Ameer Kotecha

Ameer Kotecha is CEO of the Centre for Government Reform. He was formerly a senior diplomat, serving as the head of the British consulate in Russia 2023-25. He is the author of Queen Elizabeth II’s official Platinum Jubilee Cookbook (Bloomsbury).

Shabana Mahmood has said the quiet bit out loud

From our UK edition

Shabana Mahmood, the Home Secretary, has said that every woman travelling illegally to the UK will probably have been raped on the journey. It is a startling statement. Firstly, for what is implied. The trafficking operation bringing dinghies to our south coast is, the Home Secretary now admits, not merely facilitating illegal migration, it is also exposing women to the most appalling sexual violence. Her comment, made in a Leading podcast interview with Rory Stewart and Alastair Campbell, was also a whisker away from admitting that very many of the small boats arriving here may contain rapists. Second, it is remarkable that she was able to say it. You can only imagine the hysteria from much of the political establishment if someone on the right had made the same observation.

Jenrick is right to take on the shoplifting scourge

From our UK edition

Robert Jenrick is back on patrol. In a video released this morning, he confronts multiple shoplifters. One man is accused of taking a bottle of Dr Pepper from Greggs without paying, and strolling back out. Jenrick asks him: why does he think he is above the law? Why should everyone else have to pay while he helps himself? It is absurd to employ people to provide security and then create a legal and corporate environment in which all they can do is stand back and watch In another demoralising detail, the shop worker – protected by a glass screen (another recent feature of retail life in this country) and presumably ground down by seeing such theft day in day out – looks unable to bring himself to care.

The Labour minister who thinks a black dog in a pub is a ‘far-right fantasy’

From our UK edition

Britain as a place of “warm ale, (with) a black Labrador by your feet in a pub” is a “far-right fantasy that never really existed”. That is the verdict of Labour's nature minister Jenny Riddell-Carpenter. At a fringe event at Labour conference in Liverpool, Riddell-Carpenter warned attendees that the so-called "far-right" will try to weaponise rural Britain at the next election. The MP for Suffolk Coastal – that’s right, rural Suffolk – said she lies "awake at night" at what "nostalgic vision" of the countryside will be used in the supposed battle. “This is one of the things I do stay awake at night about, and think about, and fear.

Why are we giving asylum to a Hamas bodyguard?

From our UK edition

Such is the level of rot in our public institutions, and so accustomed have we become to daily stories of inexplicable and indeed unforgivable asylum decisions, that it takes a lot nowadays for a story to come along that is genuinely jaw-dropping. The Refugee Convention, the general right of asylum and our entire approach have been proven to be utterly broken But a story in this week’s Sunday Times is just that, and should be a genuine line-in-the-sand moment. The UK granted asylum protection, and then British citizenship, to a former bodyguard of a leader of Hamas.

Andy Burnham is no statesman

From our UK edition

‘Britain is back,’ Burnham declared in his big speech to the UN yesterday. We have been laid low by ten years of Brexit disruption, he told the world. We’ve heard this before: just last year Starmer was announcing ‘Britain is back on the world stage’. Heck, Cameron was insisting Britain was ‘back’ even before that fateful referendum had taken place. There is something unpatriotic about cementing this narrative of a lost decade. UN functionaries lap it up but it doesn’t do our soft power, which Burnham is so keen to make a national priority, any good. And curiously, having informed the General Assembly that Britain had returned to the world, Burnham then spent several minutes listing all the institutions and alliances from which we have never departed.

Labour is hooked on benefits

From our UK edition

More than half of Labour MPs have a greater number of disability benefit claimants in their constituency than the size of their electoral majority. Some 58 per cent of Labour’s 366 seats in England and Wales have more people claiming personal independence payments (Pip) than Labour’s majority, according to a report in the Times. Pat McFadden – Secretary of State for Work and pensions – is one of those MPs. And, more than 100 Labour MPs have more individuals specifically claiming Pip for mental health conditions (e.g. anxiety, ADHD and autism) than their majorities. Is it any wonder that Labour MPs are expected to again revolt over plans to reform – however modestly – disability benefits? The spiralling welfare bill risks bankrupting the country.

Does Angela Rayner really think Reform’s donors are ‘fascists’?

From our UK edition

Angela Rayner has used a big speech to the TUC to brand Reform’s biggest donors ‘a couple of off-shore billionaires trying to buy our democracy’. Labour, she went on, would defend that democracy against any ‘fascist oligarch’ who ‘seeks to divide our country and buy our politics.’ That demagoguery is not quite the sort of thing she was preaching ten years ago. Addressing the same TUC Congress in September 2016, in the aftermath of Jo Cox's murder, Rayner urged delegates to honour Cox through ‘the example we set’, reminding them that ‘we have more in common than what divides us’. What happened Ange?

The pathetic pearl clutching over Reform’s donations

From our UK edition

Thirty Six is clearly the magic number. A record-breaking £36 million donation to Reform announced last night from Ben Delo, the British-born and bred cryptocurrency billionaire, has been matched today by another donation for the same amount by Christopher Harborne, the British businessman and tech investor. The donations will be a massive shot in the arm for Farage’s party. It’s worth taking a moment to consider just what lengths Labour have gone to to try to stop this happening. They’re introducing a £100,000 annual cap on donations from people living overseas and a one-year waiting period before returnees can escape the cap, not to mention a moratorium on all political donations in cryptoassets.

Is Reform right to prioritise ‘British-born’ citizens?

From our UK edition

Lee Anderson and Richard Tice fronted another Reform presser yesterday, this time on their plans for council housing, should they be elected to government. Included in the announcement was the desire to prioritise council housing for married couples with children, as well as 'British-born' citizens. To analyse this fresh distinction, Oscar Edmondson and James Heale are joined by Ameer Kotecha to go over the plans, and ask whether it is right to draw a line between the Brits who are born here, and those who are not.

Why shouldn’t British workers be prioritised for council housing?

From our UK edition

Who can argue against making British workers and veterans the priority for social housing? Given the limited stock of housing, wouldn’t it be monstrously unfair not to put those in work and those who fought for the country first? Well, of course so much of our public policy in the last few decades has been illogical and monstrously unfair. And so, as a few weeks ago when I wrote in support of Reform’s announcement to ban foreigners from council homes, I find myself in agreement with the proposals put forward by Richard Tice yesterday that council housing allocation should prioritise young British married working couples with children, along with military veterans. Overhauling the system is well overdue.

We should ban foreigners from council houses

From our UK edition

State House occupies a prized hilltop location in central Freetown. As befits the official home of the President and First Lady of Sierra Leone, the colonial-era residence includes wide verandas, arched colonnades and ceremonial lawns, embodying – as the official website proudly describes – ‘imperial grandeur’. Ensuring that foreigners are not put above Brits removes one of the most egregious council housing injustices You might ask why a lady blessed with such an abode might want a second property in Walworth, South London. But wherever Sierra Leone’s First Lady chooses to spend her time shopping, any sensible country would conclude that she has quite enough moolah to buy own accommodation. But then we are no longer a sensible country.

Stopping the boats would be good diplomacy

From our UK edition

Pedro Sánchez is in the diplomatic doghouse. The Ceuta migrant crisis last week has prompted an extraordinary diplomatic spat, with EU states calling for Spain to be removed from the Schengen zone. Amid fury at Sánchez’s previous amnesty of 600,000 illegal migrants which they fear has served as a potent pull factor in the latest crisis, the EU has reportedly told Sánchez he must verify the figures his government has provided on removals, given doubts over Spain’s claim that the vast majority of the 60,000 that crossed into the Spanish enclave had been returned. The hardening of European attitudes means the real diplomatic risk now lies not in uncompromisingly enforcing our border, but in appearing incapable of doing so.

We need a crackdown on crackpot charities

From our UK edition

Hundreds of thousands of pounds have been given by the Scottish government, the NHS and local councils to a charity which helps trans women – i.e. biological men – try to give human milk to their babies. As the Times reported this week, the charity provides a space for people ‘breastfeeding, chestfeeding or giving human milk to their baby in any amount... no matter what your feeding journey looks like.’ Its ‘Queer Milk’ initiative involves weekly sessions in Edinburgh which are apparently open to biological men that identify as women –  people who are, of course, unable to lactate naturally. Of all the charities it could be supporting, why has the state decided that it is outfits like this one that deserve taxpayer funding?

Keir Starmer leaves the country in a terrible state

From our UK edition

You get two impressions of Britain at the moment. First, that nothing works. Second, that the state is not on the side of those who try to work for a living and generally do the right thing, but on the side of those who intend to ride on the backs of others and generally take the mick. Keir Starmer today leaves the country in a worse place on both counts. Let us take them in turn. People are understandably coming to the conclusion that they might as well not bother, and instead take the dole from the outstretched hand of the state Starmer did not cause the broken state but, as one of the bureaucracy’s chief princelings, he has done nothing to fix it.

The danger of the Olly Robbins legal challenge

From our UK edition

It is hard not to grin. Our lawyerly soon-to-be-former Prime Minister, Mr Process, stands accused of, er, failing to follow the proper process. Olly Robbins was chief mandarin at the Foreign Office until he was unceremoniously thrown under the bus by Starmer in a panicked attempt to find a scapegoat for his disastrous decision to appoint Peter Mandelson to the country’s most senior ambassadorial role. Robbins has now applied to the High Court for a judicial review of Starmer’s decision to dismiss him. The sight of Sir Keir being hoisted by his own petard in his final week in office when he wants to be left alone to focus on booking his tickets to the World Cup final and unscrewing the lightbulbs from the Downing Street flat, is undeniably rather funny.

David Miliband would be a disastrous foreign secretary

From our UK edition

At the Rabbi Jonathan Sacks memorial lecture at the LSE this week, David Miliband ‘broke his silence’ after days of intense speculation that he will soon be announced as Andy Burnham’s Foreign Secretary. Unfortunately, I think Miliband as foreign secretary would represent at best stale continuity and at worst a disaster We shall have to wait and see whether he gets the call-up. But his speech will have further convinced his admirers that he has both the intellectual heft and unusually extensive experience to make a great success of the role.

The civil service’s war on expertise

From our UK edition

The revelation in The Spectator last week that the Treasury is more concerned with boosting its DEI outcomes than hiring people who can count, was – for those who have served in our blessed civil service – shocking but not surprising. But the truth is that this numeracy story is not a wacky aberration or an isolated case. It is, to quote Dominic Cummings, ‘the system working as intended’. Let me explain. The dominance of DEI ideology in recruitment to some of the most powerful roles in the state has long roots, going back to the Blair era. As I’ve reported before, the main graduate internship scheme for the civil service excluded middle-class white applicants until very recently. But BLM further deranged the mandarin mind.

REVEALED: Treasury abandons numeracy to boost diversity

From our UK edition

12 min listen

A scoop by The Spectator’s news editor has taken Westminster by storm this week, after it emerged that the Treasury had ditched the numerical reasoning test for its high-flying graduate scheme. Oscar Edmondson speaks to the story’s author, John Connolly, and Ameer Kotecha, a former senior diplomat and now chief executive of the Centre for Government Reform, about how deeply anti-meritocratic hiring practices are rooted in the civil service. Produced by Oscar Edmondson and Henry Lloyd.

Farage and Kemi’s pitch for conservative hearts and minds

From our UK edition

At the entrance to the hangar-like Olympia conference centre is a huge, framed drawing, showing a design for an imagined triumphal arch. It depicts the intellectual, scientific and cultural contributions to the world made by Western civilisation, from the abolition of slavery to shipbuilding and the caravel. ‘Civilisation’ – and how to defend it – was the primary concern of those attending the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (ARC) conference this week. Over three days, 4,000 attendees pondered the ‘civilisational moment’ at which we stand. Down one fork in the road lies freedom, prosperity and flourishing. Down the other: stagnation, division and managed decline.

Why Starmer has been such a failure

From our UK edition

There were lots of contested takeaways from the Makerfield by-election this week. But the one thing that seems incontrovertible is that almost everyone wanted to get rid of Keir Starmer. Some of those people voted for Reform, more did so for Burnham – in large part because that was the quickest way to change PM. Starmer appears to have a deeply-held superiority complex – of morals as well as talents – that explains his habit of telling everyone else that they are irresponsible and incompetent This is effectively the end of Starmer’s premiership, with reports today that he may step down as soon as Monday. I have spoken previously of Sir Keir as a Beadlet anemone – a red jelly-like blob – that sticks stubbornly in place until forcibly dislodged.