Joe Bedell-Brill

Joe Bedell-Brill reviews the Sunday politics shows for The Spectator

Jonathan Reynolds shoots down Transport Secretary’s P and O comments

From our UK edition

Jonathan Reynolds: Transport Secretary’s comments on P&O Ferries ‘not the government’s position’ This week, Transport Secretary Louise Haigh described P&O Ferries as a ‘rogue operator’ and encouraged consumers to boycott the company, leading parent company DP World to threaten they would pull out of the government’s investment summit on Monday, and put a reported £1bn worth of investment in the UK on hold. Keir Starmer said that Haigh’s comments were ‘not the view of the government’, despite previous government press releases using the same language, and DP World subsequently reconfirmed their attendance at the summit.

Tzipi Hotovely: Israel will dismantle Iranian threat

From our UK edition

Israel won’t rule out strikes against Iranian nuclear capabilities Iran launched missiles against Israel this week, and the world is waiting anxiously to see how Israel will respond. On the BBC this morning, Laura Kuenssberg asked Israeli Ambassador Tzipi Hotovely if Israel would rule out a strike against Iran’s nuclear capabilities, which President Biden opposes. Hotovely said Israel had no interest in being attacked by Iranian missiles, and they would ‘dismantle the threat’. Hotovely implied that Israel were considering going against the US president’s wishes, telling Kuenssberg that the world needed to prevent ‘this regime of terror’ in Iran from having nuclear abilities. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Kemi Badenoch: ‘Of course not all cultures are equally valid’

From our UK edition

At the Conservative party conference in Birmingham this morning, the Tory leadership candidates set out their stalls. Speaking to Laura Kuenssberg, Badenoch said it was essential that there was a ‘shared culture and a shared identity’ in the UK, and that it was important to choose ‘who comes into the country’. Asked which cultures in particular were less valid, Badenoch said: ‘lots… cultures that believe in child marriage.. or that women don’t have equal rights’. Pressed to be more specific, Badenoch told Kuenssberg: ‘I know what you’re trying to do. You want me to say Muslims. But it isn’t all Muslims.’ Badenoch argued that we need to emphasise ‘the thing that we share… British values'.

Angela Rayner: ‘I don’t believe I broke any rules… in fact I think I was overly transparent’

From our UK edition

Angela Rayner: ‘I don’t believe I broke any rules… in fact I think I was overly transparent’ The Labour conference has got off to an awkward start, as senior figures continue to battle controversy around donations, Starmer’s approval rating plummets, and anger persists over the winter fuel allowance. Speaking to Laura Kuenssberg in Liverpool, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner defended her holiday stay in a New York apartment gifted to her by Lord Alli. Rayner argued that ‘MPs have accepted gifts for years… all MPs do it’, and said that the important point was that the government was being ‘open and transparent’ about it.

David Lammy: Labour ‘won’t be bullied by Putin’s shameless grandstanding’

From our UK edition

This week the prime minister and Foreign Secretary David Lammy flew to the US for discussions involving whether to allow Ukraine to fire long-range missiles into Russian territory. Putin responded by warning he would view that outcome as ‘direct participation’ of Nato in the conflict. Speaking to Trevor Phillips on Sky News, Lammy talked up the West’s increased support for Ukraine, but would not confirm any decision regarding the long-range missiles specifically, saying the UK’s allies were continuing to ‘discuss the detail’. Phillips pointed out that Zelensky keeps reminding the West that delays in support mean more Ukrainian lives are lost. Lammy said the UK has already repeatedly disregarded Putin’s warnings, and will continue to do so. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Keir Starmer: ‘We are going to have to be unpopular’

From our UK edition

In his first major interview in Downing Street, the Prime Minister told Laura Kuenssberg that his government had to do ‘difficult things now’ in order to bring about change. Starmer’s plan to take away winter fuel allowances from most pensioners has drawn criticism, and he faces a potential rebellion in parliament next week over the decision. Starmer claimed the Tories had ‘run away from difficult decisions’, and said he was ‘determined’ to deliver change. The Prime Minister admitted he was ‘worried’ about the rise of the far right, and said ‘delivery in government’ was the only way to tackle the ‘snake oil of the easy answer’. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Sunday shows round-up: Labour accuse Tories of finance ‘cover up’

From our UK edition

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is this week expected to announce a £20 billion black hole in the country’s finances. Many believe Labour are setting the ground for inevitable tax hikes and spending cuts in the autumn, blaming unexpected levels of Tory mismanagement for their decisions. On Sky News this morning, Environment Secretary Steve Reed said Labour would be ‘open and transparent’ about what they’ve learned since coming into government. Trevor Phillips suggested it wasn’t credible that Labour had only just realised the extent of the UK’s economic woes, and showed a statement from Reeves made last month in which she said on the subject: ‘You don’t need to win an election to find that out’.

Labour won’t spend outside fiscal rules, says Reeves

From our UK edition

Chancellor Reeves adamant she will ‘make sure the sums add up’ Rachel Reeves gave an interview with Laura Kuenssberg this morning in which she emphasised the ‘mess’ she says the Conservatives have left behind, and restated that Labour would not spend outside of its fiscal rules. Kuenssberg asked the Chancellor whether she would be prepared to ignore the recommendations of the independent pay review bodies, which have called for a public sector pay rise of 5.5 per cent. Reeves would not confirm the government’s position, but accepted that ‘there is a cost to not settling’ public sector pay disputes, implying she might be open to above-inflation pay increases. What is Labour doing for the poorest in the country?

Sunday shows round-up: politicians condemn Trump shooting

From our UK edition

Today’s British news is dominated by Donald Trump narrowly escaped with his life after an attempted assassination at his rally in Pennsylvania. Images of the aftermath show Trump being escorted away with a bloodied ear, as one spectator was killed and two others are in critical condition. Secret service agents shot and killed the gunman, whom the FBI has identified as 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks. On Sky News this morning, journalist Tom Newton Dunn, who was present at the rally, gave his account to Trevor Phillips. Newton Dunn said that it took a few seconds before the crowd realised they were hearing high velocity rounds, and ‘that’s when the terror struck in’.  He described a lot of anger after the incident, with some men ‘blaming Joe Biden, blaming CNN’.

Sunday shows round-up: the Tory election defeat inquest begins

From our UK edition

Jonathan Reynolds on Reform: ‘Now…they will get the scrutiny they deserve’ On Sky News this morning, Trevor Phillips pointed out that Labour had the smallest vote share of any election-winning party - and asked the business and trade secretary Jonathan Reynolds if it was sustainable that votes for smaller parties like Reform and the Greens did not translate into seats. Reynolds argued that Labour’s successful campaign under this electoral system gave them a legitimate mandate to govern, and claimed that smaller parties were given ‘far less scrutiny’ because they’re not seen as ‘parties of government’. Reynolds also implied that many people who voted for Reform don’t really know their policies. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Sunday shows round-up: Cleverly says cabinet not involved in gambling controversy

From our UK edition

A betting scandal surrounding the election date has led to more controversy for Rishi Sunak this week, with multiple Conservatives being investigated by the Gambling Commission following unusual betting patterns. This morning it is reported that the Tories’ chief data officer, Nick Mason, is part of the inquiry. On Sky News, Trevor Phillips asked Home Secretary James Cleverly if this was an example of his party’s ‘moral decay’. Cleverly said he would ‘not in any way defend people who placed bets on that’, but that he could not discuss details while the investigation was ongoing. He added he ‘had no reason to believe,’ any of his cabinet colleagues were involved. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Sunday shows round-up: Streeting says Tories are ‘arsonists’

From our UK edition

Wes Streeting: ‘Do not give the matches back to the arsonist’ On Sky News this morning, Shadow Health Secretary Wes Streeting suggested there could be greater spending increases than promised in Labour’s manifesto, ‘if the conditions allow’, but said Labour wouldn’t ‘make promises we can’t keep’. Trevor Phillips argued that Labour’s manifesto doesn’t amount to real change, but Streeting accused him of a ‘wall of cynicism’, and called the Conservative manifesto ‘Liz Truss’s mini-budget on steroids’.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KsUMyiS3QWU Mark Harper: ‘We’ve got a strong record’ Laura Kuenssberg asked Transport Secretary Mark Harper why Conservative candidates and their election material are avoiding using official branding.

Sunday shows round-up: Farage doubles down on D-Day attack on PM

From our UK edition

Rishi Sunak has been accused of making a massive error of judgment after he exited the D-Day commemorations early on Thursday, leaving Foreign Secretary David Cameron to deputise for him at the international leaders event. Speaking to Work and Pensions Secretary Mel Stride, Sky News’ Trevor Phillips asked whether the PM understood the weight of the event. Stride said Sunak was deeply patriotic, arguing that his actions as Chancellor during Covid demonstrated how much he cared about the country. Stride said a mistake had been made, and the Prime Minister had ‘unequivocally apologised’.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Sunday shows round-up: Diane Abbott bullied by ‘overgrown schoolboys’

From our UK edition

Questions over whether Diane Abbott had been banned from standing as a Labour candidate were a distraction for Keir Starmer’s campaign this week, eventually ending with Starmer confirming that Abbott was ‘free to go forward’ for Labour. Some in the party are unhappy with Starmer welcoming Tory defectors while suppressing left-wing candidates such as Lloyd Russell-Moyle and Faiza Shaheen, who were both barred from standing for Labour this week. Speaking to Laura Kuenssberg, Baroness Chakrabarti claimed Diane Abbott had been bullied by ‘overgrown schoolboys in suits’ sending anonymous briefings.

Grant Shapps: Infected blood scandal is a ‘shameful failure’

From our UK edition

Grant Shapps ‘angry’ about infected blood scandal The final report on the infected blood scandal will be published on Monday. The scandal is the biggest treatment disaster in NHS history, with more than 30,000 infected with HIV and Hepatitis C between 1970 and 1991. On Sky News, Defence Secretary Grant Shapps agreed with Trevor Phillips that the scandal was ‘one of the most shameful failures of government in our lifetime’. Shapps said he hadn’t seen the report, but was ‘angry’ at the lack of responsibility over a period of decades. He agreed that compensation has taken far too long to arrive, and said the government would make a statement quickly after the report is out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Sunday shows round-up: Labour’s newest MP embroiled in controversy

From our UK edition

Natalie Elphicke’s dramatic defection to Labour had already caused some controversy this week, with many in Labour feeling she should not have been welcome given her history on the right of the Tory party. Now there could be more trouble for Keir Starmer after the Sunday Times reported that Elphicke may have lobbied Justice Secretary Robert Buckland over her husband’s forthcoming trial on sexual assault charges in 2020. Speaking to Labour frontbencher Jonathan Ashworth on the BBC, Laura Kuenssberg asked if Elphicke should be investigated. Ashworth told Kuenssberg he ‘wasn’t there’ at the meeting in 2020, but said that Elphicke insisted the allegations were ‘nonsense’. He also asked why the justice secretary had never mentioned the incident before.

Sunday shows round-up: Sunak refuses to rule out summer election

From our UK edition

The Tories are expected to lose around half their councillors in the upcoming local elections on 4 May. Trevor Phillips interviewed the prime minister on Sky News, asking him whether a general election could take place as early as July. A frustrated and bullish Sunak claimed he did not get distracted by his diminished approval ratings, and repeatedly refused to confirm or deny the possibility of a July general election, telling Phillips: ‘you’re going to try and draw whatever conclusion you want from what I say’.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FwdJTVZumvM Conservative defector Dan Poulter: Tories now resemble a ‘nationalist party’ The Conservatives suffered another humiliation this week after MP Dr Dan Poulter quit his party to join Labour.

Atkins: British planes operating in region at time of Iran attack

From our UK edition

Conflict in the Middle East entered a new dangerous phase on Saturday night, as Iran launched over 300 drones and missiles against Israel, its first direct military attack against the country after years of shadow warfare. On the BBC this morning, Health Secretary Victoria Atkins told Laura Kuenssberg this was an ‘incredibly significant attack’. She confirmed that British military planes were operating in the region as part of pre-existing missions, although could not clarify whether British planes had taken part in shooting down missiles and drones. https://www.youtube.com/watch?

Dowden: UK position on arms sales to Israel ‘has not changed’

From our UK edition

Dowden: UK position on arms sales to Israel ‘has not changed’ Israel and Hamas are expected to hold a new round of ceasefire negotiations in Cairo today, at a time when Israel is under more pressure than ever before to pause the conflict. An IDF strike on an aid convoy which killed seven aid workers, including three Britons, led to Foreign Secretary David Cameron telling Israel that British support was ‘not unconditional’. This week there have been calls for the UK to suspend arms exports to Israel. Deputy Prime Minister Oliver Dowden said this morning on Sky News that the UK has ‘one of the toughest arms export systems’, based on legal advice.

Hunt: Tories will keep the triple lock on pensions

From our UK edition

Jeremy Hunt: Russian government creating a ‘smokescreen of propaganda’ On Friday night, a terrorist attack at a large concert in Moscow led to at least 133 deaths. Russian officials vowed revenge and suggested Ukrainian involvement, despite Islamic State claiming responsibility. On Sky News this morning, Trevor Phillips asked Jeremy Hunt how much Russia’s version of events could be believed. The Chancellor said it was always a tragedy when innocent people lost their lives, but that the UK had ‘very little confidence in anything the Russian government says’. He suggested they were creating a ‘smokescreen of propaganda’ to justify their invasion of Ukraine.