As soon as the news dripped out last week that Alan Milburn was going to propose stripping certain benefits from 18- to 24-year-olds, my TikTok feed was inundated. Whether by Chinese state design or an algorithm trained on my journalistic interests, I was served up post after post of hysterical PIP (Personal Independence Payment) recipients who claimed Milburn and Andy Burnham – if he adopts today’s proposals – were going to kill them.
The bed-ridden TikTokers are not cheating the system. They genuinely believe they are too sick to work
These TikTok sickfluencers all had three things in common: an odd haircut, obesity and genuinely impressive articulation skills. They also shared a conviction that employment isn’t just difficult but impossible. Smart and well-spoken enough to make their case to thousands of online followers, they’d surely breeze through most interviews. Yet they’re certain they’ll never work. Instead they have condemned themselves to lives lived from their beds, totally dependent on state support.
They are not alone. At last count some 981,000 – more than one in eight – young people are classed as not in education, employment or training – the so-called Neets. In Europe, only Romania finds itself in a worse crisis. Six in ten Neets have never worked, and an increasing number find themselves in this predicament through long-term sickness. Costs for the taxpayer continue to pile up, with youth disability benefits on course to hit nearly £9 billion by 2037.
Today’s Milburn report tries to change that. Its remedies include a new target for 90 per cent of five-year-olds to be ‘school-ready’ (surely this should be 100 per cent?); doubling apprenticeships over the next decade; faster mental health support; and a new ‘Youth Opportunity Service’.
The benefits system for under-25s should be torn up too, Milburn argues, with plans to replace the Universal Credit health element with a ‘Youth Allowance’ and PIP with a new payment for those facing significant additional costs as a result of disability. Those with the most severe conditions would receive more generous support.
These measures, Milburn says, will help 440,000 young people into work by 2036 and deliver £3.6 billion in annual welfare savings in a decade’s time.
But they won’t come cheap. The report suggests that an initial half a billion quid should be made available next year to ‘kickstart the reform programme’ by ‘reprioritising existing spending’. From then on, billions in (mostly unfunded) employment support outweigh welfare savings for ten years before we hit break-even and the welfare bill begins to come down.
If it does something to tackle what is a human – as well as economic – tragedy, then it’s to be welcomed, even if some of the measures sound like more unwelcome red tape.
But government schemes, spending and reforms alone will not be enough to fix the crisis we’re in. We have to start asking more difficult questions of wider society about how we got here.
In Milburn’s speech today, and in the foreword to his report, he’s clear in his view that this is not a ‘snowflake generation’ or a ‘generation that lacks resilience’. He also boldly claims that he hasn’t met a single Neet who wants to be a Neet.
Yet the data in his report suggests a different diagnosis. Some 130 pages in, he quotes the earlier report into ADHD and autism by Professor Peter Fonagy, which, whilst finding that behavioural conditions were not being ‘overdiagnosed’ in the sense that mental distress did not exist, did find that real-world prevalence of these conditions is ‘largely flat’ and that we are heading towards a risk of ‘misdiagnosis and overdiagnosis’.
Earlier, on page 20, he points out that the staggering ‘growth in benefits far outweighs the actual change in ill-health and disability among young people’. He concluded that our children need ‘the confidence and resilience to cope with the normal anxieties and setbacks of growing up’.
So resilience does seem to be an issue after all, and resilience is something that I think we’ve lost. We have become a society where discomfort is to be avoided at all cost rather than tackled head on.
It’s true that child and teenage mental health had been worsening for a long time before Covid, but normalising staying away from school and work when things get tough sure as hell poured petrol on a flickering flame. So-called persistent absence, the report points out, is still two-thirds higher than before the pandemic, with severe absences (missing more than half of the school year) up 172 per cent.
Indeed, yesterday, in anticipation of today’s report, the BBC ran a story about children so anxious about going to school that they would vomit or faint in the playground each morning, with the solution being home schooling or alternative provision schools. But avoidance surely only makes things worse.
Anyone who has suffered with anxiety – probably everyone, given it seems inherently part of the human condition – will know that anxiety begets anxiety. The more you avoid the thing that makes you feel scared, sick and sweaty, the stronger those feelings get and the harder the anxiety is to overcome. Sufferers also learn, as they age, that exposure therapy is the only really successful experience. Doing the thing that makes you feel sick – and yes, maybe being sick – but not – in the end – dying or something almost as terrible happening while you do it is really quite the effective feedback loop.
Anyone who has suffered with anxiety – probably everyone, given it seems inherently part of the human condition – will know that anxiety begets anxiety
Alan Milburn can’t teach people that. Ministers can’t reinstil that resilience in British young people. So, it’s over to the rest of us. But it means asking tougher questions.
It means refusing to accept the absurd statistic from the government’s Family Resources Survey which suggests one in four of us are disabled – up 3.8 million in a decade. It means asking why, in the same period that disability benefit claims have increased 46 per cent, actual disability has increased by only 17 per cent. It means asking whether the phrase ‘unseen disability’ should just mean conditions like epilepsy and Crohn’s rather than anxiety and depression. It means tackling avoidance culture ourselves.
How we perceive our own health matters too. Milburn finds that nearly half of Neets claim a long-term health condition compared with the one in four in the general population. They may well truly believe they are sick, enabled by GPs, but it is their jobs, and ours, to convince them that that isn’t the case.
It also means accepting that work isn’t always fun. Milburn’s review finds that 73 per cent of Neets don’t want to be Neets and that only 4 per cent are doing nothing. But that surely means a good chunk don’t express that desire – flying in the face of Milburn’s remarks.
The same poll in the report also finds that 61 per cent could move forward now ‘if the right opportunity became available’. But shouldn’t taking any opportunity be the norm? Talk to young unemployed people and it is not uncommon – whatever Milburn says – to find those who feel their humanities degree makes them overqualified for hospitality work, for example. Gone is the idea that it’s easier to get the job you want from the job you don’t like than from no job at all.
There have to be jobs for young people to take though. While Neets need to be encouraged to take any job going, and while the benefits system reforms need to remove any disincentive to work – save for the genuinely sickest – ministers need to stop disincentivising employers from hiring people. Retail and hospitality, Milburn says, provide 37 per cent of jobs for 16 to 24-year-olds. Yet this is the part of the economy worst hit by national insurance hikes and minimum wage rises.
As the report points out, the minimum wage for 18-20 year olds is up 65 per cent in five years. In April 2025 alone it rose by over 16 per cent compared with 6.9 per cent wage growth for the average worker. You don’t need to be a Nobel prize winning economist to know it’s young and first time workers who lose out if there’s no longer a discount for hiring them.
Milburn’s economic diagnosis is the right one, but he doesn’t seem to want to prescribe the toughest cure ruling out a cut on employer National Insurance – probably the single most harmful policy to young people this government has enacted. Instead, he calls for a ‘glide path’ for 21 to 24 year olds working in retail and hospitality ‘when fiscal conditions allow’.
If adopted, lots of what Milburn’s report proposes will surely work. It has to. His reforms to the welfare system and removal of work capability assessments in favour of genuinely needs-based benefits are welcome. And his desire to make Britain a ‘working state’ rather than a welfare one is a vision we all share. But policy can only do so much. The bed-ridden TikTokers are not cheating the system. They genuinely believe they are too sick to work. But we have encouraged and incubated this belief because we’ve allowed the very idea of resilience to wither. It’s on all of us to put that right.
Comments