Matthew Lynn Matthew Lynn

Andy Burnham has to choose between Europe and the Neets

(Photo: Getty)

Young people have to be helped back into work. It is a scandal that they are being left on benefits. And the government is planning to offer whatever training is needed so they can make a start on their career.

Anyone following the government’s spin about the Milburn report yesterday would have been left with the impression that Prime Minister Andy Burnham had no greater priority than fixing the Neets, or ‘Not in Education, Employment or Training’, crisis. But hold on. It now turns out he also wants to flood the labour market with tens of thousands of young Europeans. Burnham may not know enough economics to have figured out there is a contradiction between the two – but sooner or later he will have to choose between the EU and the Neets. 

Plenty of young Europeans will take jobs in Britain, and very few will travel in the other direction

There is certainly no shortage of rhetoric around the plan to get young people back into work. With almost a million 16-24 year olds not doing much except browsing TikTok all day, some 13 per cent of the total age group, something clearly needs to be done. The Neet crisis is costing a fortune in welfare and, perhaps more importantly, it is stopping people from starting a career that might give them some purpose. We can all argue whether the Milburn report has the right solutions. But at least the intention is there.

The trouble is, it is about to be undermined. As part of his EU reset, the Prime Minister is planning to sign up for a ‘youth experience scheme’ with the rest of Europe. Sure, it may sound like a nice gap year programme. But in fact, it would allow 100,000 low-skilled workers from across the continent to come and work in Britain for up to three years

But hold on? How does that fit in with the plan to get young British people back into work? There are already plenty of visas for skilled workers, so surely it is only going to flood the market with young Poles and Italians looking to improve their English while serving coffee for a couple of years. In fairness, it will also allow some of the British Neets to work at the Munich beer festival, or run the kids’ club at a hotel in Corfu. Overall, however, the traffic will be one-way. Plenty of young Europeans will take jobs in Britain, and very few will travel in the other direction. 

There are only two ways this can work out. At best, all the extra workers will lower wages, undermining the drive to get people off benefits, by making work less attractive than it already is. At worst, they will take most of the few jobs that are still available. Partly because they are cheaper, and also because many of them will already have some experience. The money will be spent on retraining all the Neets, and then at the end of the process there won’t be anything for them to do. We already knew that Burnham had a very limited understanding of economics. But it was not clear it was quite this limited. At a certain point, he will have to choose between the EU and the Neets. Just hoping to get through on vibes won’t work much longer. 

Written by
Matthew Lynn

Matthew Lynn is a financial columnist and author of ‘Bust: Greece, The Euro and The Sovereign Debt Crisis’ and ‘The Long Depression: The Slump of 2008 to 2031’

This article originally appeared in the UK edition

Topics in this article

Comments