Uk politics

The end of the peer show

16 min listen

Hereditary peers have left their red leather benches for the final time. The House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Act became law earlier this year, which removes all hereditary peers’ right to speak and vote in Parliament by virtue of their family ties. Critics have described their role as indefensible, but others accuse Labour of political point-scoring and vandalising the upper house – removing a ‘living part of Britain’s constitutional inheritance’. James Heale and Megan McElroy discuss – joined by Lord Strathclyde and Lord Courtenay.

The end of the peer show

Starmer vs the basics of politics

16 min listen

Does Keir Starmer have confidence in Rachel Reeves? Kemi Badenoch pressed the Prime Minister on his Chancellor’s future at PMQs – and he declined to answer, twice. Westminster (and Twitter) is now awash with reshuffle rumours. No 10 has since issued a denial, but the damage may already be done, raising a familiar question: is Keir Starmer just bad at politics? With recess looming and Labour braced for a battering at the local elections, Tim Shipman and Noa Hoffman join Megan McElroy to discuss.

Starmer vs the basics of politics

Can the King handle Trump?

King Charles is about to travel to Washington to visit President Trump. The brief? Fix the strained relationship. No pressure! Can royal diplomacy steady relations? Will the trip be awkward given Trump’s recent words on Starmer, Chagos, The Falklands, and Canada? Does the King have what it takes to navigate such a diplomatic minefield? Elsewhere, Morgan McSweeney will appear before MPs tomorrow to explain his actions relating to the appointment of Lord Mandelson as ambassador to the United States. Given he’s already said he doesn’t recognise portrayals of himself in the media, is he going to come out swinging? Tim Shipman and James Heale discuss.

Can the King handle Trump?

‘Worse than the worst of Boris Johnson’ – are Labour turning on Starmer?

19 min listen

Somewhere in the documents surrounding Peter Mandelson’s ambassadorial appointment, the Spectator’s political editor Tim Shipman reveals, is a text Keir Starmer sent the night before the announcement. ‘You’ll be brilliant in challenging circumstances,’ he told the Prince of Darkness. ‘And after many years of our discussions, we get to work together side by side. I really look forward to that.’ The message was leaked after a week in which the Prime Minister’s relationship with senior civil servants has collapsed. Tim says Starmer’s ‘apparent incomprehension of the very process he advocates has led officials to conclude he is no better than the predecessor he most deplores – Boris Johnson’. Has Starmer

‘Worse than the worst of Boris Johnson’ – are Labour turning on Starmer?

Why the Lib Dems are aiming for second – with Al Pinkerton MP & Mark Pack

16 min listen

Liberal Democrat peer Mark Pack and MP for Surrey Heath Al Pinkerton join James Heale to explain that it is a matter of ‘when not if’ the party become the second biggest in local government. Overtaking the Conservatives would be ‘seismic’ but they see it as inevitable, following a ‘long-run of sustained wins’ in the post-coalition Lib Dem era. Faced with criticism that the Lib Dems are too focused on community and that leader Ed Davey is more interested in stunts than policy, they explain that a ‘rich and varied’ diet of political communication has never been more necessary, and that they will never apologise for taking up the causes

Second in local government: who should the Lib Dems target? with Al Pinkerton MP & Mark Pack

Mandelson latest: can we trust Starmer’s ignorance?

20 min listen

The Peter Mandelson scandal just got more scandalous. Last night the story broke that Mandeslon actually failed his enhanced vetting before being made US Ambassador. Number 10 are pleading ignorance. Their defence sits on the suggestion that the Foreign Office’s most senior official unilaterally decided to ignore the findings and – what’s more – that he told no one. It’s a stretch and, as Tim Shipman says MPs’ ‘fury is overwhelming’. There are a number of outstanding questions, including: what could possibly be in it for the FCDO to withhold this key information? Now Sir Olly Robbins has been sacked, will he go public? Did Starmer knowingly mislead parliament when

Mandelson latest: can we trust Starmer's ignorance?

Are the Treasury & the MOD at war?

11 min listen

George Robertson (pictured), a former defence secretary and former NATO secretary-general, has accused the government of ‘corrosive complacency’ towards defence, which puts the UK ‘in peril’. This is all the more stinging because the Labour peer was one of the authors of the government’s Strategic Defence Review – and that makes two of the three who have since criticised it. How much trouble does this spell for Starmer? And is this just the latest battle in the ongoing war between His Majesty’s Treasury and the Ministry of Defence? Megan McElroy speaks to James Heale and Lucy Fisher, Whitehall editor of the financial times and who broke the story. Produced by

Are the Treasury & the MOD at war?

Will Labour lose Wales?

14 min listen

With one month to go until the local and regional elections, Megan McElroy and James Heale have hit the road with Luke Tryl and Louis O’Geran of More in Common. They report back from the focus groups they’ve been running in Wales, where voters view Labour through the prism of a double incumbency, as they hold both the Senedd and Westminster. Starmer faces an uphill battle to avoid an historic loss – so is he about to lose Wales? Produced by Megan McElroy and Patrick Gibbons.

Will Labour lose Wales?

Left turn: who should Reform target?

15 min listen

Gawain Towler, Reform UK board member and their former director of communications, sits down with James Heale to talk about Reform’s appeal ahead of the local elections. Gawain argues that Reform needs to broaden its appeal as it won’t find the votes to win to its right, but points to their anti-establishment, nationalist and pro-business credentials. While acknowledging that some of the negative stories about a minority of Reform councillors is uncomfortable, he argues that the scrutiny that comes with governing is necessary in order for Reform to prove credibility and competency for national government. Gawain also dismisses Rupert Lowe’s Restore Britain as ‘not a political project’ but ‘an angry

Left turn: who should Reform target?
Is Britain losing its sense of fairness?

Is Britain losing its sense of fairness?

49 min listen

Has Britain become a freeloader’s paradise, asks the Spectator’s economics editor Michael Simmons in our cover piece this week. Michael analyses ‘the benefits of benefits’, at a time when Britain’s welfare bill is burgeoning and most households are struggling with cost of living. For example, while a family of four can expect to pay £111 to visit the Tower of London, that is just £4 total on Universal Credit (UC), and for London Zoo it is £108 compared to £26. Michael is not arguing against the idea of helping those in need, but pointing out that – as the benefits bill continues to increase – this is another case of

Only one man could bridge this footballing divide

It reminded me a little of that wonderful Christmas Day truce in the first world war, when the two sides briefly came together, put aside their homicidal enmities and played a game of football and sang carols. The venue was the Riverside Stadium in Middlesbrough, fittingly on Good Friday. Boro, then second in the Championship, were hosting my team, Millwall, third in the Championship. The end of the season was nearing. The tension was acute and pressing and unrelenting. Whoever won would be in pole position for automatic promotion to the Premier League. Not an empty seat in the ground, Millwall too having sold out their allocation of 2,100 tickets.

How to save our churches 

Easter is being celebrated by millions of families across our country. It’s one of those moments when we should come together, pause and remember what really matters. As a mother with a very busy job, I value this time with my children more and more each year. It is a time for faith, family and fun. Britain is a Christian country. Our values, our customs and many of our greatest institutions were shaped by Christianity. That is why, for so many people, going to church at Easter still matters. I teach my children that it is not just a ritual. It is part of who we are. That is why

Hero voters: who should Labour target? with Chris Curtis MP & Deborah Mattinson

Hero voters: who should Labour target? with Chris Curtis MP & Deborah Mattinson

30 min listen

Labour won the 2024 general election in part by focusing on ‘hero voters’ – so called because they may have voted Labour in the past but felt the party had abandoned them. Now they risk losing them again – so how does Labour maintain their support? Chris Curtis, Labour MP for Milton Keynes North and former pollster, and Deborah Mattinson, Labour peer and polling guru, join Tim Shipman to talk about how to appeal to this set of voters. Research suggests that voters from this group that are socially liberal are switching to the Greens, while the socially conservative voters are switching to Reform. What binds both groups though is

Why is Starmer so unpopular? with Lewis Goodall

28 min listen

Opinion polls consistently show Keir Starmer as one of the most unpopular Prime Ministers in history. His critics point to inertia and a lack of vision, while his supporters argue that media spin is harming the image of a decent man. Less than two years on from Labour’s landslide victory, broadcaster Lewis Goodall joins James Heale to try to answer the question ‘where did it all go wrong?’ – a subject which Lewis explores in a Channel 4 Dispatches documentary. Lewis explains the factors at play, from Starmer’s personality and Labour party politics to the effect that the Conservative Party’s implosion had on Labour’s preparedness for government. Is Starmer a

Why is Starmer so unpopular? with Lewis Goodall

Conservative radicalism: who should the Tories target? with Jack Rankin MP

27 min listen

Can the Conservatives win back voters’ support through a new kind of ‘conservative radicalism’? Jack Rankin, Conservative MP for Windsor, joins James Heale to explain why he believes a focus on aspiration and wealth creation, paired with political courage to combat ‘short-termism and stakeholderism’, would enhance the Party’s appeal and energise its supporter base. Jack argues that Conservative politicians need to be more honest about the country’s problems, including with immigration and integration – where the expectation of a minimum level of British values should be set. He doesn’t shy away from discussing the Tories’ challenging record too, reflecting on political unity, the need for party reform and the flaws

Conservative radicalism: who should the Tories target? with Jack Rankin MP

Is politics becoming more religious? With Tom Holland & Jonathan Sumption

39 min listen

Is British politics becoming more religious? Madeline Grant certainly thinks so, arguing – in the Spectator’s cover article – that the next election could be the most religious for decades. Issues like immigration and Islam, assisted dying – and even the establishment of the Church of England are likely to play a role. The current Labour government’s ‘most telling divide’, Madeline writes, is between MPs – like Shabana Mahmood and Wes Streeting – who understand religion – and ‘those who don’t’. For the Edition’s Easter special, host Lara Prendergast is joined by vicar – and Madeline’s husband – The Rev’d Fergus Butler-Gallie, former Supreme Court justice Jonathan Sumption and the historian and

EU déjà vu: the emergency brake is back!

13 min listen

Charles Grant from the Centre for European Reform and Tim Shipman join James Heale to reflect on the rumours about Britain’s latest set of negotiations with the European Union. There are reports that the EU may be willing to accept some form of mechanism, that the UK could use, should Britain ever wish to temporarily halt the number of inbound students. Perhaps we could call such a mechanism an ’emergency brake’. Sound familiar? What does this tell us about the dynamics of the EU, how the UK-EU relationship works – and how inevitable was the result in 2016? Produced by Patrick Gibbons and Megan McElroy.

EU déjà vu: the emergency brake is back!

Will Trump pull the US out of NATO?

15 min listen

Donald Trump has said he is ‘strongly considering’ pulling the US out of NATO, in comments made to the Telegraph – and it doesn’t appear to be an April Fool. This isn’t the first time he has rallied against the Alliance so should the UK take him seriously? Plus – what is Keir Starmer’s strategy? – as he tries to balance a testing transatlantic relationship with pursuing closer relations with the EU. Patrick Gibbons speaks to Tim Shipman and James Heale. Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

Will Trump pull the US out of NATO?

Anas Sarwar: why I said Starmer should go – and what I told Wes Streeting

50 min listen

One month on from calling for Keir Starmer’s resignation, Anas Sarwar – the leader of Scottish Labour – joins Michael Gove to reflect on British politics ahead of the May elections. Does he stand by his call for the Prime Minister to go? And, having spoken to Wes Streeting the weekend before, what advice did his close ally give? The May local and regional elections promise to be the ‘fiercest battle’ for Scotland’s future. Yet after over two decades in power, what does he make of polling that suggests the SNP will win – again? Is Reform posing a threat to Labour? And how can Scottish Labour offer a realistic