Eliot Wilson Eliot Wilson

Labour is running out of time to prepare Britain for war

Andy Burnham (Credit: Getty images)

House of Lords select committees are not entirely like their Commons counterparts. They operate in similar ways, but they are quieter, more stately, draw on more experienced membership, have less of an eye on the following day’s headline and tend therefore to attract less attention.

In the past week, however, two Lords committees have published reports on issues of immediate interest and importance, bound up in the government’s recent warning that Nato could face a direct military threat from Russia by the end of the decade. Last week, the Industry and Regulators Committee published Ready for action in 1,000 days? Forging a new partnership between government and the defence industry. This week has seen a report from the National Resilience Committee entitled Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience.

There is a lot packed into these reports. They will not have a wide popular readership but the government is expected to respond to select committee reports within two months. Having worked for at least eight committees across both Houses, I know that these responses can be proper and earnest engagement or a hastily penned fobbing-off letter.

The government knows what the threats could be and how seriously we should take them

There are two issues raised which seem particularly pressing and in tune with the wider news agenda. The Industry and Regulators Committee calls for a closer working relationship between government and the defence industry. Few could argue against that. It does, however, address the government’s chosen headline-grabbing timescale for war.

Defence Secretary Wes Streeting wrote in the Daily Telegraph last month that the UK has ‘a little over 1,000 days… to be ready with our allies to fight and win’ against Russian aggression. Defence needs more money, but that will always be true. But the committee argues that money is not the only element required.

The government should engage earlier and more meaningfully with industry, to share knowledge and build a mutual understanding with them so that they can develop innovative solutions rather than wait for government specifications.

The Ministry of Defence has already changed its procurement processes with the appointment of a National Armaments Director, Rupert Pearce. There is not much evidence that the effect has been revolutionary yet, and time is at a premium. The committee believes that a civil servant alone cannot move the needle and will require support and impetus from the Defence Secretary. But it also calls for this to be ‘reinforced by the Prime Minister in a strategic statement on defence to ensure industry is able to provide UK defence readiness’.

This buy-in and support from the top is essential across the defence sector. The Strategic Defence Review (SDR) of June last year said that a ‘whole-of-society approach is essential’ for defence and security and a ‘national conversation on how we do it is required’. Sir Keir Starmer welcomed the SDR and claimed to accept all of its recommendations, including a ‘two-year series of public outreach events across the UK, explaining current threats and future trends’. Under Starmer, however much he talked about defence, there was never a dialogue. The ‘national conversation’ simply never happened.

If we now have less than 1,000 days before a potential conflict, any further delay amounts to unforgiveable dereliction of duty by the government. Yet Burnham seems only able to tackle the subject if it comes in a multibuy with more familiar topics. In the summer, he announced spending £8.4 billion on the fourth stage of building the four Dreadnought-class submarines which will replace HMS Vanguard and the three other boats as platforms for the UK’s independent nuclear deterrent. But all he could articulate was more jobs, higher pay and greater opportunities.

‘There is a path for you into a reindustrialised Britain,’ he told young people, ‘and it starts with the apprenticeships we are funding through this investment today.’

This simply isn’t enough. We are facing – as the National Resilience Committee reports – changes to our way of life and our expectations on a scale which has yet to be fully appreciated. Its report skilfully picked an example which would resonate universally to illustrate its argument.

Britain imports an alarming proportion of ‘essential medical supplies, including blood, medicines and medical equipment’, yet this is hardly noticed. When the government launched its Be Ready campaign earlier in the autumn to encourage people to store vital supplies for several days, it was little more than a larky, well-meaning student awareness campaign: the Prime Minister enthused about baked beans, while Angela Rayner had said her emergency supplies would include mascara, concealer and a bottle of Sauvignon Blanc.

Baroness Coussins, Chair of the National Resilience Committee, expressed concern that the UK depends heavily on China and other countries for supplies of antibiotics. She pointed out that there is no longer any significant production since GlaxoSmithKlien closed its plant at Ulverston in Cumbria last summer. All of these concerns point in one direction, which the National Resilience Committee explicitly enunciated: ‘the government appears complacent and the UK is underprepared.’

It is now nearly 18 months since the Strategic Defence Review and the ‘national conversation’ it advocated for has not begun. No UK Defence Readiness Bill was mentioned in the King’s Speech and is rumoured to be deferred until later in this parliament. Next year we are also promised a review of the Civil Contingencies Act 2004, but that could be another year lost.

The government knows what the threats could be and how seriously we should take them. Yet it cannot, or will not, be honest with voters. How many people recall that Iranian-linked hackers shut down a UK power plant for four days in July this year? Or paid attention to a Russian drone attack at Leipzig airport in August which was intended to destroy Ukrainian cargo aircraft? We may not be at war with Russia, but we are not at peace. The government does us no favours if it lets us sleep soundly in our beds. If hostilities break out, we must be prepared.

Written by
Eliot Wilson

Eliot Wilson was a House of Commons clerk, including on the Defence Committee and Counter-Terrorism Sub-Committee. He is contributing editor at Defence On The Brink and senior fellow for national security at the Coalition for Global Prosperity

This article originally appeared in the UK edition

Topics in this article

Comments