the second month in a row. Does this vindicate Rachel Reeves' tough decision on the winter fuel allowance?  Katy Balls speaks to Kate Andrews and John McTernan.  Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Tuesday

Katy Balls

Tory leadership latest: ‘Melmentum’ runs out

13 min listen

It's been a busy day in Westminster today. Labour avoided a large scale rebellion on the winter fuel allowance and Mel Stride was eliminated from the Tory leadership race – not to mention the sale of a certain weekly politics magazine. Oscar Edmondson discusses with Katy Balls and James Heale.  Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Katy Balls

The winners and losers from today’s Tory leadership vote

The names of the final four candidates left in the Tory leadership contest are in. Mel Stride has been eliminated from the contest, with just 16 MP backers. That leaves Robert Jenrick, who leads with 33 backers, Kemi Badenoch in second on 28 MPs and James Cleverly and Tom Tugendhat who are tied in third place with 21 backers each. The four leadership hopefuls will now head to party conference where they will use the four-day event to try to prove to their parliamentary colleagues and the grassroots that they have what it takes to lead the party in opposition. Stride’s exit was largely expected Stride’s exit was largely expected.

Monday

Katy Balls

Will Rachel Reeves soften the winter fuel cut?

14 min listen

Tomorrow MPs will vote on Rachel Reeves’ decision to cut winter fuel payments for pensioners who aren’t eligible for pension benefits. We spoke on this podcast on Friday about the pressure that Labour is under from all sides on this, but the temperature has increased over the weekend with the trade unions getting involved. What's the latest?  Also on the podcast, there have been some allegations of 'dark arts' during the first round of voting in the tory leadership contest, and possible vote sharing. Is there any truth to these rumours?  James Heale speaks to Katy Balls and Fraser Nelson.  Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Katy Balls

Will Rachel Reeves hold her nerve over the winter fuel cut?

Will Rachel Reeves hold her nerve over the winter fuel payment? That’s the suggestion inside government ahead of a Commons vote tomorrow on the proposed cut that will see only pensioners eligible for benefits receive the £300 payment. Already this morning, government sources have had to play down the idea that there could be a change in course after a Home Office minister appeared to imply the plans could be watered down. Addressing MPs on Monday evening at a meeting of the parliamentary Labour party, Reeves urged her colleagues to get behind her: 'There are more difficult decisions to come. I don't say that because I relish it. I don't - but it is a reflection of the inheritance that we face'. However, the party’s wider backers are voicing their concerns over the move.

Saturday

Katy Balls

Coffee House Shots live: the Starmer supremacy

47 min listen

Join Fraser Nelson, Katy Balls and Kate Andrews, along with special guest Jonathan Ashworth, for a live edition of Coffee House Shots recorded earlier this week. They dissect the first few weeks of the new Labour government and look ahead to the policies autumn, and the budget, might bring. Having surprisingly lost his seat at the election, how blunt will Ashworth be? The team also answer a range of audience questions, including: how big of a welfare crisis is the government facing? Would – and should – they reform the NHS? And could the challenge Reform UK poses to traditional parties continue to grow?  Produced by Patrick Gibbons and Megan McElroy.

Friday

Katy Balls

Does Rachel Reeves need an ‘escape route’ on winter fuel?

14 min listen

Fraser Nelson and Katy Balls join James Heale to look ahead to a crucial week for Labour. On Tuesday, Parliament will hold a binding vote on the changes to winter fuel allowance - how are Labour expected to deal with this? Former shadow chancellor Ed Balls, and husband of the current home secretary Yvette Cooper, has argued that Labour need an 'escape route' from the policy. What can we read from this intervention? And how influenced are the government by the spectres of George Osborne and Liz Truss? Also on the podcast, Fraser talks about both the problems facing Germany, and the surprisingly successful measure that Sweden has introduced, to deal with net migration.

Thursday

Katy Balls

The rise of the Gaza Five

What should the Tories do about Nigel Farage? The leadership candidates have made many speeches and written many columns explaining how they would answer this question. Yet at Kemi Badenoch’s campaign launch on Monday, she dismissed it. Instead, there was another contingent of new MPs she was more concerned with: the pro-Gaza independents. ‘When everyone was worried about the election of Reform MPs, I was far far more worried about the five new MPs elected on the back of sectarian Islamist politics, alien ideas that have no place here,’ she said. ‘[That is] the sort of politics we need to defeat – and defeat quickly.’ This represents the introduction of a new sectarian politics to Britain If Badenoch had waited a few hours, she would have had even more cause for concern.

Wednesday

Katy Balls

Tory leadership race latest: Priti out

14 min listen

The first round of the Conservative leadership race has seen Dame Priti Patel eliminated with the fewest votes. Robert Jenrick came out on top but, with a second vote taking place on Tuesday, where could Patel's supporters go? Who could get eliminated next? Will 'Melmentum' build? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Katy Balls and James Heale. Produced by Patrick Gibbons and Oscar Edmondson.

Katy Balls

The two winners from the first Tory leadership round

Priti Patel is out of the race to be the next Tory leader. In the first knockout round of the contest, the former Home Secretary received the lowest number of votes at 14, behind Mel Stride who was in fifth place with 16 votes. It is Robert Jenrick who has the most to celebrate – after coming out on top in the ballot with 28 votes. His supporters have said this week that they believe he is ‘nailed on’ to make the final two, who are then picked by the membership. While he still needs to gain more support, this result will add to the sense that Jenrick is a serious contender. With another knockout round next week, the battle is now on to hoover up Patel’s supporters As for the other candidates: the initial bookies’ favourite Kemi Badenoch came second with 22 votes.

Tuesday

Katy Balls

Is the UK still a ‘staunch ally’ of Israel?

16 min listen

The fallout continues from the UK's decision to suspend some arms sale licenses to Israel. Defence Secretary John Healey insists the UK remains a 'staunch ally' of Israel, yet the decision has been criticised by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as 'shameful'. What has the domestic reaction been to the government's decision, and who is it designed to please?  Patrick Gibbons speaks to Katy Balls and Michael Stephens, associate fellow at RUSI.  Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

Katy Balls

Britain’s arms crackdown on Israel could end up pleasing no one

Is the UK still a 'staunch ally' of Israel? Defence Secretary John Healey insisted so on the broadcast round this morning. But his claim is coming under scrutiny following the government's decision to suspend 30 out of 350 arms export licences to Israel, thereby affecting equipment which includes parts for fighter jets, drones and helicopters. Foreign Secretary David Lammy revealed the news on Monday, telling the Commons that it was 'with regret' that he had concluded for certain arms exports 'there does exist a clear risk that they might be used to commit or facilitate a serious violation of international humanitarian law'. It comes as part of a review by the new government of Israel's compliance with international law.