As Andy Burnham himself was aware in his introductory jokes at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet, there was a significant disjunction between his famous ‘Makerfield test’ and his surroundings and attire. If I were a Reform or Tory spin doctor, I would tweet out clip after clip of him in his white tie and tails excitedly telling his constituents (and the rest of us) that ‘Next year, we will be in the world’s spotlight as we take on the Presidency of the G20. What an opportunity that is for us at just the right moment’; and/or ‘Britain is not in a position to turn its back on a potential deal that could add up to 0.4 per cent to GDP. That is what is at stake at Friday’s UK-EU Summit in Brussels and I pay tribute to Keir Starmer for laying the groundwork.’ As MPs used to say sarcastically about political statements which failed to connect: ‘That’ll go down well in the Old Dog and Duck.’ Today, unfortunately, there are no Old Dog and Ducks left anyway.
It should be a rule of government pinned up like a biblical text in every government and parliamentary office which says: ‘Unless legislation is necessary, it is not necessary.’ This test should be applied to every bill. Only if it passes it should it be presented to parliament. The test is needed more than ever because so many bills nowadays are the productions of obsessive lobbies which have won the ear of government, sometimes via networks of jobs and party contributions. Recent examples include the numerous attempts to ban the import of hunting trophies, the promised ban on trail hunting (a sport which Labour ministers positively advocated when its MPs voted to abolish hunting proper), the nationalisation of the governance of the Reserve Forces, the weird, undead Chagos Bill, and most bills known as ‘X’s law’. The logic in the mind of lobbies is that a new law can ban bad things and ensure good things. That is not necessarily logical at all. And because it is considered glorious to get a new bill through parliament, enthusiasts are not interested in using existing law or seeking a non-legislative remedy. The latest such legislation is the Conversion Practices Bill. It would take many, many hours (as is happening in committee) to chase down all the difficulties which this bill raises, but two central points should be held in mind. The first is the extreme shortage of modern evidence of such practices. The second is the problem of unintended (or possibly, which is worse, secretly intended) consequences. The lobbies, in this case, Stonewall, adrift from its original LGB moorings, don’t care about this – Stonewall has held no fewer than 15 formally acknowledged meetings with ministers since the Labour victory in 2024 – but legislators must. Hence the intervention of Lady Cass, of the Tavistock Clinic report on trans, who was hustled by the government for her support, but has now withdrawn it. Her anxiety about conversion practices does not blind her to the danger that the bill could lay professionals open to reputational attack, false accusation and even criminal charges.
Another bill being touted is one to abolish Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs). This would surely have perverse effects. If workplace victims of sexual harassment know that no NDA will be available, the bar of cost and reputation to launching a complaint will be much higher, with all the risk and misery that court or tribunal might involve. Legislators need to understand that the best can sometimes be the enemy of the good.
This column has often complained about the presumption of guilt, rather than innocence, in modern sex cases, as witness so many false accusations of paedophilia. In theory, that is possible with Russell Brand. The fact that he did so many dreadful things does not automatically mean he is guilty in every case. So I find it reassuring that the jury in his case found him innocent on some counts as well as guilty on others. It suggests they were thinking hard and fairly about the evidence put before them.
One must not say, obviously, that David Walliams is guilty of the offences alleged against him. But I hope he would agree that it would be quite a good parody of his most famous joke to write a sketch in which a middle-aged celebrity makes an indecent suggestion to a 16-year-old girl and she replies, in that special Walliams voice: ‘Teenager says No.’
Have you noticed the suggestion creeping in that the late Professor Jason Arday did nothing wrong and is the victim of a ‘hi-tech lynching’? His fate was very sad and could have been avoided if those appointing him had tested him with any rigour. But there is multiple evidence, collected by more than one scholar, of plagiarism. Of the series of claims Arday made about his achievements, I have counted at least 15 which are – I express this gently – extremely hard to believe. These points must be maintained if the Cambridge authorities tasked with reporting start to pour gallons of whitewash over what actually happened.
Like almost everyone who has a satnav, we are grateful. I used to pride myself on my ability to find my way with map alone but that was, to adapt Shakespeare, the expense of spirit in a waste of time. There is one minor problem, which is pronunciation. There are several Welsh place-names where, in desperation, it becomes the techno version of John Redwood singing the Welsh National Anthem. As for our own dear Hastings, it pronounces it ‘Hystings’, which we think snobbish and unfunny. Travelling to and from Norfolk last weekend, we encountered ‘Swarfham’, ‘NewMARKET’ and ‘GT Yarmouth’, the G and the T separately pronounced, as in ‘Mine’s a G&T’. I hope Rupert Lowe, the town’s hyperactive Member of Parliament, can sort this out. If asked, how would satnav pronounce ‘GT Britain’?
Comments