Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator and author of Why We Get the Wrong Politicians. She also presents Radio 4’s Week in Westminster.

Seven awkward questions for the Tories

From our UK edition

Tony Blair asked Labour seven awkward questions this week, ranging from issues that everyone's talking about to rather more quirky ones that the former Prime Minister would like everyone to talk about, like using advances in DNA to fight crime. It's the mid-term, when parties start to wonder what they can tell voters they stand for in the next general election, what problems they believe the country is facing, and, more importantly, whether they think they've got a hope of solving them. I've spent most of today talking to Tory MPs about what they think the seven awkward questions for their own party might be, and here they are, in all their awkward and quirky glory: 1. How do the Tories address public concern on immigration while continuing to be a globalised economy?

Snooper’s charter faces rocky road

From our UK edition

We're only a few weeks away from the Queen's Speech, yet there's one significant piece of legislation from this session which has yet to be resolved. It has already caused one big row, and will certainly cause another one when it is published. The Snooper's Charter, better known to the ministers as the Communications Data Bill, was supposed to be published before this session ended, but it's looking like the government is going to have to re-announce it in the Queen's Speech instead.

Tory local election broadcast focuses on cost of living

From our UK edition

The Tories have released a local election broadcast, to be shown on the TV tonight. Unlike previous ones, it doesn't have any awkward confusion between debt and deficit, preferring instead to focus on people looking a bit confused as they try to remember what the government has or hasn't done on council tax, income tax and the cost of living, accompanied by some cheesy guitar music. It's actually quite a snappy piece of work as it sells the party's key achievements at a national level to voters in a rather understated way, partly by admitting that not all of them have noticed what's going on, then driving home the key messages in capital letters across the screen. It also features David Cameron at the start and finish, underlining how important he is to the Tory brand.

Cameron confident of common ground with Merkel

From our UK edition

David Cameron is setting off with his children to visit Angela Merkel on Friday. It's part of his EU reform mission that started and was thrown off course on Monday following the death of Margaret Thatcher. As I blogged back then, the circumstances aren't perfect, and one of the reasons for that is that France and Germany recently snubbed an invitation to be involved in the UK's 'balance of competences' review. But today Cameron tried to play down the significance of this. He told Adam Boulton: 'Our review of competences was always and will be a British exercise. We didn't particularly, that story was… anyone's free to feed into our review, but that piece of work is a British piece of work. For years people said you'll never have the European budget cut, I've got it cut.

Blair’s warning to Miliband about the policy abattoir

From our UK edition

Nothing like a former PM poking their nose into your business, eh? John Major experienced what Daniel Finkelstein this week delicately described as 'sub-optimal' behaviour from Margaret Thatcher when he was in office, and today Ed Miliband has his own helpful little missive from his own former leader, telling him that if only he were just like Tony Blair, then everything would be OK. Blair's piece in the New Statesman isn't surprising in many ways as it articulates the former Prime Minister's firm belief that his party must engage with the centre of politics as it is at the moment, rather than trying to move that centre in the direction it would prefer.

‘If only people could see the real Margaret Thatcher’: Lords pay tribute

From our UK edition

Today's debates in Parliament about Baroness Thatcher were supposed to be a tribute to the first female Prime Minister. If you were looking for the most faithful rendition of this, you should have been sitting in the House of Lords, not the Commons this afternoon. In the Other Place, the debate is always rather more civilised and measured, though it has grown rather rowdier in recent years. But today the speeches painted a fascinating picture of Margaret Thatcher, not least because many of them came from those who worked with or in opposition to her when she was in power. Some were notable by their silence: Lord Howe arrived with notes, but left without speaking. Lord Heseltine was nowhere to be seen.

Cutting and running from Afghanistan

From our UK edition

MPs on the Defence Select Committee made a similar warning this morning about the UK's withdrawal from Afghanistan as Con Coughlin made in The Spectator last month. He wrote that Britain's 'attempt to undertake a dignified retreat from Kabul has all the makings of yet another Afghan disaster'. You can read the full piece here, but here are the main points that it makes, followed by the main warnings from the select committee's report: 1. Is the ANSF ready to take over? Because of a failure to defeat or reach a political settlement with the Taleban, the withdrawal plan depends on trusting Afghan troops 'who have already shown a worrying ability to switch sides'. Coughlin outlined a trend of 'green on blue' killings in recent months.

MPs line up to pay respects to – and criticise – Margaret Thatcher

From our UK edition

This afternoon's tribute debate in the House of Commons will continue until 10pm, with many MPs wanting to pay their respects to Margaret Thatcher. There will be many speeches about how the former Prime Minister inspired and shaped the politics of those speaking. But there will also inevitably be those who want to talk about the negative aspects of her legacy. Ed Miliband, who gave a measured tribute on Monday, faces the challenge of giving a speech that isn't insincere but that remains respectful too. Some of his MPs, such as John Healey, who has written a forceful piece for PoliticsHome, are boycotting the event. Others, such as David Winnick, say they will attend and criticise Thatcher.

Sir James Crosby gives up knighthood and vindicates the Banking Commission

From our UK edition

Well, that was inevitable. Sir James Crosby's announcement that he wants to give his knighthood back and forego a slice of his pension is surprising only in that it came a little sooner after the Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards' report than everyone expected. He could have waited for a real public outcry to build, as it did with Fred Goodwin, but instead he's managed to walk off with a pension that's still £406,000 and perhaps a little dignity. Fraser argued last week that politicians are the ones who should be squirming over the banking crisis, but what Crosby's decision today shows is that the Banking Commission is wielding an impressive amount of power as it rumbles through its inquiries and reports.

‘No such thing as society’: what it means for today’s welfare debate

From our UK edition

Any Tories who might be asking 'What Would Thatcher Do?' about some of the political rows bubbling away today would surely wonder what her response to the current benefits debate might be. She kept well away from welfare reform, but she did have strong views on the role of government in helping people get on. Her notorious Woman's Own interview provided us with the greatest insight, and in much greater detail than the 'there's no such thing as society' line that everyone can quote. Here's a longer extract from the transcript (which you can read in full on the Margaret Thatcher Foundation website): 'I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand “I have a problem, it is the Government's job to cope with it!

Conviction politics: ‘What Would Thatcher Do?’ grips the Tory party

From our UK edition

Conor Burns, a close friend of Margaret Thatcher, gave a fascinating interview with Radio 4's The World at One today about his memories of the Iron Lady. Like so many accounts, it focused on Thatcher's disregard for opinion polls and focus groups. Burns said: 'I think it’s a failure of politics that looks too much at focus groups and too much at public opinion polls. Again, I remember last November showing her a poll in one of the Sunday papers and it showed that we were nine points behind, and she asked when the next election was, and I said it wasn’t for another two and a half years and she said: ‘that’s not far enough behind at this stage.

Tory Thatcher tributes will mark the next stage in battle for party’s soul

From our UK edition

MPs will pay tribute to Margaret Thatcher in the Commons tomorrow. One set of speeches worth listening to with some care will be those from the 2010 intake of Conservative MPs, raised during the Thatcher years, and often considered the group most enthusiastic about keeping her flame alive in the party. It is also likely that from this group will emerge the next Conservative leader. They are a confident bunch, bursting with ideas, books and essays about how to reinvigorate Conservatism. Paying tribute to the former Prime Minister will also be an opportunity for some of them to pay tribute to her policies, and perhaps her conviction in driving through policies that she knew were right, even when colleagues protested vehemently.

Margaret Thatcher: How the Left responded to her death

From our UK edition

In 1983, a Spectator piece argued that 'the most faithful followers of the Thatcher cult are to be found within the Labour Party'. Baroness Thatcher's passing was always going to be as much of a test for the Left as it would be a sad day for the Right. The Labour leadership knew this, and took care to craft statements and tweets which, while acknowledging the glaringly obvious political differences, praised Thatcher the woman. The party has suspended its political campaigning ahead of the local elections as a mark of respect. Ed Miliband's tribute in particular made clear that he had no sympathy with those in his party tempted to celebrate the death of the Iron Lady.

David Cameron makes the case for reform in Europe

From our UK edition

Germany has elections on the way, Spain is just about holding a lid on its economic crisis while keeping a wary eye on the uphill struggle that its neighbour Portugal faces to avoid a second bailout, and François Hollande has his own political crisis to deal with (and is apparently also mourning the death of a camel). So is now really the best time for David Cameron to pitch up in Madrid, Paris and Berlin to argue for reform of the European Union? The PM visits the first two cities today, with a meeting with Angela Merkel planned for later this week on the same topic.

Tories go on tax offensive

From our UK edition

It's 45p day in Westminster, and Ed Balls is trying to make the most of the end of a 50p rate his own party only imposed for a month or so before it left government. The story hasn't made it to the front pages, aside from the Mirror getting cross about Nick Clegg going on holiday with millionaires in a ski resort, and the Tories are also out on the attack over other changes which affect many more taxpayers than that totemic top tax rate. They've produced this series of posters reminding voters of the good tax bits of the Budget. This is important: one of the biggest gripes of even loyal Tory backbenchers and ministers is that the government is achieving radical reforms, but isn't all that good at selling them.

Over 100 Tory MPs demand EU referendum bill: exclusive details

From our UK edition

Tory backbenchers have written again to the Prime Minister demanding legislation guaranteeing a referendum in the next Parliament. Conservative MP John Baron delivered the letter, which bears more than 100 backbench signatures, to Downing Street this morning. While its existence was reported in the Sunday papers, Baron has now spoken exclusively to Coffee House about the letter's contents. I understand that though Baron and his colleagues working on the plan approached only backbenchers (and those include former ministers who left the government in September's reshuffle), a number of ministers and PPSs have also approached them to express sympathy with the idea, and there are several individual letters from PPSs going to David Cameron as well.

Momentum grows for EU referendum bill

From our UK edition

One other area besides immigration where Tory MPs want their leader to go further than he feels he can is, unsurprisingly, Europe. There is growing pressure within the party for the Prime Minister to get legislation on the floor of the House of Commons which would guarantee a referendum in the next Parliament. This is what Bernard Jenkin, who favours a referendum sooner than 2015, has to say: 'The Prime Minister's veto in 2011 gave his poll ratings a great fillip, but that veto was just ignored. They just decided to go ahead with the Fiscal Union Treaty anyway but without the UK. And the UK did not achieve any safeguards to protect UK banking and financial services which the PM was then demanding.

What Tory backbenchers want on immigration, and what the PM can give them

From our UK edition

David Cameron knows that immigration is an issue that bothers voters, and that the mainstream parties have snubbed it in recent years to their detriment. So his speech today is partly an attempt to regain ground from UKIP, which fought a campaign in Eastleigh that was all about immigration, bringing every gripe back to that. He also knows, as I explained on Friday, that Tory MPs are preparing for the first dedicated Commons debate on Bulgarian and Romanian migrants, and he wants to take some of the steam out of that by announcing clear measures to reduce the 'pull factor'. Those measures, which the Prime Minister will detail in a speech in Ipswich, include: Cutting access to benefits for non-UK nationals after 6 months.

Eddie Mair to Boris Johnson: “You’re a nasty piece of work aren’t you?”

From our UK edition

Boris Johnson makes a tricky interviewee. He's charming, vague, witty and able to turn the conversation to his advantage with his ornate language and humour. If all else fails, he does something with his hair. But today the Mayor of London met his match with the equally charming and witty Eddie Mair on the Marr Show. Mair confronted him not just with persistent questions about his ambitions, but also clips from this week's documentary on Johnson which appeared to show him discussing whether to hand over the details of a journalist to his friend Darius Guppy so Guppy could have him "physically assaulted." Mair then moved in for the kill.. "And you, having heard that, tell your friend that that you will supply the address. What does that say about you, Boris Johnson? Making up quotes.

Migrants debate looms as PM prepares immigration speech

From our UK edition

It's not just Nick Clegg who is having a good long think about immigration at the moment: David Cameron is as well. He's got a big immigration speech on Monday, which shows how spooked the parties are by UKIP that they feel they need to at least address the topic, even if they insist that they're not adopting Nigel Farage's terms of debate. As he writes his speech, Cameron will probably have in mind the looming problem of how many Romanian and Bulgarian migrants are coming to this country when transitional controls lift at the end of 2013. If he doesn't, he should, because that backbench debate from Mark Pritchard on this issue now has a date: 22 April.