The use and abuse of ‘genocide’
In 1921, a law student in Lviv asked his professor a question. An Armenian survivor, Soghomon Tehlirian, had just shot Talaat Pasha dead in a Berlin street. Why, the student asked, had Talaat never been tried for the killing of Armenians? The distinguished professor Juliusz Makarewicz gave the answer of his time: a state is sovereign, and what it does to its own people is its own business. The student was Raphael Lemkin. He escaped the Holocaust, which killed most of his family, and two decades after that question, in America, coined the word "genocide". He spent the rest of his life proving his professor’s answer wrong. The legal definition of genocide is deliberately dry and narrow.