Alex Massie

Alex Massie

Tory Authoritarians

From our UK edition

Here's a surprise: a rather good speech on civil liberties and the government's (English) DNA database from Chris Grayling. Later in the debate, however, David Davies, Tory MP for Monmouth and a man who really should not be confused with David Davis MP, made this contribution: "Most of the Bill's provisions ultimately come down to a simple argument about the price of civil liberties as against the price of security. While travelling into London on the tube this morning, I was reading the dreadful stories of what is going on in Haiti. I suppose that at present the people in that country have the ultimate in civil liberties, in that they can go out and do and say what they want and steal what they want, but is anyone more secure for it? No, they are not.

Bill McLaren 1923-2010

From our UK edition

He'd been ill for some time, so the news that Bill McLaren, the "Voice of Rugby" has died is sad but neither surprising nor shocking. For nearly half a century, from his debut in 1953 until 2002, his voice dominated the game. No other rugby commentator came close. Nor, in this multi-channel age, will any again. The voice - a mild Hawick burr - was only part of what made McLaren so distinctive. McLaren's commentary combined great colour with precision. He gave viewers a sense of the drama of the game and relished the physical confrontation that lies at the heart of rugby and without which it is, if not nothing, then a much-reduced game. He was a trusted, kindly guide who taught many of us much of what we know about the game. Above all, there was a rare warmth about Bill's commentary.

More Booze-Related Fraud

From our UK edition

To return to a subject we considered the other day, it seems there's no end to the mendacity ministers are prepared to endorse if it furthers their efforts to tell everyone how to lead their lives. The latest ploy is to argue that the fact that the average Scot consumes 12.2 litres of pure alcohl every year demonstrates that politicians should be allowed to fix alcohol prices. This figure amounts, we are told, to 46 bottles of vodka a year. Well that doesn't sound all that much, does it? That's a single bottle a week with a dry spell lasting from New Years Day to St Valentines Day. Alternatively, it equates to 11 pints of beer a week. That is, one a day with an extra couple on Fridays and Saturdays. The average Scot, then, can hardly be said to be on the lash all the time.

Massachusetts Meltdown

From our UK edition

Writing about stuff before it has even had a chance to become news has been a significant media trend this past decade. The internet accelerates this. So, even though voting in the election to fill Ted Kennedy's Senate seat in Massachusetts hasn't even started yet, it's important to speculate on the outcome of the contest and its likely consequences. These days even Breaking News is Old News... Martha Coakley, the hapless Democratic candidate, seems set to lose one of the safest Democratic seats in the country to a Republican challenger no-one had even heard of a couple of months ago. This is ineptitude on such an impressive scale that you could be forgiven for thinking Gordon Brown must be running her campaign. Nate Silver gives Coakley just a 33% chance of winning.

Will Chilcot Ever Reveal a New Fact?

From our UK edition

As far as I can tell the Chilcot Inquiry has yet to unearth anything that hasn;t been public knowledge for years. Today it's Jonathan Powell's turn to confirm Stuff We Already Knew. As Paul Waugh reports: But perhaps more interesting is the detail he gave of the trip to Downing Street by Dick Cheney a month before in March 2002. Little has so far been revealed about this crunch meeting, which may well have coloured Blair's actions from then on. The Veep, the most senior hawk in the White House at the time, dropped into Number 10 ahead of a tour of Middle East allies on which he wanted to test opinion of the impact of a war on Iraq. At the meeting - and this is the first detail of its contents from Powell - Blair set out some of the "unintended consequences" of military action.

The Problem With Contested Elections…

From our UK edition

More on the special election in Massachusetts in due course. But Dan Drezner makes a good case for the ghastliness of politics: For those readers who have never had the privilege of living in a battleground state, let me explain what the experience is like.  Every other television commercial is about the campaign.  Day after day, the race dominates the front page of the newspaper.  Your mailbox is stuffed with fliers for or against one of the candidates.  Your friends and neighbors talk about the campaign -- and who you support can affect your friendships.  You can't escape the race.  All of this would be tolerable if it were not for two things.  First, the phone calls.

Today Wales! Tomorrow Scotland?

From our UK edition

Iain Dale says he has absolutely no idea why the Scottish Tories have failed to make as much headway as their Welsh counterparts. A new opinion poll puts the Conservatives on 32% on Wales, only 3% behind Labour, and a massive 11% up on the last general election. However, in Scotland, the Conservative ratings are only marginally up on 2005, Why is this? Why are Welsh Conservatives so much more successful than their counterparts north of Hadrian's Wall? We've ridden these marches here before, but another trip can't do any harm. The first and most obvious answer is that the SNP is a much stronger beast than Plaid Cymri for reasons that have plenty to do with the last 700 hundred years of history and the fabric of the Union since its foundation.

The Essence of Palinism

From our UK edition

Commenting on Sarah Palin here, regular correspondent Snowman does us all a favour by distilling Palinism to its essence: Tell me, if you will, what is it that irks you that much? If she is that of a comedian, why does she make you madder than the dogs, ha? You reckon the great unwashed of America have to told by the likes of you what to think of her? Why? Do you possess the capacity to tell us how to rate politicians, how to think, how to live our lives? Isn’t ‘hopeandchange’ equally glib? Glibness happens to be the trademark of any political rhetoric, it’s the art of talking a lot without saying very much of any substance.

Clausewitz on Cricket III

From our UK edition

An occasional series in which the great theorist's ideas are considered in terms of how they may be applied to cricket. Today: defence. Granted, Clausewitz takes the view that the defensive side in war generally finds itself in a stronger position than is customarily the case on the cricket field. Nonetheless, his observations on Types of Resistance are germane: Defence is thus composed of two distinct parts, waiting and acting. By linking the former to a definite object that precedes action, we have been able to merge the two into one whole.

A Pizza Strategy for Labour?

From our UK edition

Hopi Sen argues that Gordon Brown needs to run a Harry Truman-like campaign. That's probably right. But Labour's problem is that Brown is in a position that's more like the Truman of 1951 than the surprisingly victorious Truman of 1948. The economy has done to Gordon waht the Korean War did to the great haberdasher and, like Truman, Brown's approval ratings have plummeted. (At one point Truman's slumped to 22%). Eventually, of course, defeat in the New Hampshire primary helped persuade Truman not to run at all and it was Adlai Stevenson who was defeated by Eisenhower. It's too late - surely! - for Labour to persuade Brown to step aside. Last week's botched coup attempt was the final chance. So what can Labour do?

Things Coud Only Have Begun Better…

From our UK edition

Strauss: caught Amla, bowled Steyn 0 Photo:Duif du Toit/Gallo Images/Getty Images. Andrew Strauss might wish that he'd lost the toss at the Wanderers this morning since, as it turned out and despite a stripey pitch, South Africa would also have batted first. Strauss may have been dismissed by the first ball of the test but he's in pretty good company: the first man to succumb to the opening ball of a test match was Archie MacLaren, done in by Arthur Coningham at Melbourne in 1894. Despite being skittled for just 75, England won the match by 94 runs... Strauss's dismissal today was the 28th time that a batsman has succumbed to the first ball of the match.

When Glenn Met Sarah

From our UK edition

An hour of Glenn Beck interviewing Sarah Palin! Unwatchable and mesmerising in equal measure. Choose your own lowlights... Here's part one: Part two is, if anything, even scarier more hilarious:   See the rest here. This is a cult not a political party.

Survive the World Cup in Style…

From our UK edition

Because everything is a market opportunity, here's a perfect gift for any friend going to the World Cup this summer. Adding team colours is a particularly nice touch. Apparently this is a genuine product and at least 35 vests were sold the first day they became available. So rush now before they sell-out... Disclaimer: I actually think the World Cup will probably go off pretty well and that fears of crime, while understandable, are likely to be exagerrated somewhat.

Paging Mr Soros: I’d like my cheque now, please.

From our UK edition

I don't doubt that there would be costs were we to have more sensible (and philosophically agreeable) drug laws but one thing we might avoid is what's happening here right now: in the last couple of weeks seven heroin users have been killed by anthrax-tainted smack. But I don't think Melanie need really worry too much. The Conservatives, if they win the election, are highly unlikely liberalise our drug laws. On the contrary they're likely to double-down on a series of failed and failing policies whose principle merit is that they allow politicians to seem tough. Their "core" commitment to individual responsibility doesn't extend to letting people make their own decisions on what drugs they wish to take.

What’s the Real Cost of Booze?

From our UK edition

A reader asks if I might write something about the "ridiculous assertion that alcohol abuse costs every Scot £900 a year". Happy to do so! We all know that if a tobacco company sponsors research no-one in the press will ever call any report produced by that research "independent". Everybody knows that it's only government-commissioned research that counts as "independent". And lo, today's example of this is a report (original PDF linked to here) , paid for by the Scottish government, from "independent experts" at York University claiming that the social and financial costs of booze amount to £900 a year for every Scottish man, woman and child in the country.

Wodehouse on Islam4UK

From our UK edition

Not the Black Shorts but Anjem Choudary and the Black Tunics. As always, Wodehouse is our trusty guide: The trouble with you, Spode, is that just because you have succeeded in inducing a handful of half-wits to disfigure the London scene by going about in black shorts, you think you're someone. You hear them shouting "Heil, Spode!" and you imagine it is the Voice of the People. That is where you make your bloomer. What the Voice of the People is saying is: "Look at that frightful ass Spode swanking about in footer bags! Did you ever in your puff see such a perfect perisher?" The other important thing to remember is that I rather think the voices of the vast, vast majority of British muslims are bundled up with the Voice of the People here.

Mike Bloomberg Seems to be Inspiring Tory Health Policy. Which is a Problem.

From our UK edition

If there's one thing Team* Spectator agrees upon it is, I think, that Tory health policy is utterly inadequate and desperately confused. One especially problematic promise, however, is the notion that what we need is a Department of Public Health. How will this work? Well, the inspiration would seem to be Mayor Mike Bloomberg in New York City. This is not Good News: First New York City required restaurants to cut out trans fat. Then it made restaurant chains post calorie counts on their menus. Now it wants to protect people from another health scourge: salt. On Monday, the Bloomberg administration plans to unveil a broad new health initiative aimed at encouraging food manufacturers and restaurant chains across the country to curtail the amount of salt in their products.

Terrorism? No Big Deal. Keep Calm & Carry On

From our UK edition

I'd like to think that if the Christmas Day underwear-bomber had been en route to London rather than Detroit then our response to the attempted attack would have been a little more phlegmatic than the Cousins' but I'm not wholly convinced that would have been the case. So Fareed Zakaria's excellent column in today's WaPo applies to this country too. The whole thing is well worth reading* but Zakaria's intro and conclusion are especially bang-on: In responding to the attempted bombing of an airliner on Christmas Day, Senator Dianne Feinstein voiced the feelings of many when she said that to prevent such situations, "I'd rather overreact than underreact." This appears to be the consensus view in Washington, but it is quite wrong. The purpose of terrorism is to provoke an overreaction.

The Fox News Effect

From our UK edition

According to James Carville there'd be 67 Democratic Senators if it weren't for those ghastly chaps at Fox News. As with everything Carville says this must be taken with a pinch of salt. Nevetheless one need not look too hard to discover evidence of the impact Fox has had on American journalism* in precincts far from and not naturally disposed to take their orders from Roger Ailes' command-bunker. Why, the very same edition of the New York Times contains an excellent example of how Fox's "framing" of an issue has leached into the mainstream. In the paper's Week in Review section Helene Cooper "examines" the burning issue of whether Barack Obama is a wimp or a warrior... The answer is, of course, that like all Democrats Obama is a wimp.

Peter King Watch | 11 January 2010

From our UK edition

British readers probably don't need any reminding that Congressman Peter King (R-NY) spent decades raising money for the IRA and championing their cause at every available opportunity. However my experience is that plenty of Americans remain all too unaware of his terrorism-supporting record. Happily the nice folk at the Daily Beast asked if I'd compile a quick refresher course, detailing some of King's more egregious soft-on-terrorism moments. So here it is. It's also worth recalling that though King "broke" with the IRA in 2005 (so long ago!) and called for their disbandment he was still happy to shill for the Republican movement in the aftermath of the murder of Robert McCartney in a Belfast pub.