Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator and author of Why We Get the Wrong Politicians. She also presents Radio 4’s Week in Westminster.

Three problems with Rishi Sunak’s reshuffle

Rishi Sunak’s reshuffle has confirmed a new set of government departments focused on science and business, and a new party chair. That's all well and good: the Prime Minister is very keen to make Britain a science superpower and wants to put the right people in the right jobs as he prepares for the next election. Civil servants are moving into new jobs, as are ministers. The new departments will use the existing government estate, but it isn't yet clear where they'll all be. But there are a number of potential problems with what's been announced today.Is this the right reorganisation of Whitehall?

Are the sharks circling around Sunak over Rwanda?

Rishi Sunak has been blessed with interventions from two out of the three former prime ministers who are serving in the Commons today. Only one will be welcome: Boris Johnson made an unusually helpful contribution from the backbenches this afternoon at Home Office Questions when he asked about the Rwanda deportation policy. He said: Isn’t it obvious from today’s exchanges that many of those who oppose the UK-Rwanda migration and economic development partnership have no idea about Rwanda, have probably never been there, and are wholly wrong to condescend and to disparage Rwanda in the way that they do. And above all they have not the ghost of an idea about how to solve the problem of cross-Channel gangs putting people at risk.

Ending the strikes won’t be enough to fix the NHS

The biggest round of NHS strikes is taking place this week, and there isn't much hope of a resolution. This is despite, as Kate Andrews explores, a widespread acceptance that the strikes are detrimental to patient safety. There is also widespread public sympathy for striking healthcare workers, which surely suggests that a deal should come sooner rather than later to stop the government losing out even more politically.  So what's going on? That's a question some Tory MPs are also asking, wondering why there isn't any prospect of a deal given the Royal College of Nursing in particular seems to be keen to stop striking. 'There's an appetite for a deal,' complains one backbencher. 'Not sure why that hasn't happened yet but assume it's the Treasury.

Is it too late for the Tories to turn the tide on sewage?

Have Conservative ministers lost the battle on sewage? Once again, Tory MPs have been engulfed by a tide of fury from campaigners and constituents who say they've 'voted in favour of dumping sewage' in rivers and the sea. This is not the first, or indeed the second, time they've been on the end of these accusations, and frustration is bubbling over in the party.I've been passed some WhatsApp exchanges in which backbenchers have been kicking up a stink about the way ministers and officials keep failing to roll the pitch on sewage ahead of key votes and debates. The latest row concerns a deferred division on 25 January on water regulations, which set a target for an 80 per cent reduction in phosphates in rivers by 2038, all of which sounds very technical.

Is it the end of the road for Dominic Raab?

Will Dominic Raab fall on his sword? That's the chatter in Westminster, though it doesn't seem particularly to be based on the Justice Secretary's attitude towards the inquiry into allegations he bullied civil servants. He remains determined to clear his name, and denies the claims made against him. But there is a growing belief among his colleagues that it would be better if Raab stood aside, at least temporarily, while the independent investigation takes place. Raab is clearly seen by the opposition as the next scalp in the endless storm over Tory behaviour An exhibit in favour of this argument was yesterday's Prime Minister's Questions, where what Rishi Sunak knew about Raab's alleged behaviour – and when he knew it – formed a large part of Keir Starmer's plan of attack.

Sunak and Starmer need to change the record at PMQs

Rishi Sunak was clearly not on a fasting day of his diet when he stood up at Prime Minister's Questions this afternoon. He seemed to have consumed all the Weetabix in SW1, with more energy behind his attacks on Keir Starmer than he's had for weeks. This didn't mean the session veered away from its standard theme of two men fighting over who is the weaker, like dads at a barbecue vying over their DIY failures while burning the chicken.  Each week's weak-off has the same lines. Sunak's are that Starmer sat next to Jeremy Corbyn for 'four long years, not challenging him' and that he can't stand up to his union bosses. Meanwhile Starmer regularly accuses Sunak of not standing up to his own predecessors and cabinet colleagues who are mired in sleaze and bullying allegations.

Why are the Tories dragging their feet over public sector pay?

Why haven't ministers sent their submissions to the independent pay review bodies for their sectors? That's the question being asked of Education Secretary Gillian Keegan and Health Secretary Steve Barclay, both of whose departments have missed their deadlines for submissions on next year's pay settlement.  Some hope that a more generous pay settlement for next year might make it harder for trade unions to continue striking Keegan was out and about on the airwaves dealing with the start of the teaching strikes this morning, and explained that the education department had 'halted' the submission on future pay.

Are Tory MPs resigned to defeat?

A telling moment in today’s urgent question on the IMF’s economic outlook came when Angela Eagle pointed out the dearth of Tories who’d turned up to hear the Treasury defend its performance. She said: Despite the minister’s bluster, the benches opposite are empty. They haven’t come in in large numbers to defend the government’s economic, er, results, have they? Eagle argued that this was because the IMF had offered a ‘devastating forecast’ which ‘laid bare the economic incompetence’. But there’s another reason why the government benches were so quiet. It’s that the Conservative party machinery simply isn’t working very well.

Will Jeremy Hunt relent and agree to lower taxes?

Jeremy Hunt is giving a speech that is part of the government's economic relaunch this morning. The Chancellor is going to argue that the 'declinism' narrative about Britain is wrong and that 'the UK is poised to play a leading role in Europe and across the world on the growth sectors which will define this century'. He is trying to switch from his own previously downbeat tone about things getting worse before they get better, in part as a response to the Trussite Tories who are highlighting Britain's anaemic growth.  The interesting thing about the Truss bunch is that while many Tory MPs dismiss them as 'deranged', they then add in the same breath 'but Liz did have a point about growth, funnily enough'.

Is No. 10 preparing to let Zahawi go?

12 min listen

Over the last few days, Downing Street has been quietly distancing itself from Nadhim Zahawi, though seems unwilling to do anything until the investigation into Zahawi's tax affairs finishes. Today, the Tory chairman's plight was made worse by comments from Jim Harra, chief executive of HMRC. Cindy Yu discusses with Katy Balls and Isabel Hardman. Produced by Cindy Yu.

Keir Starmer let Rishi Sunak off the hook at PMQs

Keir Starmer could have made Prime Minister's Questions much more uncomfortable for Rishi Sunak, given the state of the Tory party. The Labour leader decided to focus his first three questions on the murder of Zara Aleena and the Probation Service failings that allowed her death to happen.  Starmer listed the devastating findings of the Chief Inspector of Probation into the case, which included short staffing, excessive workload and systemic problems which meant such a murder could happen again. He linked this to the government's 'botched and then reversed privatisation after a decade of underinvestment'.

Keir Starmer: ‘We haven’t won – yet’

When Keir Starmer won the Labour leadership in 2020, following the party’s worst election defeat since 1935, many people shook him by the hand, said ‘good luck’ and then added darkly ‘you’re not going to do it in five years’. Just three years later, he has done ‘it’, to the extent that Labour is 20 points ahead in the polls. The insult the Tories levelled at him when he became opposition leader – that he was boring – now looks like an advantage when it is offset by Conservative psycho-drama. Starmer clearly thinks things are going his way. Actually, things aren’t going his way when we meet, because his train is delayed. He is trying to go to Slough to campaign, but all the trains out of Paddington are either running behind or cancelled.

Mental health care is the next big scandal brewing in the NHS

Beth Matthews saved lives with her brutally honest, often shockingly graphic, posts about surviving a suicide attempt. She was an extraordinary young woman, whose blogs and social media threads often reached other unwell people at the darkest moments in their lives. She met the police officer who had held her hand after her own suicide attempt, shared X-rays of her shattered pelvis and told her followers that suicide was not the answer. Yet that was how Beth died in March 2022. An inquest this week concluded that neglect by the Priory Hospital Cheadle Royal contributed to her suicide. Beth had ordered poison from Russia, which she had opened near staff, but had told them it was something else.

Sunak fined by police for a second time

In the past few minutes, Lancashire Police has confirmed that Rishi Sunak has received a fixed penalty notice for sitting in a moving car without wearing a seatbelt. The Prime Minister filmed a video while touring the north west on Thursday which showed he had taken his seatbelt off, and a statement from the constabulary this evening said: You will be aware that a video has been circulating on social media showing an individual failing to wear a seatbelt while a passenger in a moving car in Lancashire. After looking into this matter, we have today (Friday, January 20th) issued a 42-year-old man from London with a conditional offer of fixed penalty.

Are the Tories serious about levelling up?

How serious are the Conservatives about levelling up? Their MPs have reportedly been told not to use the phrase in their campaign literature, presumably on the basis that it is meaningless. Today, however, ministers are fanning out across the country to make a big fuss about the latest round of levelling up funding. The biggest problem with levelling up is that local government is not strong in many areas Rishi Sunak is in the north west promising to 'build a future of optimism and pride in people's lives and the places they call home'. It's all nice and good, but even the MPs who are getting funding today are struggling to feel a sense of optimism about the future of their seats.

Can Keir Starmer be trusted?

12 min listen

In today's Prime Minister's Questions, Rishi Sunak went heavy on accusations that Keir Starmer cannot be trusted, having flip-flopped on various policy positions throughout his time in politics – 'he is not just for the free movement of people; he also has the free movement of principles'. On the podcast, Katy Balls discusses with Fraser Nelson and Isabel Hardman whether that's such a bad thing. Produced by Cindy Yu.

PMQs: Sunak struggles on ambulance wait times

Today’s Prime Minister’s Questions saw Keir Starmer launch his strongest attack on Rishi Sunak so far. The topic was the same – the NHS – but the technique new. He opened by asking the Prime Minister to tell the Commons how long someone who called for an ambulance now would have to wait before it turned up. This was slightly blunted by him saying ‘it's three minutes past 12’, and a Tory heckler shouting ‘well done!’ to chuckles around the chamber. But then the Labour leader went on: 'If somebody phones 999 now because they have chest pains and fear it might be a heart attack, when would the Prime Minister expect an ambulance to arrive?’Sunak did not engage with the question, a tactic he stuck to throughout this uncomfortable session.

When will the Tories admit defeat on nurses pay?

Another day, another strike. Nurses are walking out today and tomorrow, with the Royal College of Nursing vowing to 'keep going' with industrial action until ministers compromise on pay demands. Ambulance workers will also announce further strike dates today.  Barclay and colleagues are acutely aware that they aren't winning in this war of attrition Strikes have become part of the wallpaper in Britain recently, but what is troubling for ministers is that the state of the health service more widely is causing more angst than health workers joining picket lines. Health and Social Care Secretary Steve Barclay is still engaging with them on the basis that their pay demands are 'unaffordable' and would require cuts elsewhere in the health service.

Patel skewers Braverman over Met sex abuse scandal

The Commons was wearily furious as it responded to the David Carrick case this morning. Carrick yesterday admitted 49 sexual offences across more than two decades as a Metropolitan Police officer. The fury of MPs didn’t stop at the police. There was a great deal of frustration with ministers for being too slow to do what they could to stop offenders continuing to work as police officers after complains had been made.  This frustration didn’t just come from shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper, but from Tory backbenchers too. The most notable critic on Suella Braverman’s own side was Priti Patel. The former home secretary was customarily polite, but complained that there were already options for the Home Office to act on. She said: The recommendations are already there.

Alister Jack defends blocking the SNP’s gender bill

It would have been news if the Commons debate about the Scottish Gender Recognition Bill hadn't turned ugly quickly. The questions and answers following Scottish Secretary Alister Jack's statement about using Section 35 of the Scotland Act to stop the progress of that legislation were deeply uncomfortable. Jack insisted that he was merely focusing on the constitutional issues, something Labour's Ian Murray looked grateful to be able to do, too, given the splits within his own party on this matter.