Alex Massie

Alex Massie

America Moves to the Left

Another problem with the Republican party's apparent belief that the Same Old Tunes are just as popular as they ever were, if, that is, they're played properly is that, just as the United States is changing demographically, so its political centre-of-gravity has moved to the left. As Ross Douthat says, persuasively to my mind, what seemed radical 15 years ago now seems possible and much less scary. Thus, the rising cost - and insecurity - of health coverage has helped persuade voters that the government must be a larger part of the solution. Thus too, the rising cost of college education helps persuade families that more needs to be done to help their kids be able to afford a proper education.

The Republicans and Cameron, Cont.

Background: John O'Sullivan wrote a piece for National Review arguing that the GOP had nothing useful to learn from the Tory party's post-1997 experiences. I took issue with that here. Mr O'Sullivan then sent in this response. Here's my reply to his reply. John O'Sullivan is right. It was remiss of me to overlook the fact that, as Executive Editor of Radio Free Europe, he is currently based in Prague. Nonetheless, he is also National Review's Editor-at-Large and was, for nine years, that magazines' Editor-in-Chief. He has also edited the National Interest and been a Senior Fellow at the Hudson Institute. For good measure his family home is, I believe, in Alabama*.

Frum vs Limbaugh: the Newsweek Edition

Regular readers will not be surprised to learn that I think David Frum's Newsweek piece on the Trouble with Rush has a lot going for it. I admire David's bravery in sticking to his guns. Bravery? Why what could be easier than selling out to the Mainstream Media and the Washington cocktail party set? Frum is Canadian Low-life! Since when was he a conservative anyway? The reaction to Frum's criticisms of Limbaugh is telling: it's the reaction of a party losing interest in governing. Here for instance is Jay Nordlinger, writing at the Corner, claiming that "Rush’s politics are the politics of Reagan" and that William F Buckley "loved" Rush (I dare say he did, but as entertainer, not prophet I'd hazard).

Green Jobs? Really?

Could there be anything nicer and popular than "green jobs"? Gordon Brown and Baack Obama has determined that a "green" job - all fresh and wholesome and wrapped in the (endlessly recyclable!) promise of a "sustainable" future - is better than any other kind of job. Including, probably, the one you have right now. Also: Green is the Future. Apparently. To which you might say, "aye right" and your suspicions might not be misplaced. Here's Michael Levi in Slate: Green jobs seem to be an ideal solution. But just because "green" and "jobs" are both in demand doesn't mean that policies focused on creating "green jobs" make sense.

Charles Freeman

Appointing Charles Freeman to run the President's National Intelligence Council is not quite the same thing as asking him to be National Security Advisor or Secretary of State. How many people could name any of Freeman's predecessors? Clive links to most of the pieces I was planning to mention (though I'd add that Matt Welch makes a good and blessedly un-Israel-related case against Freeman here). Still, most of the loudest objections to Freeman concern his alleged hostility to Israel and, apparently "Jews generally". Maybe this exists and I confess I don't think I'd choose to die in the last, or indeed any, ditch to defend Freeman. Nonetheless it is painfully obvious that the people who tend to deny the existence of an Israel lobby* are also Freeman's most passionate prosecutors.

Countercyclical Assets

One of my favourite features at Marginal Revolution is Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok's occasional look at countercyclical assets - ie, products and economic sectors that are doing quite nicely at the moment. They include: Safes, Atlas Shrugged, the Mafia, Economic Disaster Tours, Tinned Soup, Matchmakers, Prayer, Second Life's economy, Cobblers, Tasers and Alpacas. So there's the future: Self-sufficient, heavily-armed Randian Alpaca farmers holding out against the Mafia with only the consolation of prayer and the escapism of online fantasies to sustain them as the "real" world collapses and man returns to a Mad Maxian, elemental state of being. Hold on tight folks, it's going to be one hell of a ride...

Obama more out of touch than Bush, Hoover, Everyone combined…

How so? Well, how can he say stuff like this and expect to be taken seriously? Mr. Obama rode to the White House partly on his savvy use of new technology, and he has a staff-written blog on his presidential Web site. Even so, he said he did not find blogs to be reliable, citing the economy as one example. “Part of the reason we don’t spend a lot of time looking at blogs,” he said, “is because if you haven’t looked at it very carefully, then you may be under the impression that somehow there’s a clean answer one way or another..." I mean, really. How preposterous....

Blogroll | 7 March 2009

Astute readers will have noticed that I've finally got round to adding a blogroll. All blogs listed are, of course, recommended. I'd particularly like to highlight, however, a couple to which I have not, I think, linked in some time: The League of Ordinary Gentlemen is a group blog that sustains an impressively high level as it wrestles with (mainly American) political ideas and, just as impressively, manages to do so in a civilised fashion even as its contributors often disagreee with one another. The American Scene, Reihan Salam's agglomeration of polymaths, is also highly recommended. Closer to home and Scottish Unionist keeps a keen eye on Alex Salmond's ministry in Edinburgh and takes great delight in pointing out the extremism (and racism) of the "cyberNat" brigade.

Giftgate Continues!

On the one hand, the rumpus over the gifts exchanged between Gordon Brown and Barack Obama is, as TIME's Michael Scherer puts it, "exhausting". Also, magnificently trivial. But let's face it, giving the PM a collection of DVDs is pretty rubbish. As Iain Martin notes, Brown is an American history buff (his favourite political book is said to be Robert Caro's monumental biography of LBJ) and it would not have taken much thought to find a better, more appropriate present. Now one of Mark Hemingway's readers raises a vital, as yet unanswered, question: It would be funny if the DVDs Mr Obama gave Mr Brown were Region 1 NTSC and therefore not compatible with the UK where DVDs are region 2 and video format is PAL. Well, is this the case? I think we should be told!

Ending the Drug War. Now.

Although there are encouraging noises coming from Latin America, much of the western world remains deaf to common sense. Still, let's hear it for the Economist which this week repeats its call for legalisation: Next week ministers from around the world gather in Vienna to set international drug policy for the next decade. Like first-world-war generals, many will claim that all that is needed is more of the same. In fact the war on drugs has been a disaster, creating failed states in the developing world even as addiction has flourished in the rich world. By any sensible measure, this 100-year struggle has been illiberal, murderous and pointless. That is why The Economist continues to believe that the least bad policy is to legalise drugs.

When philosophers attack…

Australian foreign minister Steven Smith sees trouble ahead: "This was very much an existentialist threat to Pakistan itself," he said. Quite so. Readers are invited to pair schools of philosophy with the countries they threaten... [Hat-tip: James Joyner.

Jon Stewart Pops CNBC’s Bubble

As Clive has noted, the financial press did not exactly cover itself in glory in the run-up to the present economic difficulties. No-one ws a bigger cheerleader of heroic capitalism than CNBC. As Jon Stewart so ably demonstrates here.

David Frum vs Talk Radio

David Frum called in to Mark Levin's radio show the other day to respond to, inter alia, "debate" the suggestion that Rush Limbaugh does not represent a profitable future for the Republican party. It's a remarkable exchange, even if it also demonstrates the folly of trying to engage in any sensible, coherent, interesting or adult fashion with the frothing lunatics who dominate the airwaves. You can listen to it here. Writing about the experience, Frum says: As I hung up, I wondered what it would be like to be a new listener, a nonpolitical person, tuning in to Mark Levin’s show for the first time.

Buckley and Limbaugh: Contrasting Conservatisms

Ross Douthat is obviously (well, it's obvious to me) right to think that Rush Limbaugh is an entertainer and not someone who ought to be considered a spokesman for the Republican party. Too bad El Rushbo doesn't see himself that way. In a piece for the (splendid) Daily Beast, Christopher Buckley observes that Limbaugh took the occasion of William F Buckley's death as a cue to annoint himself WFB's successor: A few days later, as I was planning WFB’s memorial service at St. Patrick’s Cathedral, I was approached by an intermediary, a big player in the vast right-wing conspiracy, with the suggestion (“Wouldn’t it be appropriate….”) that Rush should give the eulogy.

The Next Labour Manifesto

Taking a cue from Vogue and other glossy mags, the New Statesman has decided to liven things up attract some publicity by inviting a celebrity to be "Guest Editor" for a forthcoming issue. Their choice? Alastair Campbell. Among his ideas? This: As well as the articles I've already commissioned, one of the pages will be handed over to 'LabourListers' and others to finish the phrase: 'if I could get one sentence into Labour’s manifesto for the next election, it would say this...' I want to do this because, for all that the Tories may be ahead in the polls, and taking that position for granted, I think the battle of policy ideas still has more energy on the left than the right, and I hope this page will reflect that.

Why waiting for Obama to fail is not enough

Rich Lowry, editor of National Review, says everyone should calm down and have a cup of tea: Barack Obama and the Democrats have the initiative. Until such time as their policies are perceived to have failed, it doesn't matter too much what Republicans do. Yes, they obviously should endeavor to be sober and creative—replenishing their policy arsenal for the day when the public is seriously paying attention to them again—but the big question in American politics right now is how Obama handles the financial crisis and the economy. In the grand scheme of things, everything else is commentary. Aside from the fact that the Republican party is neither sober nor creative right now, there's something to this.

The Problem of Being Like Scotland

One of the problems with nationalism is that it craves attention. The Scottish variety is no exception. Thus, for instance, the normally sensisible SNP Tactical Voting asks: One day we may read in foreign newspapers "why can't we be more like Scotland?" once in a while. Wouldn't that be a refreshing change? Jeff goes on to say how jolly splendid it is that the SNP's proposals for price controls on alcohol might be emulated elsewhere in the UK and, who knows, in truly foreign countries too. Whoopee! But this is scarcely surprising. After all the Scottish parliament has led the way before. Brave Wee Scotland was the first to ban the hunting of foxes with hounds and it was also ahead of the curve, I'm afraid, with its draconian, invasive attitude to the consumption of tobacco.

The Ulster-Scots Style

Line of the day comes from David McNarry, an Ulster Unionist member of the Northern Ireland Assembly, looking forward (or not) to an entry to the Belfast Film Festival: "Porn is porn, is porn, is porn - and whether it is done Ulster-Scots-style, well, it really doesn't come into it," Aye, I guess that would be right, sure enough.