Tom Slater Tom Slater

How the mob tried to silence Nathan Cofnas at Oxford

Protestors clash with police at Oxford (photo: Getty)

Free speech prevailed at Oxford last night. But only just. Nathan Cofnas, the American “race realist” academic and exposer of Jason Arday, gave a talk at Oriel college at the invitation of Oxford’s Reform UK student society. 

The brittle authoritarianism of today’s ‘progressives’ has left them intellectually disarmed – incapable of understanding, let alone challenging, ideas they oppose

His subject? DEI in higher education. The room? A third full, reportedly. But not due to a lack of interest or publicity. Thanks to Cofnas’s now-radioactive reputation, the event sparked demonstrations from students and the perma-protesters of Stand Up To Racism. Masked activists were filmed blockading the event, forcibly preventing people from entering the college, while police were either overwhelmed or nowhere to be seen.

Cofnas, following previous brushes with cancel culture, was propelled to international infamy by the case of Jason Arday. He was the first to go public with the Cambridge professor’s long history of fabulism and academic fraud. Arday claimed to have overcome mutism, illiteracy and racist intimidation reminiscent of the Jim Crow South. Cambridge University, desperate to burnish its DEI credentials, lapped it up – rewarding Arday’s lies and (as it turns out) plagiarism with a professorship.

Before Cofnas was tipped off by a whistleblower, Arday had successfully silenced his critics in academia and journalism, via baseless accusations of racism, menacing legal letters and spurious reports to the police. Cofnas, who believes there are genetically derived differences in intelligence between racial groups, was hardly the best messenger. But he was willing to take the initial flak.

He – along with much of the media, who were able to run with the story once his blog hit the internet – was, despicably, blamed when Arday was found dead at his home in August. Cofnas was suspended from his post at Ghent University in Belgium, before being reinstated following the intervention of the US ambassador.

Oriel came under almighty pressure to cancel last night’s event. That it declined to do so points to one of the few legislative successes of Britain’s last Tory government – the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023, which beefed up the duties placed on universities to uphold free speech. The Act was referenced by Oriel in its own tepid, back-covering statements.

Still, the protests were a reminder that the culture in our universities and on the left has hardly moved on from the heady days of BLM, 2020 and what we had hoped was “peak woke.” Hundreds gathered outside the college, pastel-hued mullets blowing in the wind, Covid masks affixed to their little faces, screeching about “fascism” in an infantile and unhinged manner. One video shows ethnic-minority students, keen to attend the talk, being blocked and told they “should know better.”

The hysteria of the protestors is born of intolerance, their intellectual weakness betrayed by their demands for censorship. Photographer and social-justice warrior Misan Harriman gave an impromptu speech at the demonstration. “The intersectionality of all of our lived experiences is what makes us beautiful,” he said. Just as cancel culture hasn’t gone away, nor have the wispy, cod-philosophical slogans that accompany it. Harriman insisted Oxford “show a duty of care” to its students, apparently by protecting them from opinions they dislike.

These activists are blissfully unaware of how much their tactics are backfiring. Cofnas’s name has been forged in cancellation. In 2024, he was dismissed from a position at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, following backlash to a blogpost in which he argued that, under a truly meritocratic system, black people “would disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sport and entertainment.” (He is appealing his dismissal.) Since Arday’s death, he has been transformed into a full-blown folk devil. Cofnas is now infinitely more influential than he would have been had students and academics opted to ignore him or perhaps bothered to argue against him. 

They couldn’t even if they wanted to. The brittle authoritarianism of today’s “progressives” has left them intellectually disarmed – incapable of understanding, let alone challenging, ideas they oppose. And just as the woke left has radicalized, embracing racial identity politics and censorship, a new generation of right-wingers has begun to look afresh at ideas, like race realism, once confined to the fringes. Those of us who still cherish egalitarianism are in for a bumpy ride.

Oxford, we (still) have a problem. Those ugly scenes on the cobble stones last night made that crystal clear. Nathan Cofnas might not have been denied his right to speak, but many more were denied their right to listen, by a mob who have surrendered their ability to think. 

Comments