Katy Balls

Katy Balls

Katy Balls is The Spectator’s former political editor.

The letter row is a reminder of Theresa May’s weakness

From our UK edition

Some things never change. It's the end of the first week of the new term and the Conservatives are finishing it with a row about Brexit. Although there are several rows currently brewing on Brexit – from amendments to the EU (withdrawal) bill to David Davis's 'stability' – the one that is giving the Prime Minister the biggest headache involves a letter and a minister. The letter – thought to have been destined for the Sunday Telegraph – says that Britain should not pay into the EU budget during a transition period and must be able to sign trade deals straight after Brexit. These demands go further than current government policy and it has been circulated among Brexit-backing Tories, with dozens said to have signed it so far.

Could an Englishman ever be First Minister of Scotland?

From our UK edition

Could an Englishman ever be First Minister of Scotland? That's the question the Scottish Labour party are having to grapple with this week after Richard Leonard announced his candidacy to succeed Kezia Dugdale as leader. A former trade union organiser and chair of Scottish Labour's executive, Leonard sounds like the perfect Corbyn candidate – until you get to the fact that he is also English. Leonard's opponents have been quick to jump on his nationality – briefing out that his English heritage is no small fry. They claim his Yorkshire accent could make it 'hard' for him to 'connect' with the people the party must win over to increase their vote share. One opponent goes so far as to say that picking an Englishman would be 'disastrous'.

May fried over public sector pay at PMQs

From our UK edition

Jeremy Corbyn and Theresa May spent their lunchtime talking about McDonalds. Unfortunately for the Prime Minister, it was McStrike, rather than a lunchtime order, that dominated her first PMQs since the summer recess. Asked to show support for those workers currently taking industrial action against the fast food giant, May would only say that it was a matter for McDonalds – before going on to attack Labour for not doing more to tackle zero hour contracts when they were in government. This felt evasive and allowed Corbyn to go on and pit her against the side of the workers when he asked about the government's diluted plans to crackdown on corporate excess. Although Corbyn asked several topical questions effectively, his problem was that he asked too many.

Meet ‘other’ – the candidate to beat Jacob Rees-Mogg for Tory leader

From our UK edition

Although Damian Green has insisted Theresa May will lead the party into the next election, this hasn't stopped Jacob Rees-Mogg receiving the first 'official endorsement' for leader. Last night, Activate – the questionable attempt at a 'Tory momentum' – announced that it was backing the Moggster. Given that this grassroots movement is yet to take off, it's  unlikely to cause CCHQ much concern just yet. However, today's Conservative Home survey might. In a sign that Moggmentum isn't just confined to Facebook groups, Jacob Rees-Mogg has topped ConHome's Next Tory Leader survey of party members. A candidate by the name of 'other' comes a close second, while David Davis is now third favourite followed by Dominic Raab – a justice minister.

Should Theresa May reshuffle her Cabinet?

From our UK edition

When Parliament returns tomorrow, Theresa May will come back to work to find her position a bit more secure than it was when she left for the summer break. With no obvious leadership challenger and her party vaguely united behind her, May looks safe in No 10 in the coming months – even if her claim that she could lead her party into another election looks dubious at best. It follows that talk has now turned to how she could shore up her position and assert her authority on her party. The Times reports that the prime minister and her allies are planning to use the threat of a reshuffle to further bolster her authority.

Money worries cast a cloud over David Davis’s bank holiday weekend

From our UK edition

Spare a thought for David Davis over the bank holiday weekend. As revellers descend on Notting Hill Carnival on Monday, the Brexit Secretary will be at the negotiating table in Brussels for the third round of Brexit talks. With the EU 27 adamant that trade talks can only begin once progress has been made on the other issues, the focus will be on the Brexit 'divorce bill', the rights of EU nationals, and the Irish border. Given how uphill talks have been so far, the expectation in Whitehall is that this could be a bad-tempered outing for both sides. Michel Barnier – the EU’s chief negotiator – is expected to, once again, ask Davis to say how the UK proposes to calculate its financial obligations to the EU.

Jeremy Corbyn’s Scotland tour comes at an awkward time for the SNP

From our UK edition

Ever since the snap election, Jeremy Corbyn has been in campaign mode – claiming Theresa May's minority government is on the verge of collapse and that there will be another election within months. Tomorrow, the Labour leader kicks off a summer tour of Scotland, which he claims 'holds the keys' to getting his party back in power: 'We have stayed on an election footing all summer, and nowhere is more important to delivering another Labour government than Scotland. The only way to deliver the truly radical change that Scotland needs is to back Labour in Scotland.' Much to the upset of the Nats, the 18 seats Corbyn will be targeting on the trip are all held by the SNP – rather than the common enemy of the Tories.

A fake Tory leadership war has begun

From our UK edition

When a new MP is offered a job as a parliamentary private secretary for a cabinet member, it’s often a test to see if they really would do anything to get into government. It involves running errands, spying on colleagues, ferrying messages around the Commons and planting inane questions for backbenchers to ask in the chamber. But in this hung Parliament, another duty has been added to those of the Tory PPS: to report anyone who might look as if they’re running for leadership. The Tory whips’ office has asked every PPS to inform them if any minister is behaving suspiciously — giving grand speeches about the state of the nation, perhaps, inviting colleagues for drinks or just making a few too many friends.

The phoney Tory leadership war

From our UK edition

When a new MP is offered a job as a parliamentary private secretary for a cabinet member, it’s often a test to see if they really would do anything to get into government. It involves running errands, spying on colleagues, ferrying messages around the Commons and planting inane questions for backbenchers to ask in the chamber. But in this hung Parliament, another duty has been added to those of the Tory PPS: to report anyone who might look as if they’re running for leadership. The Tory whips’ office has asked every PPS to inform them if any minister is behaving suspiciously — giving grand speeches about the state of the nation, perhaps, inviting colleagues for drinks or just making a few too many friends.

Why you shouldn’t bet on a Rees-Mogg premiership just yet

From our UK edition

There are many ways to dampen down speculation surrounding one's leadership ambitions. However, writing an article headlined 'I do not plan to be PM, but here is how the Tories could lead better' isn't one of them. This is what Jacob Rees-Mogg did this morning for the Telegraph, thereby pouring petrol on reports over the weekend that he is 'sounding out' friends and considering throwing his hat into the ring to be the next leader. While one Tory MP, Heidi Allen, has already broken rank to say she would leave the party if Rees-Mogg were to become leader, many activists will hope the reports prove to be true. The Moggster – as he has come to be known – has developed a cult following, with Tory activists deeming him to be the Conservative answer to Corbyn.

Bank of England: inflation blip is ‘entirely’ temporary

From our UK edition

Although Mark Carney has earned a reputation for doom-mongering over Brexit, today's Bank of England press conference wasn't all doom and gloom. While the bank voted – at six votes to two – to keep interest rates at 0.25pc (see the leader in this week's issue of The Spectator for why this isn't such a great idea), its Inflation Report did bear better-than-expected news. On inflation, Carney said it was expected to peak at 3pc in October from its current rate of 2.6pc.

The Tories need to seem serious about balancing the books

From our UK edition

There are some things in life that you can always rely on: the sun will rise in the East, there will be showers in April, and the Conservatives will find a way to put off balancing the books. Although George Osborne – back when he was Chancellor – initially aimed to eliminate the structural deficit by 2015, it has since been pushed back time and time again. His successor Philip Hammond isn't much better, pushing paying off the deficit until the middle of the next decade, in the 2017 manifesto. At the time, I wrote that their record on the issue meant there was little reason to believe the Tories would even stick with the new date.

Breaking: Prime Minister’s spokesman says nothing new

From our UK edition

Ahead of the summer recess, there was concern among Tory high command that the long holiday could result in seven weeks of leadership plotting. But worried Mayites can rest easy as instead what's transpired instead is an endless free-for-all over the government's Brexit position. Every day hacks now take a comment from a minister on one aspect of Brexit and then try and work out whether or not the whole Cabinet agrees with them. Today it was the Prime Minister's spokesman who stepped up to the plate.

The Cabinet’s Brexit position is transitioning

From our UK edition

Although this week has seen a divergence of views in the Cabinet over Brexit (not to mention Labour's continuing Brexit confusion) on everything from chlorinated chicken to freedom of movement, there is one aspect of the negotiations that all ministers can agree on: the need for a transitional agreement. Speaking on the Today programme, the Chancellor confirmed that 'many things would look similar' the day after Brexit. The new Cabinet consensus for an implementation period while the UK moves towards a new relationship with the EU is something Philip Hammond has been lobbying for for some time. The expectation in Whitehall is that Theresa May will give a speech in September setting out in more detail the government’s view on Brexit and transition.

The confusion over immigration shows the government is being pulled in three directions

From our UK edition

Another day, another mixed message from the government over its position on Brexit. This time it's immigration that has become the source of confusion after the Home Secretary and her minister appeared to come up with conflicting lines this morning. In an article for the Financial Times, Amber Rudd said she wanted to reassure businesses and EU nationals that 'we will ensure there is no “cliff edge” once we leave the bloc'. To do this, she said the flow of EU workers would continue for an 'implementation period' after Britain's exit. However, speaking on the Today programme, Brandon Lewis – the Home Office minister – appeared to take a more hardline approach. He said freedom of movement from the EU would end in Spring 2019.

Cabinet ministers deserve to be roasted for giving this chicken story legs

From our UK edition

Don't Liam Fox and Michael Gove know how to use Skype? Just as the Cabinet finally start to reach agreement on the nuts and bolts of the UK's Brexit negotiating position, a row has broken out across the Atlantic about chlorinated chicken. Much to Fox's frustration, his trip to Washington to begin US/UK trade talks has been dominated by chicken. After accusing the British press of being 'obsessed' by the issue of chlorinated chicken being a part of a trade deal, Fox has attempted to dampen down speculation on the issue.

Liam Fox’s Brexit optimism is matched by President Trump’s

From our UK edition

Liam Fox is well known for his optimism when it comes to Brexit. The International Trade Secretary has even been accused by his critics of wishful thinking over what Britain will look like outside of the EU. And so it was that as Fox headed to Washington this week to lay the groundwork for UK/US trade talks, there were murmurs that rather than preparing the ground for a free trade deal, these talks would be about nothing more than ensuring 'continuity' once Britain has left the EU. Wrong – at least one Yank shares his optimism. President Trump has taken to social media to talk up the 'big and exciting' 'major trade deal' that could be struck between the UK and US: https://twitter.

Will Labour’s tuition fee row end Corbyn-mania?

From our UK edition

As Theresa May sets off hiking in the Italian alps, CCHQ can take heart that – for a change – it's not Conservative in-fighting dominating the headlines. Instead, it's Labour's dubious election promises – thanks to Jeremy Corbyn's admission on the Andrew Marr show that his party has no plans to abolish pre-existing student debt. The reason this presents a problem for Labour is an interview Corbyn gave to NME magazine during the General Election campaign. Discussing tuition fees, the Labour leader said that on top of axing fees, he would 'deal with those already burdened with student debt’: 'I don’t see why those that had the historical misfortune to be at university during the £9,000 period should be burdened excessively.

Brexit talks reach a stalemate on EU nationals

From our UK edition

This afternoon, David Davis and Michel Barnier gave a joint press conference to update hacks on the progress that's been made in the second instalment of Brexit talks. However, there wasn't all that much progress to report back on. Michel Barnier, the EU's chief negotiator, said there was a 'fundamental' split between the EU and the UK over how to guarantee the rights of EU nationals. The disagreement rests on whether citizens' rights should be backed by the Court of Justice of the European Union or the British courts. Barnier appeared to adopt a more hardline approach than before on the reasons for wanting the ECJ to rule on this – he said citizens had moved to the UK expecting this to be the case.

In defeat, Theresa May has done what David Cameron couldn’t

From our UK edition

Today the House rises for summer recess and, as James writes, Downing Street achieves its immediate post-election aim: Theresa May makes it to the summer recess. The government hopes the break will allow the party to regroup and come back more focused and more united. Whether that happens or not, what is clear is that the Prime Minister's position will be uphill. Following her fateful decision to call an early election which saw the Conservatives lose their majority, May is a diminished figure – both within her party and in public. MPs openly make jokes at her expense at parties while her Cabinet talk freely now that her authority is shot.