It seems unlikely that there will be much in Alan Milburn’s report tomorrow into young people and work that hasn’t already been widely reported. The big question is less what he will say and more whether his report will become the latest in the long line that is quietly dumped, such as Sir Andrew Dilnot’s 2011 commission into social care provision and Henry Dimbleby’s proposed National Food Strategy in 2021 (both under Conservative governments; this is not a party-political point).
The big question is less what Milburn will say and more whether his report will become the latest in the long line that is quietly dumped
Andy Burnham and work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden have certainly given every indication that they are committed to Milburn’s reforms. But as we saw in 2024 with the collapse of Liz Kendall’s relatively minor proposals in the face of opposition from Labour MPs, it is one thing for a PM and a Secretary of State to back a reform; it is quite another for them to follow through and deliver it.
In that sense this may be a case of déjà vu for Milburn, because he has been here before: back in 2002 when he was Health Secretary and a key aspect of his plan for radical reform of the NHS was dumped by the then Prime Minister in the face of opposition.
Milburn was made Health Secretary by Tony Blair in 1999 after the initial disastrous appointment of Frank Dobson, who was not only clueless about the real problems with the NHS but determined that nothing should change. Milburn was given the task of doing whatever he could to bring the NHS into the modern world. He started off with a bang, signing the so-called Concordat with the private sector in June 2000 which allowed the NHS to use private hospital beds for waiting lists and winter pressures.
But Milburn had far bolder ideas for NHS reform, one of which was for Foundation Hospitals. Much like the introduction in 2000 of academy schools that were freed from local authority control, so in 2002 Milburn proposed a form of independence for hospitals.
Taking inspiration from public/non-profit hospital models abroad (such as in Spain), Milburn’s proposed “earned autonomy” for the best performing “three-star” trusts, which would give them freedom from central micro-management. This would foster a more entrepreneurial, dynamic culture where hospitals could respond faster to patient needs and local conditions. It was classic Blairite “third way” policy, with a public-benefit model sitting between traditional state-run bureaucracy and private healthcare that would drive up standards across the NHS.
But one key part of Milburn’s plan was that these quasi-independent hospitals would also be financially self-governing and thus able to borrow without it counting towards the government’s balance sheet, free of the Treasury.
The proposals were met with vitriolic opposition from the Labour left and even beyond. But while Blair would as a matter of habit (and some pride) ignore the left, there was another opponent Blair could not ignore: Gordon Brown.
The Chancellor argued that hospitals would pile up debt in the knowledge that the state would have to rescue them if they got into trouble. Brown’s opposition became public knowledge in August 2002 when Milburn wrote an article in the Times in which he described the battle within government between transformers and consolidators:
“There is a choice. We could choose a strategy of consolidation – accepting the reforms made so far and relying on increased public expenditure to deliver an expanded service but one whose culture remains essentially unchanged. Or, as I believe we must, we could choose transformation, recognising that extra spending alone is insufficient to deliver improvements in public services.”
The row dragged on in an increasingly bitter dispute between Milburn and Brown. In October, Blair called both in to Downing Street and, essentially, caved to Brown. Borrowing by foundation trusts would stay on the government’s balance sheet and count against the spending limits the Treasury had already set for the NHS, so anything a foundation trust borrowed had to come out of what was left for every other hospital. The new Foundation Hospitals could not borrow freely, set their own pay or compete on price.
Twenty-three years later, Milburn again has the supposed backing of a prime minister for a series of bold reforms he is proposing, this time over welfare. But here is a salutary thought. The last time he was in this position, the PM caved to opposition. That PM was Tony Blair. Is there anyone who seriously thinks that Andy Burnham will have more stomach for a fight over reform than Tony Blair?
Comments