James Hanson

Data center derangement has spread to Britain

(Photo: Getty)

Why are AI data centers sending everybody mad? On Saturday, thousands of people marched through the streets of Edinburgh in a staggering display of latter-day Luddism. Women dressed in owl costumes carried placards reading “hands off our habitat” while other signs decried “we can’t drink data” and “AI data centers threaten humanity.” While some protesters had concerns about specific sites, such as East Lothian and Falkirk, many simply rejected the need for data centers altogether. A placard reading “tech billionaires don’t need more money” seemed typical of the wider sentiment.

American golf course uses more than 2 billion gallons per day for irrigation, more than four times as much

The sudden skepticism about AI data centers seems to have migrated from America to Scotland. Opposition to data centers was cited as one of the reasons for the Democrats’ recent success in the midterms. In Texas, which is home to more than a quarter of America’s planned data center gigawatts, Senator-elect James Talarico made the issue a cornerstone of his campaign. Pro-Talarico super-PACs targeted traditionally red counties with leaflets that read: “WARNING: there is an existing or proposed data center near you… Ken Paxton made it easier to build.”

Some of the opposition to data centers is understandable. Voters are already anxious about the onset of artificial intelligence and its potential to change the world beyond all recognition. At best, people worry AI will take their jobs. At worst, they fear it will destroy humanity. Given these anxieties, it’s pretty easy to portray data centers as the uninvited harbingers of a dystopian tomorrow. It also doesn’t help that the men in charge of the world’s biggest AI companies are some of the most unlikable on the planet, from the adulterous Jensen Huang to the cringe-inducing Elon Musk. The tech bros are the perfect comic book villains for the anti-data center movement to rail against.

And yet so much of the opposition to data centers is completely irrational. We’re not talking about chemical factories pumping out fumes, we’re talking about warehouses filled with computers. Give me a data center on my doorstep over a recycling plant or an asylum facility any day. Furthermore, claims about their water usage are hugely exaggerated. US data centers use roughly 449 million gallons of water per day for cooling. By contrast, the average American golf course uses more than 2 billion gallons per day for irrigation, more than four times as much. So why aren’t the Democrats campaigning against golf courses, and where are Scotland’s anti-Open Championship protests down the Royal Mile?

But the question of water usage is built on a false premise. Neither Britain, nor the entire planet, lacks enough water to keep data centers cool. We simply lack sufficient places to store it. The last time a new reservoir was completed in the UK was 1992, and it’s not as if the much-maligned private water companies haven’t been trying to build them. Thames Water have been wanting to construct a new reservoir in Abingdon for years, except it’s been consistently blocked by locals. Bristol Water tried to build a second reservoir at Cheddar, until it was rejected by the regulator Ofwat in 2014. Planning permission has also been refused for new reservoirs in East Sussex, Hampshire, Kent and the Lower Severn.

Just think about that. Thames Water wanted to build a reservoir: locals said no. Bristol Water wanted to build a reservoir: the regulator said no. And yet now we’re being told Britain doesn’t have enough water to accommodate new data centers. It’s almost as if the problem isn’t really data centers, it’s decades of catastrophic planning decisions. And yet the very same people who have thwarted new reservoirs are now attempting to thwart data centers.

Then, there are the concerns over the energy consumption of data centers. In Britain, an oft-quoted statistic is that their electricity requirements are equivalent to the domestic usage of approximately 1.7 million households. While that figure is broadly accurate, data centers still only account for around 2 percent of demand on the UK’s national grid. Inevitably that number will increase over time, but it is a false binary to suggest data centers pose a threat to the transition to clean energy. By contrast, AI can help finance that transition, not least because the huge electricity demand caused by such sites will provide companies with the commercial incentive to increase generating capacity.

Britain used to be a country that built things. Now we’re a country that blocks things. What would Brunel make of the fact we’ve spent more on the planning application for the Lower Thames Crossing (first proposed in 1989 and still not built) than it cost the Norwegians to construct the world’s longest road tunnel? If the great engineer were around today, he’d be a tech bro planning his next data center, because being opposed to them in 2026 is a bit like being opposed to steam or coal power in the late eighteenth century. The AI train is leaving the station and Britain simply cannot afford to be left behind.

Comments