I spent a recent Tuesday night trying to find a quiz. Specifically, I was hunting down the original “How woke are you?” quiz that Jezebel ran in 2016, which I needed for a footnote. I found the page. The quiz was gone. It had run in an embedded widget from a quiz service (qzzr.com), and that widget no longer loads. All that was left was a blank box where the quiz used to be. Woke 1 was craaaaaaazy, and it was memory-holed in an unmarked grave.
It was about halfway through writing my forthcoming book, The Left Can’t Meme: How Comedy Wins Culture Wars that I realized I was writing a history book. I’m not sure why this wasn’t evident to me when I pitched the book, or until I was about 30,000 words deep. Probably because it’s part memoir and memoir is easy. The research for my own story was reading journals and old Spectator columns and piecing together fragments of the past decade from memory. Writing the story of how the left managed to lose its stranglehold on comedy and culture to a bunch of heroic anonymous shitposters using frog memes was another thing entirely. It took me on an unguided tour through the seedy backwaters of the internet. I started calling these late-night sessions “rabbit-holing.” Dead ends. Broken links. Forgotten lore. Strange realms from an era that feels like it was at least 30 years ago but was barely more than ten. I’d wander around labyrinthine digital ecosystems and pull open a door and go down a hall and lose hours remembering all the things I’d forgotten. Harambe. Pokémon Go to the Polls. Dark Brandon. Opening doors I had walked past a million times and never entered, like Gamergate, and reading the ancient texts. 4chan screengrabs in the Wayback Machine. Internet archived Reddit threads. Long-dead forum arguments between men named things like xXRedPillWarriorXx, conducted like they were drafting the Constitution.
My researcher and I would text each other our finds at 1 a.m. and every so often one of us would write, “We’re in too deep.” Some nights, chasing the origin of a single meme, it felt like a dream within a dream. You’d find the source, and the source would cite a source, and that source would be a broken image link with the alt text “lol.”
I didn’t go to college and writing this book often felt like I was writing a book report or a thesis or whatever it’s called. And now my book has Chicago-style endnotes, which sounds fancy but only makes me want pizza. Not that I did them. My researcher helped (saved) me, and the most I contributed was asking questions like, “Is it ‘author unknown’? Is it ‘Anonymous’? Does the frog get credited? Do we need permission to use him in class?” I’ve learned there is a correct way to cite an anonymous image-board post from 2015. I’ve learned this the way you learn your accountant has done your taxes. And often during the process I wondered why I was the one writing this book. It felt like a man should be doing it. They were there, in their gaming Discord or whatever they’re called, trying not to get booted for calling their buddy a “f*gg*t.” But there is a reason dorks like me end up writing the book. The people who were actually there, posting, weren’t writing it all down for posterity. So the history of the most consequential comedy movement of the past decade falls to a college dropout with a coffee addiction and her far more qualified researcher, footnoting Pepe at midnight. We’re monks in the scriptorium, if one of the monks was a chick and the other one did all the detail-oriented work.
We say “the internet never forgets” but that’s not exactly true. It actually does forget and it’s getting worse. The Internet Archive is fighting to stay afloat. When media companies fold or migrate their sites, entire bodies of work disappear overnight. Meanwhile, AI slop floods everything that’s left, so the past is being deleted at one end and buried under filler at the other. I think we’re living in the meme golden era and don’t know it. Every culture has an art form it doesn’t appreciate until it’s gone. Vaudeville. Penny dreadfuls. Pamphlets nailed to church doors. Ours is the shitpost, a joke made by a stranger in 30 seconds that somehow moves an election, ends a career or names a decade. The primary sources for the defining cultural war of our time are image macros with impact font, and it’s all disappearing in real time.
Someone has to write it down. I just never imagined it would be me, or that it would require so many footnotes, (shout out to my researcher, he’s insane now). History used to be written by the winners. Now it’s written by whoever remembered to take a screenshot. We’ll lose the think pieces, the quizzes, the columns, probably this one. But I’d bet money the frog survives. He always does.
Comments