Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator and author of Why We Get the Wrong Politicians. She also presents Radio 4’s Week in Westminster.

Andrew Mitchell: A strange apology

From our UK edition

Over the past thirteen months since the 'plebgate' row broke over Andrew Mitchell and subsequently broke the then chief whip's career, a number of pieces entitled or themed 'Andrew Mitchell: An apology' have appeared here and there as more has come to light about the allegations levelled at Mitchell. In most cases the writers accept that an initial op-ed or blog that they penned about his alleged behaviour wasn't, with the benefit of hindsight and more information, correct. None have been quite so striking as the statement released this afternoon by the three Police Federation officers who met Mitchell after the allegations surfaced.

Lib Dem free school confusion undermines Clegg’s ‘sausage machine’ model

From our UK edition

What does everyone think about free schools? That's the question that is being asked of every Liberal Democrat who has the misfortune to pop up in broadcast interviews today, because it seems that you can now take any position you want on the subject, so long as you're wearing a certain hat or you've got your fingers crossed behind your back. Ed Davey this morning tried to explain the difference between what David Laws said last week at the despatch box in defence of free schools and what David Laws apparently thinks when he's not at the despatch box. Davey told the Today programme: 'He is defending the Government's position as a Coalition government as he should do, and I understand that.

Justin Welby and the Downing Street grid

From our UK edition

One man who isn't on message at the start of the government's economy week is Justin Welby, who has been warning against excessive jubilation at the end of this week when the next tranche of GDP figures are released. He told the Telegraph: 'A flourishing economy is necessary but not sufficient. A healthy society flourishes and distributes economic resources effectively, but also has a deep spiritual base which gives it its virtue.' This sounds a little bit like pre-2010 David Cameron, but it doesn't quite chime with the political offensive that the Tories want to go on this week, accusing Labour of making consistently bad predictions about the economy.

Hinkley nuclear deal: what it means for the global race and the big freeze

From our UK edition

Today is, as we all know, the start of economy week in Westminster, with politicians striving to show that all that jubilant talk about dawns breaking over the hill this summer wasn't misplaced. The Hinkley Point deal, the first new nuclear plant in a generation, is supposed to show that Britain is open for business, is building, and is providing jobs and training for a new generation of workers in a new generation of nuclear plants. On the Today programme this morning Energy Secretary Ed Davey tried to outline some of the value that this deal with EDF and Beijing-controlled energy companies China National Nuclear Corporation and China General Nuclear Power Group would have for this country.

Nick Clegg isn’t the only senior Lib Dem who could damage free schools

From our UK edition

After Nick Clegg decided to have a grump about free schools in a paper whose own polling suggests they are popular with the public (more on this from Fraser), the Education department has hit back, reminding those who are frightened of that over-used word 'ideology' just what the big idea behind free schools really is: 'Free schools are raising standards and giving parents more choice. They are run by teachers – not local bureaucrats or Westminster politicians – and are free to set their own curriculum, decide how they spend their money and employ who they think are the best people for the job. This Government is not going to take these freedoms away.' You can read the rest of the statement, along with a translation, in Fraser's blog here.

Why politicians shouldn’t say ‘should’

From our UK edition

David Cameron is currently trying to work out what his position on jumpers is after Number 10 was forced to issue an amazing clarification this afternoon. A spokesman said: 'To be clear, it is entirely false to suggest the PM would advise people they should wear jumpers to stay warm. Any suggestion to the contrary is mischief-making. The Prime Minister would point people to a range of things being done to help people with their fuel bills, such as legislating to put everyone on the best tariff for them. He believes Labour's "price freeze" policy is a con - and certainly would not advise people on what they should wear.

Was Jeremy Browne shut out of the tight Home Office ship?

From our UK edition

There's a lot of interest in Jeremy Browne's revelation in the Times this morning that senior Tories have already been trying to persuade the sacked Lib Dem Home Office minister to defect. Browne bats this away by showing that he really is a true Lib Dem with the only evidence that his fellow yellows will accept. 'Not many people have delivered more leaflets than me,' he protests. It's also worth asking why Lib Dems are quite so obsessed with shopping trolleys: Browne uses the same image that Clegg used to criticise Theresa May this spring. But what's just as interesting is what Browne has to say about his struggles in the Home Office. On those controversial 'go home' vans, he says: 'I wasn't told about the vans. I wasn't copied into the paper that was circulated in the Home Office.

Food bank use is up again: how can ministers respond?

From our UK edition

Today's figures from the Trussell Trust on food bank use were good fodder for Labour at PMQs. But the message from the charity, which I profiled for the Spectator a few months ago, is that there needs to be a proper parliamentary inquiry into food poverty, which sounds eminently more sensible than people shouting at each other about complacency. Chief executive Chris Mould said this morning: 'We said in April that the increasing numbers of people turning to foodbanks should be a wake-up call to the nation, but there has been no policy response and the situation is getting worse. The level of food poverty in the UK is not acceptable. It’s scandalous and it is causing deep distress to thousands of people.

The energy price freeze is becoming the new 50p tax

From our UK edition

David Cameron clearly didn't think he'd had a good PMQs by the time he'd finished with Ed Miliband. There was something irritable and tired about the Prime Minister as he took questions from backbenchers, and that weariness was compounded by the sight of Dennis Skinner limbering to his feet to deliver a long, angry and moving question about the work capability assessment. Dennis Skinner is the last thing you want floating to the top when your PMQs performance has been below par. And it was below par. I understand that Cameron was given a very detailed briefing indeed today on energy prices because it was highly likely that Ed Miliband was going to come back for round two. As James says, the session is settling into a pattern.

A plot to harm ministers has harmed the plotters more

From our UK edition

Presumably one of the motivations behind the decision of Police Federation members to try to discredit Andrew Mitchell was an attempt to discredit the government's wider reforms of and cuts to the police service, which the union representing the force was at the time engaged in a bitter battle with ministers over. But oddly enough, the plotters' misdemeanours appear to have found them out, with calls now for reform of police disciplinary procedures. On Today, former Home Secretary Jack Straw said the Federation had shown a 'poverty of leadership': '[They] had the idea that if they embroidered the truth - and I put that mildly - then they could get the scalp of a Conservative Cabinet minister of an administration with whom they were in conflict at the time.

New Number 10 policy board announced

From our UK edition

After last week's reshuffle and the gap left by Jesse Norman's departure from the policy board, Number 10 has announced a number of promotions which increase the board's size -  and its brainpower. Alun Cairns, Andrea Leadsom, Priti Patel, Chris Skidmore and Nadhim Zahawi have all been promoted, which is interesting as all of them bar Skidmore are rebels to a greater or lesser extent. So it's a sign that the Tory leadership wants to forget past troubles and use all the best brains to forge 2015 policy. But it's also useful to have independently-minded MPs joining the group anyway, as the last thing the board tasked with developing flagship policies needs is a group of obedient MPs without any ability to think freely.

Theresa May’s apology to Andrew Mitchell

From our UK edition

Giving evidence to the Home Affairs Select Committee this afternoon, Theresa May said it would be 'appropriate' for the West Mercia chief constable to apologise to Andrew Mitchell over the way the 'Plebgate' allegations were handled. She was being questioned on the Independent Police Complaints Commission's report, published this morning, which found that there was an 'issue of honesty and integrity' which went above 'merely naive or poor professional judgment' on the part of three Police Federation officers who gave an account of a meeting with Mitchell following the 'plebgate' allegations that contradicted the claims of the former chief whip.

Afriyie amendments continue to wait hopefully for supporters

From our UK edition

Oh dear. Poor old Adam Afriyie. Just over a week ago he was boasting of a 'cross party' campaign behind his amendment to James Wharton's EU referendum bill. Now the updated list of signatures has been supported, and there hasn't exactly been a stampede of support. Last week, the amendments said this: Adam Afryie Keith Vaz Clause 1, page 1, line 4, leave out ‘before 31 December 2017’ and insert ‘on 23 October 2014’. Adam Afryie Keith Vaz Clause 1, page 1, line 5, leave out subsection (3). And this week, the updated amendments look like this: Adam Afryie Clause 1, page 1, line 4, leave out ‘before 31 December 2017’ and insert ‘on 23 October 2014’. Adam Afryie Clause 1, page 1, line 5, leave out subsection (3).

EU red tape push will give Cameron cover for renegotiation

From our UK edition

The government's business taskforce will give a presentation today to Cabinet on its report on slashing EU regulation. David Cameron has already indicated that he will support the 30 recommendations in the report, compiled by M&S chief executive Marc Bolland, Kingfisher chief executive Ian Cheshire, ATG Access managing director Glenn Cooper, BTG chief executive Louise Makin, entrepreneur Dale Murray and Diageo boss Paul Walsh. European Commission president Jose Manuel Barroso has said that he will look to resolve complaints about legislation burdening companies, and Cameron sees this as an important way of showing that Britain can lead on making the case for reform in the European Union as a whole.

Same old ding-dong as Reeves and IDS face off for first time

From our UK edition

After insisting that her appointment in no way represented a 'lurch to the left' at the weekend by repeating the policy pronouncements that her predecessor was allowed to come out with, Rachel Reeves pitched up at DWP questions today with the same strategy that Liam Byrne had employed when taking on the Tories on welfare. The new shadow Work and Pensions secretary decided to focus not on who was the toughest on welfare, but on the delivery questions that had occupied Byrne towards the end of his tenure. When it came to her turn at topical questions, she rose and said: 'We on this side of the House support the principle of universal credit but we've repeatedly raised questions about the Secretary of State's ability to deliver.

Boris Johnson: Visa plan is unclear

From our UK edition

It is just two weeks since Boris Johnson came over all loyal at the Conservative party conference. The Mayor, it was reported, was putting his weight behind David Cameron because of the presence of Lynton Crosby and the apparent private offer of a safe seat. But it looks like he's back to being troublesome by immediately questioning the government's announcement that it will be relaxing visa rules for Chinese tourists. He told the World at One: 'Well, we'll have to see how this scheme actually works because the detail is a little bit unclear to us at the moment and I'm initially very, obviously very supportive and would hope that it will make sure that we are able to get large numbers of Chinese students, of tourists, people who are going to bring income to our city.

No 10: PM has ‘sympathy’ with calls for partial lift of hunting ban

From our UK edition

Number 10 didn't make any effort to shoot the fox hunting story that's doing the rounds at today's lobby briefing. Responding to calls from a cross-party group of MPs for a partial lifting of the hunting ban to allow farmers to use a full pack of dogs to flush out foxes, the Prime Minister's official spokesman said this morning that 'the Prime Minister has some sympathy with these concerns' around 'the impact is has on particular farming communities such as hill farmers'. He added that it was significant that these questions had been raised 'by MPs from across the house', saying: 'Given the cross party nature of concerns that have been raised in this area, I think this is something which the House may wish to address.

The global race means swallowing pride every so often

From our UK edition

George Osborne is in Beijing at the moment, drumming up support for Britain in the global race. Although that doesn't quite work because Britain is obviously racing China in this global race, but all the same, he wants China to run alongside Britain cheering it, rather than sledging as it steams ahead. And to be able to do that, this country apparently needs to swallow some of its pride about the sort of country that China is.

The truth about Tristram Hunt’s ‘conversion’ on free schools

From our UK edition

Much rejoicing in the ranks of education reformers today as just one sinner repents. Tristram Hunt has toldthe Mail On Sunday that Labour doesn't think free schools are just for 'yummy mummies' and that now his party does support free schools, but under the 'parent-led academies' banner. This is supposed to be a Damascene moment for Hunt, but really he's just explaining with greater clarity the stance his predecessor Stephen Twigg took in June. Here is the key line from the MoS: Will PLAs offer everything free schools have got? ‘Yes, but in an area of need, absolutely,’ Hunt enthuses. ‘The innovation, creativity, community engagement you see in the best free schools – great, let’s have more.

Gove sets early policy test for Tristram Hunt

From our UK edition

The congratulations have been flowing in from across the Labour party for Tristram Hunt as the new Shadow Education Secretary. But there is no praise higher for the newly promoted MP than to get a detailed letter from Michael Gove testing his mettle just a few days into the job. Gove saw Stephen Twigg as someone he didn't need to worry about a great deal, more of a distraction from his daily hobby of provoking the teaching unions than a mighty threat. But Hunt, while still possibly in danger of proving too Blairite for his party's tastes, appears a mightier candidate. Education Questions in the Commons will certainly be an entertaining festival of rhetoric from now on. The letter, which you can read in full here, says: 'Congratulations on your promotion to the Shadow Cabinet.