The Spectator

Portrait of the week: Burnham’s Brexit claims, Boots’s £6.7bn sale and the Pope’s cancer diagnosis

Home Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, said on a podcast: ‘I asked the question coming to Downing Street, “Well, was there interference in the 2016 referendum from Russia?” I’ve had the clear answer that, yes, there was.’ Sir Ken McCallum, the director-general of MI5, said during questions after an annual speech: ‘I’m a little bit worried that [if] we all stay in this debate for another few days, the Russian trolls who didn’t appear to do all that much at various points over the years, they’ll be delighted they are front-page news once again.’ The Prime Minister told the House of Commons that whatever happened at RAF Fairford, Gloucestershire, on 27 September was ‘almost certainly directed by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard’.

Donald Trump is no friend to conservatives

Perhaps P.J. O’Rourke put it best. When explaining, in 2016, why a self-declared ‘Republican Party Reptile’ was voting for Hillary Clinton over Donald Trump, O’Rourke admitted that the former first lady was ‘wrong about absolutely every-thing’. But at least she was ‘wrong within normal parameters’. A decade later, conservatives are paying the price for ignoring O’Rourke’s advice. Donald Trump has weakened the western alliance and undermined America’s constitution; he has demeaned himself, his office, his country and, perhaps most of all, his supporters. With Republicans facing a congressional reckoning next month, it is time for conservatives to dis-avow the President and face up to the damage that he has done.

Letters: Prisons are for punishment

Little cheer Sir: I found the headline on Tim Shipman’s excellent article (‘Tories’ reasons to be cheerful’, 10 October) more than a little misleading. There was little to cheer me up. Although Kemi Badenoch is growing in political stature week by week and her approval ratings have increased, the Conservative party has much ground to make up. In the Holborn and St Pancras by-election, the Tories came a poor third and saw the share of their vote drop compared with 2024. The Tories’ main problem is that they have no allies. Reform UK, Restore Britain and the Lib Dems will not work with them. Labour, on the other hand, would sell its soul to the devil and join with the Greens.

Livestream: Masters of War

From Napoleon’s conquests across Europe to Lord Salisbury’s diplomacy during the height of the British Empire and Churchill’s wartime strategy, our panel will explore how history is shaped disproportionately by great figures making crucial decisions at moments of crisis. On Thursday 15 October, The Spectator’s editor Michael Gove and assistant editor Madeline Grant sat down with Andrew Roberts, just days after the publication of his latest book, Napoleon and His Marshals, to explore the legacy of some of modern history’s greatest and most controversial wartime leaders. Watch the livestream of this event here.

Portrait of the week: The US withdraws its bombers, Kemi promises a ‘Britannia shield’ and Christa Pike survives her execution

Home Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, said there were ‘strong indications’ that Iran played a part in the events at RAF Fairford. The United States withdrew all its bombers from Fairford, which President Donald Trump of America said had been because of ‘some threats’. A dual Iranian-British man aged 27 and a 22-year-old British national were arrested in Westminster on suspicion of the preparation of terrorist acts in connection with Fairford. Two Iranian nationals appeared in court charged with plotting ​acts of terrorism involving the use of a homemade bomb to attack the Jewish community in Manchester at the behest of a figure believed to be based in Iran; the court was told both men had come to Britain from Europe ​in boats.

Kemi Badenoch knows the right way forward

Last year’s Conservative party conference was a difficult one. Reform UK was leading the polls; the local election results had been as painful as the general election the year before; and the story at conference was not Kemi Badenoch’s successes, but speculation over Robert Jenrick’s attempts to replace her. Adversity, however, proved her friend. The past year has seen Badenoch’s leadership blossom, with confident public appearances, a by-election victory in Aberdeen and Jenrick’s fortuitous exit to Reform. This week, she stood up in Birmingham as a leader truly in command of her party – and with a plausible route back into government. There are still a great many obstacles to overcome.

Letters: Don’t worry about AI novels

A right old mess Sir: Although Andy Burnham seems to be turning to Old Labour, what he is really turning against is Thatcherism and the shift towards neoliberalism. Your editorial (‘The return of Old Labour’, 3 October) rightly identifies low growth, ballooning government debt, high energy costs, low investment, inadequate preparation for technological change, uncontrolled migration and invertebrate defence as current concerns. All can be attributed to governments since 1980. It is no good saying that government itself is unequal to the task. Who has been responsible for this? A winter is coming all right. What is less clear is whether the right has renounced its faith in false gods and has the ideas and people to solve the problems it has lumbered us with.

Livestream: Free Speech Debate

On Monday 12 October we hosted the Free Speech Debate. Britain has been a bastion for freedom of expression for centuries – but can the country still claim that title today? There are now countless examples of free speech being suppressed: from arrests for social media posts and the ‘shadow banning’ of online accounts, to sackings for expressing opinions at work and the shutting down of public protests. Many argue that there are legitimate boundaries to free speech that must be enforced to prevent ‘harm’ – but where should the line be drawn? Our speakers debated the motion: This house believes Britain no longer has free speech.

Watch: The Nixon Revival

From our US edition

The Spectator held its first event in Manhattan on Wednesday September 30 — and you can watch the full discussion above. Known to many as “Tricky Dick,” Richard Nixon has often had his legacy reduced to the scandal that brought his presidency crashing down: a break-in at the Democratic National Committee headquarters, a criminal cover-up, then his resignation. But what if his story is far more complicated? Why has J.D. Vance described Nixon as a “new icon” for young conservatives? And why do some Gen Zers now see him as an “America First” populist pioneer?

Portrait of the week: the end of the triple lock, odd happenings in Gloucester and Pope Leo in France

Home Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, announced the end of the pensions triple lock from 2030, when the link with earnings would be broken. Wearing a suit but no tie, he told the Labour party conference: ‘I will make a break with the direction of the past 40 years.’ He said that houses would be confiscated if left unoccupied or if rented out but not well maintained. He said he would ‘repeal Margaret Thatcher’s ideological ban on public ownership of water companies’; he would reduce electricity prices by establishing the Great British Grid, a publicly owned company. He tearfully promised a National Care Service, after a review by Baroness Casey of Blackstock. Ties with the EU would be explored and electoral reform would be in the next Labour manifesto.

Andy Burnham begins the long march left

When the Social Democratic Party was launched in 1981, its prospectus was dismissed witheringly by the liberal thinker Ralf Dahrendorf as a plan for ‘a better yesterday’. Andy Burnham has gone one better. He plans to rerun Labour’s last term in office. But this time with feeling. The Prime Minister’s address to his party conference was many things – fluent, passionate, moving, politically effective. But one thing it was not: forward-looking. The quality of the delivery invited comparison with Tony Blair but, unlike Blair, our current PM was not promising modernisation. He was instead seeking to revisit the Blair years and pursue the road not taken by Labour in 1997 – the long march left.

burnham

Here today

Power seems immutable A never-ending dance Entirely indestructible Each blow the merest glance Yet what was indisputable Now looks much more like chance.

Which old rockers are still touring?

Orange prize What is so special about the Garvaghy Road to Ulster Unionists? The area around Portadown attained significance for loyalists thanks to the Battle of the Diamond in 1795 when Protestant and Catholic forces clashed at a road junction. Twelve years later, Orangemen started their annual march from Portadown to the church at Drumcree, returning via the Garvaghy Road, which was then in the countryside. It wasn’t entirely peaceful then, with a Protestant magistrate remarking in 1835 that the Orangemen had gone out of their way to pass by a Catholic chapel, stirring up the locals. But the march became more of a flashpoint after a council estate inhabited mostly by Catholics was built along the Garvaghy Road in the 1960s.

Letters: Brits should love Canada

Fire is a leveller Sir: It was disappointing to read Fin Taylor’s Diary (26 September) in which he reflected upon feeling a ‘tinge of satisfaction’ at the California wildfires. He made the rather sweeping statement that Californians believe they live beyond the laws of nature, and that those affected are so rich that it is of no consequence. In fact, the fires at Pacific Palisades affected the whole community. Near to us, a children’s day centre, largely used by low-income families, was completely lost. Our local Ralph’s supermarket burned to the ground with dozens of jobs lost. Landscapers, gardeners, waiters, domestic workers all lost their livelihoods. Whether a billionaire or working for $20 an hour, the merciless devastation touched everyone.

Monet’s Broom

If he’d had students, he’d have said always have a broom at hand to sweep out all the readymade images of your subject which come to mind; he’d have said this is the hardest part, harder than putting paint on canvas. He’d have said the broom’s handle should become smooth from use and the day you think you don’t need it is the day memory has won. Look at the results of his encounter with that iris – he’s eighty-four and it’s as though he’s never looked at one before.

Andy Burnham should call an election now

So far, Andy Burnham’s premiership has been characterised by compromise and obfuscation. When choosing his Chancellor, instead of picking Shabana Mahmood on his party’s right or Ed Miliband on the left, he went with the reassuringly un-ideological John Healey. Rather than committing to spending 3 per cent of GDP on defence, he postponed any decision until a spending review next year. His broader agenda for his premiership will only be revealed in a ‘Ten-Year Plan’ in November. For a country confronted by as many challenges as Britain, this is an appalling lack of clarity. A reckoning with reality is required. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQnfP-jOET8&t=1387s One thing that Burnham has been clear about is an early election – he has ruled it out.