Andrew Gilligan

The truth about the links between Bylines Network and Byline Times

Byline Times and Bylines Networks Ltd are controlled by the same people, Peter Jukes (pictured) and Steve Colegrave (Credit: YouTube)

When I’m investigating someone who I know will complain, I often hold back evidence from the initial piece. Once the indignant threats and protests come in from the subject, I roll out that saved material to, shall we say, put their denials into perspective.

My story in The Spectator on Tuesday that Bylines Network, an organisation closely linked to the left-wing crank website Byline Times, had been handed £266,000 of public money in a government programme to promote “trusted” news caused a stir, including being followed up nationally. Unsurprisingly, Bylines Network wasn’t pleased. Who’d want to be publicly associated with an operation as absurd as Byline Times?

Unsurprisingly, Bylines Network wasn’t pleased. Who’d want to be publicly associated with an operation as absurd as Byline Times?

Bylines Network can’t very well deny that they share two directors, Peter Jukes and Steve Colegrave, with Byline Times; or that they describe themselves as a “partner organisation to Byline Times” and say that the two organisations “work closely together.” But they have complained, denying any “financial or policy overlap” between them and Byline Times; said that they are “legally, financially and editorially separate” and that “none” of the articles they have published “was commissioned or edited by anyone connected to Byline Times.” They further insist that Bylines Network is “non-partisan” and “politically neutral.”

That seems to run entirely contrary to statements made by Mike Galsworthy, Bylines Network’s founder and one of its four directors, who has described Bylines Network’s ten outlets (Bylines Yorkshire, Bylines Scotland, Bylines Sussex, etc) as “local citizen versions of Byline Times” produced using a “white label version of their website” with legal, technical and funding support from Byline Times. Sounds like a legal and financial overlap to me, Mike!

As he put it:

“The Bylines Network developed from a direct collaboration with Byline Times…We had the communities and structures to approach local journalism from a very new angle; local citizen journalism starting with a large ready-made audience. I pitched that idea to Peter [Jukes] and he told me that the web developers for Byline Times had just developed a ‘white label’ version of their website, but did not know what to use it for. This notion of local citizen versions of Byline Times fitted like hand in glove…

“Byline Times had provided the inspiration for our citizen journalism model. They now also provided the know-how. Peter and team helped us out with our web design, legal advice, tech support, and part-funding an audience development officer post for a year, which made a huge difference.”

The claim that there is “editorial” separation and that “none” of the articles Bylines Network publishes was commissioned by anyone connected to Byline Times is also false. This year alone, one Bylines Network outlet, North West Bylines, has published – indeed cut and pasted, largely word-for-word – at least three articles commissioned and published by Byline Times, all of them written by BT’s truther king, Nafeez Ahmed (see here, here and here, and the original Byline Times versions here, here and here.) More broadly, across its ten sites the Bylines Network has cited Byline Times journalism a total of 152 times, by my count.

As for political impartiality, let us examine the “politics” section of Yorkshire Bylines, the first Bylines Network site to be established. Articles published are overwhelmingly left-wing, anti-Tory and Reform and pro-EU (Galsworthy, the founder, is chair of the European Movement UK.) The most recent month’s fare includes: “Embracing EU free movement should hold no terrors for the UK,” “‘Reforming’ Britain? A window to the past,” Burnham has opened the door on Europe – now let the public in,” and “Burnham’s bold plan for social care reform.”

Earlier impartial work included multiple pieces attacking Yorkshire Tory MPs, including one on Miriam Cates depicting her in a handmaid uniform from The Handmaid’s Tale. The Byline Times Nafeez Ahmed pieces published by North West Bylines were mostly part of an emergency effort to stiff Matt Goodwin, the Reform candidate in the Gorton byelection.

There’s nothing wrong with partisanship, of course. The Spectator is partisan. But it is honest about it – and it is not funded with public money.

Comments