In schools across America, libraries – once the heart of our educational institutions and protected home of deep, prolonged contemplation – have been rebranded as “learning commons.” The change is not only one of name: learning commons differ in kind from the libraries they replaced.
Where libraries were quiet, almost sacred spaces, learning commons are loud, collaborative, screen-rich rooms designed for everything, which is to say, for nothing in particular. One boarding school in Massachusetts infamously rid its library of all physical books in 2009, believing that the future was digital; it has since come to its senses and reversed course.
But even in learning commons that still have books on their shelves, the books gather dust, little more than decorative reflections of a bygone era. The one space that was designed for calm, sustained, individual encounters with ideas has been remade in the image of the very technology that makes it harder to engage students with those ideas.
Faced with emptier rooms and thinner budgets, many libraries have become something else entirely
The generation first victimized by these changes has now arrived at university. Professors from state colleges to the Ivy League report that their students struggle to complete readings that have already been shortened for them. That may be because students are assigned far fewer books in high school English than in decades past. And even when a whole book is assigned, audiobooks and detailed chapter summaries are often supplied to ease what some teachers presume will be an arduous, unpleasant experience for their charges.
What professors describe are students who have not only lost their skill for reading, but lost their appetite for it. They feel ill-equipped to grapple with difficult texts, and uninterested in trying, because the conditions that would have cultivated that capacity – ambition and joy – were never provided earlier in their education. My colleague recently sent me a photo of a hollowed-out novel. She begins each of her English classes with ten minutes of silent, individual reading. On this particular day, she glanced up from marking papers to see a mischievous grin on the face of one of her students. On investigation, she discovered that he had cut an inch-deep hole into the pages of a borrowed book like a convict hiding a file in a cake. What contraband did he intend to smuggle in? His phone, of course. Ten minutes of scrolling in place of ten minutes of reading was worth the hour it took him to vandalize the school’s property the night before.
His was an elaborate solution to a problem most of his generation solves far more simply: by never opening a book at all. Reading is in steep decline. On buses, on park benches and in airport terminals – the traditional territories of the casual reader – seeing someone reading a paperback is like encountering a bird of paradise in the wilds of Papua New Guinea.
Nor is the paperback faring much better in the only public spaces built to house it. A recent report by PEN America warns that the nation’s public libraries are nearing “a breaking point.” While the report emphasizes the government’s reckless and increasingly imperious penchant for censorship, the subtler story is about money.
Last year, Donald Trump signed an executive order that failed to abolish the Institute of Museum and Library Services, which issues grants to local libraries across the country, but succeeded in freezing its funding. Though the money was eventually restored, the administration’s 2027 budget asks for just $6 million “for necessary expenses to carry out [its] closure.”
Meanwhile, 93 percent of Americans tell pollsters that funding cuts to local libraries would hurt their community. And yet, for years, fewer of them have been walking through the door. Between 2008 and 2017, library visits declined by more than 17 percent per person.
Faced with emptier rooms and thinner budgets, many libraries have become something else entirely. Nearly half now offer internet hotspots for checkout. BiblioTech, billed as the nation’s first bookless library, opened in San Antonio in 2013. The county judge who dreamed up the idea was inspired by a biography about Steve Jobs; to those wondering what the place would look like, he suggested, “go into an Apple store.”
Nearly three centuries earlier, in 1731, Benjamin Franklin founded the Library Company of Philadelphia, boasting that libraries “made the common tradesmen and farmers as intelligent as most gentlemen from other countries.” Odd that he never mentioned iPads.
The logic of the learning commons proliferates through libraries of all kinds now, and our schools got there first. Between 2009 and 2023, America’s public schools shed a quarter of their librarians; by the end of that period, more than a third of districts had none at all. In some places, the position survived, but only under new names with lumbering titles like “Library Interventionist” or “Library Information Technology Teacher.” It’s as though the word librarian has been forced into retirement, relegated to a dusty shelf of its own. And the norms of the library went the way of the librarian too, banished in favor of screens and sociability. A child raised in that kind of school, who has only ever encountered that kind of a public library, may reach university without ever setting foot in a room whose sole purpose is reading.
Today’s undergraduates don’t reminisce about their first enchanting foray into Narnia, back when they read The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe in the fifth grade. Instead, they recall their favorite IXL “quest.” You know the one: you collect coins while steering your avatar through a Game Boy-style animation of ancient Egypt, the perfect setting to learn about adjectives. Perhaps that explains why my colleague’s student didn’t hesitate to take a blade to a novel. To a teenager raised on coin-collecting quests, a book isn’t a wardrobe that opens onto another world; it’s an obstacle standing between him and his screen. To him, the book was hollow long before he cut into it.
We can put physical books back into the hands of our pupils, we can restore the library as a place of quiet
It would be easy to dismiss him as a delinquent, but a part of me suspects he sees his school more clearly than its administrators do. He carved out the contents of a book, leaving its spine and its cover intact, to make room for a phone. That’s exactly what we have done to reading in our schools. The facade survives: the English class, the shelves in the learning commons, the librarian behind the desk. But the substance has been carved out from behind it, leaving enough space for a device to sit snugly in the hollow. The boy didn’t defy his school’s values; he simply expressed them with an X-Acto knife.
But the same story offers a sliver of hope. The student went to such lengths because, for ten minutes a day, his teacher made his phone unwelcome. Our schools needn’t mirror the culture beyond their walls; they can stand against it. The tide of aliteracy has already swept over the buses, the park benches and the airport terminals, but the classroom is one of the few places left that can act as a bulwark.
We can put physical books back into the hands of our pupils, we can restore the library as a place of quiet rather than a showroom for screens and we can remove the distractions that profiteer on our children’s attention. But most importantly, we can let educators, not software, teach children to read. Most of that is a return to what schools did before someone sold them something shiny and new.
The shell of a reading culture still stands in our schools. It isn’t too late to turn the learning commons into libraries again and put the books back where they belong.
Comments