James Heale

James Heale

James Heale is The Spectator’s deputy political editor.

Burnham’s LBC interview told us nothing new

With less than three weeks to go until he enters No. 10, Andy Burnham has adopted a ‘Ming vase’ approach to public appearances. With victory inevitable, why expose himself to media scrutiny at the risk of binding his hands on taking up office? Since his devolution speech on Monday, the new Makerfield MP has kept his interventions to a minimum, with a planned appearance at the New Economics Foundation cancelled last night. But having declined to take journalists’ questions on Monday, Burnham did decide to submit to a radio interview with Andrew Marr on LBC tonight. The party is split on whether its current malaise is ‘comms or policy’.

Reform are right to fear a Boris return

Reform is right to fear the return of Boris

18 min listen

Boris is (sort of) on manoeuvres, as Tim Shipman reports in this week’s magazine. There are signs that the former Conservative prime minister and one-time editor of this magazine could emerge from his frontline political hiatus to throw his weight behind the Tory cause. He has already been advising Kemi Badenoch and is said to be driven, in part, by a ‘hatred’ of Nigel Farage. Should Reform fear the return of Boris? It has been a damaging month for Reform, following the Makerfield by-election, a plateau in the polls, rumbling questions about Farage’s £5 million gift and now suggestions that he did not declare his full property portfolio to parliament. Has Reform peaked? Oscar Edmondson speaks to Tim Shipman and James Heale. Produced by Oscar Edmondson.

Burnham’s chancellor could decide his fate

War! What is it good for? A ding-dong political row. The Defence Investment Plan (DIP) continues to dominate Westminster, following its unveiling by Keir Starmer yesterday. An extra £15 billion will now be spent on military budgets – a figure far short of the £28bn that John Healey was demanding prior to his resignation as defence secretary. That shortfall has been roundly condemned as insufficient by both opposition parties and much of the military establishment. If the chiefs do not think it is enough, the argument goes, then why should the British public? Starmer was not unreasonable on the subject at Prime Minister’s Questions.

The secrets of the Spectator summer party

The secrets of the Spectator summer party

17 min listen

As the nation holds its breath to see if England will be progressing in the World Cup, the bottles of Pol Roger are on ice for the post-match after party: the Spectator's summer party, taking place this evening. Opening the doors of the Spectator to listeners of Coffee House Shots, James Heale, Freddy Gray, Noa Hoffman and Tim Shipman talk about their favourite memories, how to survive events like this – and which politicians handle their drink best. Plus, with Starmer on the way out, will Labour politicians be partying – or plotting? Produced by Patrick Gibbons.

Badenoch attacks Starmer over defence at PMQs

At today’s Prime Ministers’ Questions there was only one subject anyone was discussing. The Defence Investment Plan is supposed to be Keir Starmer’s big legacy so there is no surprise that is deeply suspect and lacking in fiscal credibility. Kemi Badenoch chose to ask all of her six questions on the subject. She began by asking about the gulf between the £15bn promised and the £28bn which John Healey wanted to then effortlessly narrowing her focus to whether Andy Burnham was signed up to a plan with a £4.7bn black hole in it. ‘Any Labour Prime Minister would stand behind this plan’, insisted Starmer. ‘Cheers Keir’, his predecessor must be thinking. It was not just Badenoch asking about defence. The Lib Dems and even the SNP both queued up too trying to have a go.

Defence Investment Plan – a looming problem for Burnham

The Defence Investment Plan is published today in Parliament. All eyes are on how much Dan Jarvis managed to secure (£15 billion), given the dramatic resignations of Al Cairns and John Healey over funding. Noa Hoffman speaks to James Heale and Tim Shipman about the plans, plus a scoop from The Spectator's John Connolly – its been revealed that DEI has taken precedence over number counting in the Treasury...

Defence Investment Plan – a looming problem for Burnham

The Burnham agenda: who will pay for it?

23 min listen

Andy Burnham has set out his big pitch to the country: a ten-year plan for devolution, reindustrialisation and a new ‘Number 10 of the North’. But, as he prepares to enter Downing Street, does he have anything like the ten years he wants to deliver it? And who will pay? Is Middle England about to be squeezed to fund Burnham’s vision? James Heale speaks to Tim Shipman.

The Burnham agenda: who will pay for it?

Does anyone want what Burnham is promising?

This morning Andy Burnham has set out his devolution agenda for government. At the People’s History Museum in Manchester, the new MP for Makerfield promised the ‘biggest change in our lifetimes to the way the country is run’, with mayors and local authorities empowered instead. A new ‘No. 10 North’ will be set up to oversee the transfer of powers and resources from a ‘broken’ Westminster. ‘The days of Whitehall fighting with devolution power into the regions and nations are over for good’, he said. ‘We will bring about the biggest rebalancing of power our country has seen.’ In a wide-ranging speech, Burnham argued that the current set-up is penalising not just the north but the whole of the UK.

Is Britain ungovernable?

14 min listen

We are on course for yet another prime minister – our seventh in just ten years. With statistics like that, and after watching the now-familiar pattern of leaders arriving with promises of hopeful change only to collapse into inertia and scandal, it is little wonder that many assume Britain has become ungovernable. But is that really true? Or have we simply had a uniquely bad crop of prime ministers, each sent packing because of their own mistakes? James Heale speaks to Tim Shipman and Luke Tryl. Produced (for the final time) by Megan McElroy. We all wish her luck at Politico!

Is Britain ungovernable?

Burnham wins Makerfield by a landslide

In the end, it was not even close. Andy Burnham has won the Makerfield by-election by a landslide, putting him firmly on course to be Britain's next Prime Minister. The Mayor of Greater Manchester managed to comfortably beat even the most optimistic of polls by winning an impressive 24,937 votes (54.8 per cent), more than 20 points higher than Reform's Robert Kenyon 15,696 (34.5 per cent). In a distant third came Restore Britain's Rebecca Shepherd who took 3,111 votes (6.8 per cent), enough to keep her deposit. In an impassioned address, Burnham suggested tonight 'could be the turning point' for the country and the 'final chance to change' for the Labour party. It was just six weeks ago, at the local elections, that Labour won just 24 per cent of the vote here in Makerfield.

Can Starmer survive the MoD exodus?

15 min listen

A second defence minister has resigned in protest at Keir Starmer’s failure to fund Britain’s armed forces. Al Carns, a former Royal Marines colonel, has followed John Healey out of the Ministry of Defence, warning that the government is letting down those in uniform – and taking aim at both the defence investment plan and Labour’s handling of Northern Ireland veterans. Starmer has now appointed Dan Jarvis as Defence Secretary, but the brief increasingly looks like a poisoned chalice. With the Strategic Defence Review still unfunded, ministers sent out to defend a plan they have not seen, and the Prime Minister heading to the G7 and Nato summit under pressure, has Starmer’s strongest claim to leadership – defence and foreign affairs – collapsed?

Can Starmer survive the MoD exodus?

Starmer loses another defence minister

To lose one defence minister might be regarded as misfortune; to lose two looks like carelessness. Al Carns has followed John Healey out of the door at the Ministry of Defence tonight, firing off a two-page letter that makes his disagreements with Keir Starmer clear. The only mystery about Carns’s resignation was why it didn’t come sooner. ‘It’s surprising he’s lasted this long,’ says one Labour aide. The only mystery of Carns’s resignation was why it didn’t come sooner Unlike Healey, Carns is neither a Treasury man nor a Labour loyalist.

How Reform is preparing for a snap election

As the Labour government continues to tear itself apart, Thursday 18 June has assumed a much greater significance than any normal by-election. If Andy Burnham, as expected, wins then many in his party will begin preparing for an imminent leadership contest. Talk of a snap election will inevitably do the rounds. At present, such talk is heard much more on the right than the left. Just as how Labour was impatient for an election during Rishi Sunak’s premiership, now many within Reform are keen for the 2027 election that Nigel Farage has long prophesised.  One factor in calling an early election is candidates: Labour obviously has more than 400 in place while Reform, officially, only have eight.

Defence Sec resigns: ‘Keir can’t keep Britain safe’

16 min listen

John Healey has resigned as Defence Secretary. In a blistering letter to the Prime Minister, he said: ‘You have been unable, and the Treasury has been unwilling, to commit the resources that the nation needs to defend the country at this time of rising threats.’ This comes after Keir Starmer failed even to secure the derisory sum of money he had demanded from the Treasury and the cabinet to modernise Britain’s forces following the recommendations of the Strategic Defence Review. The timing is equally devastating, as Starmer is heading to the G7 summit on Monday, where he will have to face Donald Trump. So what does this mean for Starmer’s premiership? Will more resignations follow – or will the missiles turn on the Treasury and Rachel Reeves’s reluctance to cough up?

Defence sec resigns: 'Keir can't keep Britain safe'

Inside the new Conservative Headquarters

The great and the good of the Conservative party turned out last night to mark the opening of the new building for Tory high command. For nearly two decades, the Conservatives have lacked a permanent home, ever since Smith Square – the site of Mrs Thatcher's three election victories –had to be sold off in 2007. Since then, they have rented offices in, first, Milbank Tower and currently, Matthew Parker Street. But now the Tories boast a new address: 1 Castle Lane in Victoria, just a ten minute stroll from their current base. The £14.3 million building was bought by the Conservative Foundation, thanks to a generous legacy from the late Lord Sainsbury, to ensure that no party leader is flogged to sell the base at the behest of bean-counters in future.

What will Keir Starmer’s legacy be?

19 min listen

With the Makerfield by-election next week, Keir Starmer is in the business of legacy-building. In a speech this morning to coincide with London Tech Week, the Prime Minister announced a clampdown on social media usage among under-18s, and in particular on the circulation of naked images on smartphones and other devices among under-18s. The intention is to shift emphasis on to tech companies such as Apple and Google, requiring them to prevent children from seeing sexually explicit images on their phones and other devices. But, in true Starmer fashion, no new law was announced – only a deadline for big tech to change its ways, or else he will do … something. This is being read throughout Westminster as an attempt at legacy-building.

What will Keir Starmer's legacy be?

The battle for Makerfield

9 min listen

James Heale is in Makerfield ahead of one of the most consequential by-elections of all time, where Andy Burnham is hoping to return to Westminster and stop Reform’s Robert Kenyon – the local plumber backed by Nigel Farage. On the ground, James hears from voters split between Labour and Reform, with some hoping Burnham can hold the line and others asking what he has really done for the area. He also sits down with Nigel Farage to discuss Reform’s chances, the party’s NHS policy, Rupert Lowe’s Restore Britain challenge, and why Farage thinks Burnham would be even worse than Starmer in No. 10.

Who won the Makerfield Question Time?

12 min listen

Last night, candidates from the five main parties in Makerfield came together for a special episode of Question Time. With four non-politicians taking on Andy Burnham, who came out on top? Tim Shipman, James Heale and Noa Hoffman digest the debate, assess Burnham’s performance, and discuss the main newsline – one that sent less than enormous shockwaves through Westminster: Burnham confirming that he would run in a Labour leadership contest.

Can Reform see off the threat from Restore?

Nigel Farage has always prided himself on being able to see off any threat from his right flank. But now a new force has emerged in the form of his ex-colleague Rupert Lowe. When the two Reform MPs fell out 15 months ago, friends shared memes of Farage’s past fallen rivals ascending to heaven. ‘Come and join us, Rupert!’ they exhorted. Instead, Lowe fought back, setting up his own party, Restore Britain. In the Makerfield by-election on 18 June, one poll puts Restore on 7 per cent– enough to stop Reform and hand the seat to Labour’s Andy Burnham. Restore’s strategy is simple: use Farage’s playbook against him. Like Farage, Lowe has put his faith in social media, building up a noisy following that can then be turned into a campaigning force.

Exclusive: Nigel Farage’s Desert Island Discs revealed

8 min listen

Canvassing in Makerfield continues at pace ahead of the by-election in two weeks time, so we dispatched Megan McElroy and James Heale to the north to report from the ground. They discuss each party’s ground game, why it looks like a Labour–Reform shoot-out, whether Restore will split the vote on the right and – most importantly – Nigel Farage’s Desert Island Discs. This comes after revelations in Lord Ashcroft’s book claimed that Farage has effectively been banned from appearing on the programme, a story that has dominated the papers over the last 48 hours, evidencing the continued interest in brand Farage. James spoke with Nigel earlier this morning and can bring the Reform leader’s favourite tracks, book and luxury item exclusively to Coffee House Shots listeners.

Exclusive: Nigel Farage's Desert Island Discs revealed