Alexander Larman

Does Thomas Markle deserve the death penalty?

Thomas Markle
Thomas Markle Sr, father of Meghan Markle, Duchess of Sussex (MEGA/GC Images)

There are many crimes that Thomas Markle may or may not be guilty of, specifically involving the possession of child abuse material, but not everyone would go quite as far as the Florida congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna. She posted on X that “I am calling for Thomas Markle to receive [sic] the Death Penalty. Agents seized items from his LA storage units including film negatives showing him (ID’d by a longtime witness) with a nude prepubescent girl, one involving apparent genital contact, plus other images of him with children in various stages of undress.” She concluded, at the end of her bloodthirsty tweet, “He is a sick human.” 

Luna, admittedly, has form in such eye-catching (and frankly preposterous) statements. The 37-year-old Republican has been heavily involved in such campaigns as releasing the Epstein files and declassifying the information available about the assassinations of both RFK and JFK, as well as writing a children’s book, The Legend of Naranja, that declares that Biden stole the 2020 election from Trump. It may well be that Luna, an ardent anti-abortionist who also claims that she has heard congressional tendency of the existence of aliens, is an extreme figure whose remarks can be safely said to lie at the more pointed end of popular feeling towards Markle – who, we should remember, has yet to be convicted of any crime. 

This unedifying saga shows no signs of coming to an end

Yet the fact that she has even made such a statement suggests that there is a growing sense that a man who was once commonly regarded only as an opportunistic narcissist is actually an abuser and will be convicted as such. Markle has not helped his own case by cutting off the electronic tag that was placed on his ankle, which led to his arrest. While most may have thought that an 81-year-old man in poor health who has had to have a leg amputated below the knee because of complications from a blood clot would hardly pose any kind of flight risk, Markle Sr’s rash actions have meant that he is now locked up in Tampa, Florida, prior to awaiting a hearing on charges of possession of child pornography. 

It may yet be that Markle avoids further incarceration or a trial. Judge Lindsay Griffin has speculated that his mental health, which includes a “lack of recall,” means that he needs to take a mental competence exam by 20 November, on the grounds that  his health is “rendering him mentally incompetent to the extent that he is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proceedings against him or to assist properly in his defense.” No doubt any suggestion that Markle is not fit to stand trial will be seized upon by his defense attorney and Meghan’s father – for, after all, that is what he has been best known for being, rather than a Daytime Emmy winner for his role in lighting General Hospital – could well find that, rather than being executed, he never serves any jail time at all, although it is likely that most will believe his guilt unless he is publicly exonerated. 

His daughter clearly believes that her father is guilty and has done so for several years, cutting off all contact with him for good in December 2025. And while his other daughter Samantha has protested his innocence, suggesting that Thomas has been set up in some way, it seems unlikely that the sheer quantity of child abuse material that has been found in a series of storage units that he has rented has ended up there by accident or through poor management. While Congresswoman Luna’s wish that Markle meet his end through legal means is unlikely to be granted, this unedifying saga shows no signs of coming to an end.

Comments