The Spectator’s Reality Check newsletter

Michael Simmons goes behind the headlines, using graphs and data to get to the bottom of what’s really going on.

Rising energy costs are driving inflation

Inflation continues to tick up. Figures just released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show that the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose by 3.6 per cent last month – up from 3.5 per cent the month before. It’s the fastest pace of price rises this year. The rise – which economists had expected – was largely a result of increased energy costs. Petrol and diesel are up 33 per cent on a year ago and rising at their fastest pace since the summer of 2022. Household gas jumped too thanks to the increase in the energy price cap. There was also an outsized contribution from cigarettes thanks to higher vape and tobacco duties. Burnham’s removal of VAT on electricity bills did little to offset these other price rises.

Milburn misses the real cause of Britain’s welfare crisis

As soon as the news dripped out last week that Alan Milburn was going to propose stripping certain benefits from 18- to 24-year-olds, my TikTok feed was inundated. Whether by Chinese state design or an algorithm trained on my journalistic interests, I was served up post after post of hysterical PIP (Personal Independence Payment) recipients who claimed Milburn and Andy Burnham – if he adopts today’s proposals – were going to kill them. The bed-ridden TikTokers are not cheating the system. They genuinely believe they are too sick to work These TikTok sickfluencers all had three things in common: an odd haircut, obesity and genuinely impressive articulation skills. They also shared a conviction that employment isn’t just difficult but impossible.

Unemployment falls – for now

Later this morning, former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn will release his report on the crisis of young people doing nothing. His solutions to the Neets problem will include new school readiness targets, more apprenticeships, better mental health support, a new benefit system for under-25s and the foundation of a ‘Youth Opportunity Service’. Before that, though, the government has had some good news by way of the Office for National Statistics (ONS). The latest labour market figures, released this morning, show unemployment unexpectedly fell to 4.6 per cent, while 20,000 new payrolled jobs were created between August and September.

Why Labour’s welfare reforms will come to nothing

It seems unlikely that there will be much in Alan Milburn’s report tomorrow into young people and work that hasn’t already been widely reported. The big question is less what he will say and more whether his report will become the latest in the long line that is quietly dumped, such as Sir Andrew Dilnot’s 2011 commission into social care provision and Henry Dimbleby’s proposed National Food Strategy in 2021 (both under Conservative governments; this is not a party-political point). The big question is less what Milburn will say and more whether his report will become the latest in the long line that is quietly dumped Andy Burnham and work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden have certainly given every indication that they are committed to Milburn’s reforms.

Britain’s GDP boost is a gift for Labour

The bogey is off. In recent years Britain’s economy has experienced an annoying trend: growth in the first half of the year which completely died off in the second. Not so this year. Figures just released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show GDP expanded by 0.7 per cent between July and September. Over the last year it means the economy is 1.9 per cent larger. The growth in the last quarter was made up of a 0.9 per cent expansion in services and 0.1 per cent in production. The construction sector, however, shrank by 0.7 per cent. Nevertheless, even on the important per head measure, the economy has grown by 0.7 per cent in the quarter and by 1.7 per cent compared with the same period last year, despite rising energy costs and assorted global troubles.

The Bank of England is taking inflation seriously again

Fears of resurgent inflation have finally caught up with the rate-setters of the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee (MPC). The Bank has voted by eight to one to raise interest rates to 4 per cent. It’s the first rate hike in more than three years, ending a cutting and hold cycle that started in 2024. So far, the MPC had resisted raising rates because the majority of the committee was not convinced that inflation was baked in or leading to so-called ‘second-order effects’, where retailers raise prices in anticipation of more inflation and employees make precautionary pay rise demands.

The rise of crypto kidnappings

Last week North Korea pulled off the biggest heist in history when state-sanctioned hackers stole $6.3 billion from the Binance cryptocurrency exchange. About half of the assets made their way into Pyongyang’s coffers. As the world’s largest exchange, Binance said it would cover its customers’ losses, but the hack still spooked many crypto traders, who are notoriously jumpy. They withdrew $3.6 billion on Sunday. The paranoia around holding cryptocurrency is well founded. In essence, they are just digital currencies which are incredibly hard to trace. You can follow the transactions, but you don’t know the identity of who owns them. Funds can be moved around multiple times a minute and easily swapped between different currencies, all with no checks.

Why are Brits so bad at investing?

Looking around Britain today, we can identify plenty of three-letter initialisms making our lives miserable. The BBC, with its hand in your pocket and potently mad programming; the NHS, which sucks in an ever-growing £205 billion a year of taxpayers’ money but seems to be incapable of reform; the WFH epidemic, which is devastating to productivity. However, there is one three-letter acronym which could solve a lot of our problems as a nation – the Individual Savings Account, or Isa. Previously, it was Sid. In 1986, the Thatcher government launched a highly effective campaign advertising shares in British Gas called Tell Sid. It persuaded some 4.5 million people to consider investing in this newly denationalised utility, reintroducing the British public to retail investing.

Girls, just say no to lab-grown diamonds

These days, when I spot a proper bobby-dazzler of a diamond on a woman’s ring finger, I feel a bit sick. Not with envy, but with the queasy certainty that I am looking at a comically large, factory-made fake. A real diamond is one of the most ancient things in this world. Under the heat and pressure of billions of years trapped in the earth, scraps of carbon transformed into a precious stone. Everything we have valued in diamonds – the hardness, the fiery glitter, the rarity – comes from that long and improbable journey. The impersonations – although we’re meant to call them ‘lab-grown’ or ‘synthetic’ – are mainly produced in Indian or Chinese machines and cost a fraction of the real thing.