Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator and author of Why We Get the Wrong Politicians. She also presents Radio 4’s Week in Westminster.

The effective PM has some difficult choices to make

From our UK edition

Jeremy Hunt’s statement to the Commons underlined that he is now running the government. This wasn’t just evident from what he said, but from what was happening as he said it. The Chancellor spoke with the Prime Minister sitting behind him in silence, barely moving save to blink. Liz Truss had belatedly entered the chamber at the end of the Urgent Question that she had refused to answer herself, and then left half an hour later. But the statement also showed us quite how hard it is going to be for any caretaker leader, de facto prime minister or other figure to take the party back into a place where it is electorally appealing. Hunt, who until last week was campaigning for more money for the health service, is now about to make some unbelievably tough decisions.

Is Jeremy Hunt now in charge?

From our UK edition

After trying to reassure the markets by junking almost everything Liz Truss announced in her mini-Budget, Jeremy Hunt briefed Tory MPs about his premiership – sorry, plans as chancellor. The mood of those emerging from the briefing was probably the best Tory MPs have been in since the government U-turned on the 45p rate at the start of the Tory conference. 'He was superb and emollient,' says one MP, while another describes the briefing as 'really good'. Both of these MPs, by the way, have told me in the past few days that their party is in the worst position it's ever been. That's not to say it was a good mood: it's just that they're at least relieved that the new chancellor appears sensible and in control.

‘She’s just so bad at everything’: Tory MPs turn on Truss

From our UK edition

Liz Truss’s Downing Street press conference has made everything worse, as far as Tory MPs are concerned. As soon as it was over, a number of backbenchers who had supported Truss for leader were locked into a call with Thérèse Coffey, the PM’s closest friend in Parliament and the Deputy Prime Minister. Those on the call said it was ‘like a wake,’ with even Coffey sounding ‘broken.’ ‘You could see the loss in her eyes,’ said one. Coffey reiterated the points the Prime Minister had made in No. 10, before taking questions. The ‘wake’ line is one you hear a lot at the moment.

Will sacking Kwarteng be enough to save Truss’s premiership?

From our UK edition

Can sacking Kwasi Kwarteng really save Liz Truss’s premiership? In the past few minutes, the chancellor has had a meeting with the Prime Minister – and he has now left the government. Tory MPs have spent the past week doing a lot of writing. The first thing many of them have been writing is a letter to Sir Graham Brady calling for a vote of no confidence. Even though the rules currently don’t allow one for a year after the election of a new leader, those who’ve sent their missives expect that he will reach a point where he has to tell the Prime Minister there would be a vote if it weren’t for that rule – and that the time has come to do something.

Will Truss be gone by Christmas?

From our UK edition

14 min listen

After a day of speculation, the rumours that Liz Truss was about to U-turn on more areas of the mini-budget proved untrue. Conservative MPs had a tense evening in the 1922 Committee meeting last night – are there any good options left for the Prime Minister?Isabel Hardman speaks to Fraser Nelson and James Forsyth. Produced by Natasha Feroze.

Starmer and Truss both face problems of their own making

From our UK edition

Today's Prime Minister's Questions taught us two things. The first was that Keir Starmer has still got a long way to go before he is the one putting Liz Truss on the ropes. The second is that Truss has got a long way to go before she isn't putting herself on the ropes instead.  It wasn't a high energy session from either leader: Starmer fell back into his habit of enunciating every syllable in an exasperated tone, whether he was talking about the BUSINESS. SECRETARY. or MORTGAGE. PAYMENTS. In fairness, there is a fair bit to be exasperated about, but Starmer would probably adopt the same tone about his sock drawer. The overall effect was that Truss didn't really struggle as a result of his questions about her mini-budget and the impact it has had on the economy.

Kwasi Kwarteng’s easy ride

From our UK edition

Tory MPs were in an anxious mood as they returned to the Commons this afternoon after weeks of conference recess and government meltdown. Their first session in parliament was, appropriately enough, Treasury questions, where they had a chance to air some of their anxieties with the Chancellor and his team. It could have been a much worse session for Kwasi Kwarteng, given the way things have gone recently. But the number of MPs seeking reassurance won't have left him feeling very relaxed. Kwarteng told the Commons that his mini-Budget had been ‘really strong' Kwarteng told the Commons that his mini-Budget had been ‘really strong’ and that MPs constituents would have been pleased with many of the ‘strong measures that we have introduced.

Conor Burns sacked from government

From our UK edition

In the past few minutes, Conor Burns has been told to leave the government after a complaint of 'serious misconduct' was made against him. Downing Street has released a statement saying:  Following a complaint of serious misconduct, the Prime Minister has asked Conor Burns MP to leave the government with immediate effect. The Prime Minister took direct action on being informed of this allegation and is clear that all ministers should maintain the high standards of behaviour – as the public rightly expects. No. 10’s press release is keen to stress that the Prime Minister took immediate action Burns was moved sideways by Liz Truss in the recent reshuffle, from Northern Ireland to the same Minister of State position in the International Trade department.

Are Truss and Macron now ‘bons amis’?

From our UK edition

13 min listen

Liz Truss attended the European Political Community summit in Prague, where her frosty relations with Macron came to a head. Rather than 'frenemies', there were signs of thawing relations between the two. After years of diplomatic tensions over Brexit, immigration and energy, can the two leaders kiss and make up?Katy Balls speaks to Isabel Hardman and James Forsyth.Produced by Max Jeffery and Natasha Feroze.

Is Truss back on track?

From our UK edition

13 min listen

Liz Truss has today delivered her speech to the Conservative Party Conference where she set out the vision for her government. It was arguably the best moment of a difficult week for the party. Has she succeeded in calming Tory nerves? Who are the 'anti-growth coalition' that she is taking on? Isabel Hardman speaks to James Forsyth and Katy Balls. Produced by Max Jeffery.

Truss’s workmanlike conference speech

From our UK edition

Liz Truss’s speech at Conservative party conference was workmanlike; she performed the task she’d set out to do. It was helped by a brief protest in the middle by Greenpeace, which allowed the Prime Minister to drive home her point about an ‘anti-growth coalition’ to a hall that was united in willing her on and booing the protestors. The Prime Minister is not the most rousing public speaker. Indeed, the standing ovation at the end of the address felt a little uncertain, almost as though the audience was wondering if this was the start of a more energising peroration, not the payoff. She looked awkwardly at the autocue throughout, almost as though she didn’t trust the way it moved.

Iain Duncan Smith joins the benefits rebels

From our UK edition

Iain Duncan Smith is the latest senior Tory to speak out against cutting benefits by not uprating them in line with inflation. The former work and pensions secretary and party leader told a ConservativeHome fringe on Universal Credit this morning that he thought it was a 'peculiar debate' to be having, adding:  Almost certainly there would have to be a vote [on changing the benefits calculations] because it's automatic. And therefore if you freeze it or change it, then that will be changing the system. My personal view is I don't see what will be gained by it. But I do see what will be gained by making sure that they have enough money through the winter. Because, as I say, that money will flow back into the economy at the very time that we need the economy to be growing.

Liz Truss walks into another row

From our UK edition

With a wearying inevitability, Liz Truss has gone from one row to another. One of her own cabinet ministers, Leader of the Commons Penny Mordaunt, has warned her against cutting benefits. She told Times Radio:  'I’ve always supported – whether it’s pensions, whether it’s our welfare system – keeping pace with inflation. It makes sense to do so. That’s what I voted for before.'  In the parties and bars in Birmingham last night, the 45p reversal hadn't really calmed Tory nerves This is the kind of cabinet indiscipline that you'd expect in the weakest and latter days of a premiership, not the first few weeks. Mordaunt joins a growing list of Tories who have broken cover to insist benefits must be uprated in line with inflation.

What does Michael Gove want?

From our UK edition

Tory conference has long been more stage-managed than other party meetings, but this year the official speeches from ministers have also been condensed into a very strange late afternoon slot lasting just two hours. The rest of the time is free for fringe meetings and plotting. Ministers and their aides have been told they have to keep their addresses to the hall announcement-lite, which makes those two hours feel largely pointless. Kwasi Kwarteng didn't announce very much at all, even though his two U-turns have dominated the day's agenda. This morning, the Chancellor dropped the plan to abolish the 45p rate of tax, and this evening it has emerged that he is also bringing forward his medium-term fiscal plan from 23 November – something ministers had been asked to hold the line on.

Are the Tories in the business of managing decline?

From our UK edition

Kwasi Kwarteng's speech to Tory conference was an attempt to get his party back behind him after his U-turn on the 45p rate. He acknowledged it a number of times in his address, opening by saying it had been a 'tough' day, but insisted that the government needed to keep going. The members in the hall laughed as he referred to 'a little turbulence' and insisted that 'we are listening'. After the U-turn, it was quite audacious to insist the government had an 'iron commitment' to anything After the U-turn, it was quite audacious to insist the government had an 'iron commitment' to anything, but his commitment today was to 'fiscal discipline' and the 'central and guiding mission' of the government to grow the economy.

74 Years of the NHS: Can its crisis be cured?

From our UK edition

30 min listen

As the NHS turns 74, the service has never been under so much strain. The pandemic has created record waiting lists of almost seven million in England alone. Every month, tens of thousands of accident and emergency patients are left to wait for more than 12 hours with ambulances queuing up outside. Other long-term challenges such as an ageing population are coming to a head.  On this podcast, Isabel Hardman, The Spectator’s, assistant editor and her guests take a look back at the history of the NHS to talk about what the service was founded for, and why it is in crisis now.

Why would Tory MPs trust Truss now?

From our UK edition

Most Tory MPs went to bed last night convinced that their party was heading for an almighty showdown over the 45p tax rate. In the bars and parties of the conference in Birmingham, both Conservatives who were loyal to Liz Truss and those who were less-than-loyal were confident of one thing: she wouldn't fold quickly.  'She's got one thing left which is her reputation as someone who doesn't turn,' one backbencher said to me. 'If she loses that then she loses that credit with the public, and my colleagues will stop trusting that they can go on the airwaves and defend what she's doing.' They are waking to a big surprise: as Katy Balls covers here, the Chancellor has U-turned on the 45p as an unnecessary distraction.

Is levelling up dead?

From our UK edition

Does Liz Truss really believe in levelling up? She doesn't talk about it that much, and it wasn't really a major feature of the 'fiscal event' recently (though given the way that's gone, this might not be a bad thing). This evening Levelling Up Minister Dehenna Davison insisted that it really was still a thing. She told a Tory 'fringe'* event that she didn't understand why people were questioning its longevity, saying:  Over the past few weeks, we've seen this emerging narrative that the government is dropping levelling up, isn't having it anywhere near as much of a priority, and I honestly have no idea where that has come from, because levelling up is very much at the heart of what this government is about.