Those born at the turn of the millennium will have lived through a lot of bad music. Dubstep, LMFAO and the protracted craze for Auto-Tune were the soundtracks to our unhappy adolescence. It is not without justification that our parents told us it was all garbage compared with Zeppelin and ‘the Stones’. In fact, there are studies which suggest music has become markedly more repetitive and self-centred since the 1970s.
There is one glimmer of hope, however: our generation’s music was better than the AI slop the kids are listening to now. ‘Movin’ to the Sun’, a song credited to the French producer Hugel, Imael Angel and Ultra Naté, has now been no. 1 on the UK dance chart for 14 weeks. The song is so popular that it reached no. 2 on the official singles chart in August – kept off the top spot only by Olivia Dean and Sam Fender – and has racked up more than 220 million streams on Spotify. There have now been several calls for ‘Movin’ to the Sun’ to be removed from the UK charts on the basis that it was made using AI.
What if people come to love AI music? What if it takes over popular music entirely?
‘Movin’ to the Sun’ was created by Imael Angel – real name Bernadett Gango, a Hungarian energy healer living in England – who wrote the lyrics and some of the melody before feeding them into Suno, an AI music generator. The result, ‘I’m Moving to the Sun’, was sung by an AI-generated voice and went viral on TikTok. Hugel then picked it up, rebuilt the production and recruited Ultra Naté, best known for the 1997 track ‘Free’ (no. 4 on the UK Singles Chart), to sing a new lead vocal.
So while ‘Movin’ to the Sun’ is not pure AI slop, it is also not purely not AI slop. So what is it? Partially AI slop? Just people making use of new tools? Hugel says the finished product is overwhelmingly human – his team puts it at about 95 per cent – because he rebuilt the drums, bass, keys and strings himself and Ultra Naté recorded her vocals in a studio. But he also admits that parts of the original were sampled, and an AI-generated vocal still sits in the mix beneath hers.
The IFPI, the record industry’s global body, says charts should exclude tracks made with AI services that are not ‘properly authorised and lawful’ or that are not ‘substantially human-made’. Suno, which was trained on other people’s music without their permission, was not licensed when Gango used it, and the IFPI has excluded ‘Movin’ to the Sun’ from the charts it runs. Our own Official Charts Company says it welcomes the rules but has not yet put them into practice, which is why the song is still in our charts.
Hugel is appealing his exclusion from the international charts, but given the understandable strength of feeling that human musicians have towards AI, and the outsized cultural and political influence they often enjoy, it would seem a fair bet that over time AI-generated tracks will be excluded from the charts.
There is a risk to excluding AI songs – what if people come to love AI music? What if it takes over popular music entirely? The charting firms refusing to acknowledge this change would just mean their charts have no bearing on what people are really listening to. I gave ‘Movin’ to the Sun’ a listen on the way into work this morning and must confess that it was catchy, if a little mindless.
The good news for the technophobes is that there are already well over 250 million tracks held across streaming services today, which should be enough to last you over a few dozen lifetimes of continuous listening without ever having to listen to anything made after ChatGPT was released in 2022. Fingers crossed that the AI can’t figure out how to make us all immortal, or we’ll be ‘Movin’ to the Sun’ forever.
Comments