Like a dark cloud on the horizon, distinguished members of the British elite are once again advocating for the reintroduction of national service. In an op-ed offensive earlier this month, former prime minister Rishi Sunak and ex-national security adviser Mark Sedwill have separately argued for the scheme’s revival.
Reintroducing national service is a terrible idea. It strips young people of their freedom and autonomy at the most exciting point in their lives. Our military also neither needs nor wants this burden, the associated costs and economic disruption. A National Citizen Service was introduced by David Cameron in 2010 and ran until last year, clearly having no discernible effect on ‘social cohesion’ and no lasting impact on the national psyche.
Subjecting the nation’s embittered youth to nine months of menial tasks in the name of skills development and togetherness is more likely to engender a lingering resentment towards the state than solidarity with one’s countrymen. When Sunak included national service in his 2024 election manifesto, he was asked by one young student why he ‘hates young people so much’.
The young should be allowed their liberty
Interestingly, proponents of national service can’t quite agree on what the scheme might look like – only that young people must suffer. While Sedwill articulated a distinctly military form of service, Sunak quite rightly acknowledged that Britain’s armed forces neither need nor could manage a massive influx of volunteers akin to the pre-1960s model. Instead, Sunak has talked of a ‘resilience corps’ with a selective military cadre and far more emphasis on options such as ‘St. John Ambulance or Meals on Wheels’. In other words, compulsory volunteering.
Sunak would, therefore, have it such that young people are drafted en masse to prop up collapsing parts of the state before entering a workforce shouldering the highest tax burden since the end of the war. But the belief that national service could improve skills and help the young out of the ‘NEET crisis’ rests on a reluctance to accept that successive governments have destroyed the entry-level job market in Britain, and the assumption that even more state intervention can fix this. This type of thinking was visible in the recent Milburn review on NEETs, which recommended that the state subsidise entry-level jobs instead.
Minimum wage hikes, increasing National Insurance employer contributions and onerous new regulations such as those in the Employment Rights Act have made hiring young people a riskier and more expensive proposition for British businesses. At the same time, an unsustainably generous safety net insulates people from the costs of being inactive. It is strange that Sunak imagines that national service could address the rise in mental health-related benefits claims without considering how mental health exemptions could undermine his ‘resilience corps’ from the get-go.
This is a tragedy, as it is entry-level jobs that often give people their first taste of financial independence and responsibility. This breeds resilience, develops the foundations for prosperity, and produces a society that people will voluntarily want to defend.
Of course, proponents also argue that the service will help establish a common sense of identity, or ‘Britishness’, as the former prime minister put it. Perhaps this is a tacit admission that devaluing the concept of citizenship by letting millions of asylum seekers into the country was a mistake, but this isn’t going to be addressed by forcing the young to staff the care homes and mow grass verges on the side of the A1.
The murmurs around national service are only one part of a new obsession with resilience. As part of the new ‘Be Ready’ campaign, the government are urging people to stockpile three-days’ worth of essentials. The announcement might have been more credible had the treasury minister leading the broadcast not smirked his way through the interview before admitting he hadn’t followed the guidance himself.
It is easier to dress up impending crises as external threats rather than admit catastrophic errors in government policy. There is no doubt that our adversaries will exploit vulnerabilities in Britain’s critical infrastructure, but they are not responsible for the system’s design. The transition to intermittent renewables under net zero has left the country vulnerable to electricity shortages. Earlier this month the power grid operator issued another supply warning, paying ten times market prices to secure emergency generation from gas plant operators.
Is it preferable, then, to foster some sense of Blitz spirit if the lights go out by impressing the nation’s youth and handing out hand-crank radios? Perhaps the government could focus on the difficult but entirely fixable problems facing the country. Even on defence, it is possible to start improving numbers in the reserves by addressing the outlandish delays in recruitment caused by analogue medical processing and needlessly strict admission criteria. A more reasonable way of encouraging younger people to enlist might be to look at tying periods of service to student debt reduction.
Those in charge should devote more time to fixing these fundamentals rather than relying on the young as an inexhaustible supply of labour. Our leaders might look at Eastern European models of national service and conscription with envy, but in many of these places most people over the age of 50 had to speak Russian as subjects of the Soviet empire. We cannot hope to replicate the same sense of fear and recent historical memory that lies behind their conception of service.
Nor should we want to. The young should be allowed their liberty. The state cannot demand ever greater fealty while offering nothing in return.
Comments