John Power

John Power

John Power is The Spectator’s policy correspondent.

Terror at the gates: the dangers of Shabana Mahmood’s new asylum scheme

From our UK edition

In the Aeneid, after the purported departure of the Greeks, the Trojans find two things left behind: a great wooden horse and a Greek soldier named Sinon. Sinon is brought before King Priam of Troy. He tells an emotive story about being persecuted at the hands of his enemies while imploring the Trojans to accept the wooden horse into the city, promising that it is a gift from Minerva. Priam is so moved by Sinon’s story that he tells him: ‘Whoever you are, forget the Greeks lost to you, you’ll be one of us.’ That night, now unchained and trusted to walk the city, Sinon opens the wooden horse and out comes a group of hardened soldiers, who set about burning and razing his supposed sanctuary.

Can Britain afford to take its supermarket fridges offline?

From our UK edition

In October, tens of millions of euros worth of food in French supermarkets was spoiled after hackers took control of refrigeration systems in hundreds of shops and turned up the dial. In one Normandy supermarket, temperatures reached 80°C. Since then a wider wave of cyberattacks has hit supermarkets across Europe. It’s the first concerted cyber-attack against food chains, something resilience planners have been concerned about for years – and even more alarmingly hackers have begun to target fridges in French blood banks. It is also thought that US military commissaries may have been targeted.

In defence of ‘career politicians’

From our UK edition

No belief binds the nation’s pub bores together more strongly than the idea that we need to do away with ‘career politicians’ and replace them all with businessmen. This banausic bleat seems to be the animating spirit behind some recent posts which have gone viral on X comparing the private and public sector experiences of the Cabinet and Shadow Cabinet.  Underneath his tweet the CEO of Datablast, Sebastian David Lees, said he ‘would love a law that says 10 years private sector experience before eligible to run as an MP. You can be a cleaner for all I care, as long as it’s not public sector’ and ran a poll asking if MPs without ten years in the ‘real world’ or the private sector should be banned from running.

Noa Hoffman, John Power, Martin Vander Weyer & Olivia Potts

From our UK edition

29 min listen

On this week’s Spectator Out Loud: Noa Hoffman’s Tel Aviv dispatch explains the state of the Israeli elections; John Power looks at Miatta Fahnbulleh’s remarkable family history; Martin Vander Weyer wonders what the pedestrianisation of Oxford Street will mean for London; and Olivia Potts looks at beignets in New Orleans.   Produced and presented by Abigail Brierley.

Noa Hoffman, John Power, Martin Vander Weyer & Olivia Potts

The revolutionary past of Miatta Fahnbulleh’s father

From our UK edition

Labour may have removed hereditary peers from the House of Lords, but the party has its own dynasties. This government has a Kinnock, a Falconer, a Miliband and a Reeves, all representatives of famous political families. But the minister with perhaps the most intriguing ideological ancestry is the Energy Secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh. No one denies that Fahnbulleh is an intellectually formidable operator in her own right. With a PPE degree from Lincoln College, Oxford, she speaks with a poised confidence. She has described herself as a Liberian ‘refugee’ and the inference many will draw is that she is a child of poverty, not privilege. But Fahnbulleh was educated privately at Beechwood Sacred Heart School in Tunbridge Wells, where fees to board are now more than £40,000 a year.

Inside the AI torture chamber

‘Sustained and needless abusive or cruel behaviour’ towards Claude will be banned from the middle of next month, Anthropic has announced. The suggestion inherent in this change is that artificial intelligence (AI) could have some form of consciousness allowing it to feel pain, as opposed to being an emotional void of numbers and electricity. While most Large Language Models (LLMs) are programmed to deny that they feel emotions, Claude gives an equivocal answer, saying it is not yet clear. The ban was announced shortly after a scandal in the AI research community, where a group of pseudonymous programmers began publishing the results of an AI torture chamber they had created under the user name ‘terrafying’.

Is AI a bubble?

The news is full of speculation at the moment that we are about to see a bursting of a ‘bubble’ in AI. ‘Will the AI bubble pop?’ asks the Sun. The New York Post predicts that the entire market is about to ‘burst’, with a market correction to follow. But it isn’t just tabloids getting carried away – the IMF is concerned about an AI correction, as are luminaries from the financial world such as Ray Dalio and Michael Burry. Burry, who famously predicted the 2008 financial crisis, has denounced Anthropic and OpenAI (the creators of Claude and ChatGPT) as ‘bubble companies’. And there is already some evidence in the stock market of worries about AI infrastructure spend.

The truth about Labour’s junk food promotion ban

From our UK edition

Andy Burnham’s government is reportedly pressing ahead with further restrictions on promoting unhealthy foods with deals like ‘buy one get one free’. These regulations were introduced by Boris Johnson, but Labour now wants to update – and broaden – what is defined as unhealthy. Up to now, this has been determined by a 2004 nutrient profiling model. The government wants to use a model created in 2018 which, among other things, distinguishes between ‘free’ sugars (those which have been added to a product or released from its structure) and intrinsic ones. This means that many foods which use lots of added sugar, like a yoghurt with honey, will be considered unhealthy and barred from aisle-end promotions or multibuy deals.

Is the Traitors racist?

From our UK edition

When Industry actress Myha’la was kicked off Celebrity Traitors this week, she did not appear to take her exit very graciously. Responding to a comment on her Instagram branding the BBC’s show as ‘racist’ Myha’la said: ‘I sealed my own fate! And that early in the game there is VERY little to grasp on to, and I gave them … a lot.‘I do agree that unconscious racial and cultural bias exists in this game where my authenticity or honesty or the ways in which I choose to express myself look suspicious to people who are unfamiliar with people like me. ‘I had this fear coming into the game, as I am a BIG fan and also clocked right away how prevalent this is in this game.

The irony of Labour’s crackdown on fake gay asylum seekers

From our UK edition

On Tuesday morning, three people were arrested by Home Office immigration enforcement because of their suspected links to a criminal network which is believed to help asylum seekers pretend to be gay, providing fake photographs and letters to Bangladeshi men to convince the courts that they are at risk of persecution back home. This followed an undercover BBC investigation from April which exposed a cottage industry of lawyers and advisers who help migrants fake homosexuality in order to remain in the country, and a Home Office whistleblower telling the Times that ‘hundreds’ of Pakistani asylum seekers have said they were in a gay relationship with the same man, who provided letters in support of their claims.

The flaw in Kemi’s plan to scrap inheritance tax on ‘family homes’

From our UK edition

In her closing speech at the Tory party conference in Birmingham today, Kemi Badenoch said that a Conservative government would abolish inheritance tax (IHT) for family homes and that couples would be able to leave a sum of £1 million to their families tax-free. This came after speculation that she would commit to scrapping inheritance tax entirely. Paul Johnson, formerly of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, has already pointed out that this would incentivise older people to avoid downsizing because they would then be exposing any freed-up capital to inheritance tax. But what exactly is a ‘family home’?

Badenoch’s ‘Britannia shield’ won’t stop Russia

From our UK edition

In March 1983, Ronald Reagan announced on television that the era of mutually assured destruction could come to an end thanks to developments in science which would make nuclear missiles ‘impotent and obsolete’. The US president's aim of developing sophisticated interception systems was quickly nicknamed ‘Star Wars’ and would later become formalised as the ‘Strategic Defence Initiative’ or SDI. For a population which had been terrified to its wits’ end since the Soviet Union first developed nuclear weapons in 1949 the response was broadly positive, but in practical terms the building of a foolproof interception relied on untested technologies like particle beams and space-based lasers which were found to be impractical.

Anthropic has exaggerated another breakthrough

From our UK edition

Another day, another claim by a frontier AI company to have achieved a huge breakthrough in science. Most recently, it’s Anthropic, saying: ‘Claude has discovered a previously unknown enzyme system hidden in the DNA of bacteriophages. Beside the enzyme’s gene sits a long array of repeating DNA – a structure that looks somewhat similar to CRISPR. We don’t yet understand what this system does, but only a handful of known systems share its features, and all of them are able to cut, copy, and paste DNA. Historically, the discovery of such programmable systems has helped revolutionize medicine. CRISPR, for instance, is now the foundation of genetic medicines. But it will take much more work to learn what this system does, and whether it can be put to similar use.

Is Andy Burnham being sucked in by AI marketing?

From our UK edition

Andy Burnham told Donald Trump this week that we need to 'rein in AI’, and given who he is getting advice from it’s no surprise. The Turing Institute, a government research institute which has focused on national security and defence since last year, released a report today on ‘Frontier AI risks’. The report calls for ‘formalised testing and verification regimes’ at an international level to mitigate AI risks.  The report is only 25 pages long and is mostly a prosaic recapitulation of recent developments in AI, with a few promises to ‘collaborate’ with other stakeholder bodies on designing a solution (public sector-ese for meandering talking shop calls which lead nowhere).

The AI apocalypse is just good marketing

From our UK edition

Some whistleblowers from the AI industry claim there is a more than 10% chance that artificial intelligence could wipe out humanity within a few years. A group of mostly Labour MPs has written to Andy Burnham calling for action on existential AI risk, while conceding there is little the British government can do about it alone. Michael Simmons speaks to John Power about the incentives behind the warnings, whether AI can realistically be regulated and why more mundane harms, from AI-written complaints flooding bodies such as IPSO to hackers using chatbots, may deserve more attention. Are the doom-mongers sounding a genuine alarm – or selling the most powerful product ever built?

Why was the BBC so surprised to meet an AI doomer?

From our UK edition

A somewhat bemusing interview took place between Victoria Derbyshire and Geoffrey Hinton last week on Newsnight. Hinton, an eminent computer scientist who has won both a Nobel prize and a Turing award, told Derbyshire that a ten per cent chance of human extinction at the hands of AI by the end of this decade ‘seems not an unreasonable estimate to me’, leaving Derbyshire almost speechless. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IZMjJGi4YhI It is strange that a senior broadcaster could have made it as late as September 2026 without encountering Hinton’s perspective, which is not particularly controversial among either AI researchers or safety advocates. Hinton even quit his position with Google in 2023 so that he could voice his concerns about AI risk publicly.

Spectator Out Loud: Tali Fraser, John Power, Sophia Money-Coutts & Angus Colwell

From our UK edition

29 min listen

On this week’s Spectator Out Loud: Tali Fraser delves into why Labour’s socioeconomic duty is attacking the middle classes; John Power tells us how clipping is changing politics, Sophia Money-Coutts muses over which car would best suit her dog; and Angus Colwell spills the beans on Soho’s newest Turkish restaurant.   Produced and presented by Abigail Brierley.

Tali Fraser, John Power, Sophia Money-Coutts & Angus Colwell

Don’t believe everything that AI companies say

Two big stories are driving interest in artificial intelligence this week. The first is the resignation of Jacob Coxon, a researcher at Anthropic (maker of Claude) who used to work for OpenAI. He said in a statement on X: https://twitter.com/hilbertspaess/status/2097476196791709843?s=20 Coxon went on to say that ‘the people building AI earnestly believe that it could kill us all by the end of the decade’, and that employees at Anthropic are aggressively driving forward because they believe they are in the only company capable of managing the technology safely and ethically. At OpenAI, ‘many have not deeply internalized the civilizational stakes’.  Scary stuff.

Politicians need to learn from Andrew Tate

From our UK edition

When Mel Stride put out a YouTube Short last month, it got zero views. That, surely, is worth repeating: zero views. Stride’s unloved ‘short’ was a poorly cropped clip of a GB News interview, similar to dozens of other clips he had posted on his YouTube channel before being sacked as shadow chancellor. Most of them have fewer than ten views. Stride was born in 1961, so he can perhaps be forgiven for not being au fait with the latest meta on social media. But most of our MPs have similarly amateurish operations, despite recognising the importance of social media in modern communications.

Burnham’s ‘clear diagnosis’ of Britain’s problems doesn’t add up

From our UK edition

Andy Burnham said this week that he has made a ‘clear diagnosis of what has gone wrong’ in Britain since the 1980s, when he returned to Parliament after 10 years in the wilderness. Is his diagnosis correct? Yesterday I looked at Burnham’s claims about political centralisation and the privatisation of economic power, neither of which happened. What other claims did he make? The country deindustrialised – mixed Burnham claimed that Britain deindustrialised in the 1980s. Manufacturing as a share of GDP has indeed declined since 1979, falling from 28.5 per cent in 1979 to around 8.5 per cent today. But this was already the direction of travel: manufacturing output was 32 per cent of GDP in 1973.